4 ms·
On P9 at Bell labs, everything could be connected and uniform. In the real world with corporate firewalls, HTTPS is very nearly the only reliable option for co
by aidenn0 11y ago
On P9 at Bell labs, everything could be connected and uniform. In the real world with corporate firewalls, HTTPS is very nearly the only reliable option for connecting to other computers.
On top of that, the fact that most workstations in this world do not have public IP addresses, and p2p becomes really a non-starter.
- zymhan 11y agoFirst of all, you can just tunnel whatever storage protocol over HTTPS if needed. The point of the quote is that we could be using Operating Systems that abstract away the various kinds of storage available so that you can use whatever combination of options work for you. It's like if everyone was using Linux and paid for plans from for example a cloud storage provider, but was able to reliably and automatically mount their storage like any other network share. With open technology and widespread fast internet, it's really not that hard to accomplish. We've already got the former. Now we just need a lot more of the latter.
- chatmasta 11y agoThis seemingly destructive segmentation of the Internet is precisely what will lead to its successor: a collection of "overlay networks" built on top of the existing IP stack. We're already seeing it in many ways, with Tor and VPNs as two commonly used examples. But overlay networks are not just advantageous for packet transport. They can represent any decentralized network. BitCoin is an overlay network, in that it's literally a payment network, is a payment network, built on top of existing IP infrastructure. We are going to see more and more of these "overlays" as the Internet "re-decentralizes". Sure, what we know as "the Internet" is becoming increasingly centralized, and people are right to be concerned. But there is nothing to fear, so long as we can build more abstractions on top of the Internet as we know it. Let Amazon, Google, and the big "clouds" centralize as much of the Internet as they want. They are only digging their own grave, because the next revolution, the "Internet 2.0" will be as decentralized as its predecessor. Only instead of being built on the "dumb pipes" of copper and fiber, it will be built on the "dumb pipes" of the existing, increasingly centralized, Internet. The more the Internet infrastructure consolidates itself, the more it provides an opportunity to re-decentralize on top of it.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 11y agoWhat you say made me think of hamachi, a nice vpn overlay network for windows (at first) from the late 90s, and guess what happened to it? > For paid subscribers Hamachi runs in the background on idle computers. The feature was previously available to all users, but became restricted to paid subscribers only [0] More short sighted business practices as usual. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LogMeIn_Hamachi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LogMeIn_Hamachi
- chatmasta 11y agoYou should check out the ipop project [0], the technology behind socialvpn and groupvpn. They have an active and extensive github. [1] The problem with technology like Hamachi, and even IPOP, is that the nature of NAT traversal means that for any given p2p network, "supernodes" will always be required. IPOP uses STUN/TURN (the same technology as WebRTC) for NAT-traversal. According to Google usage stats (can't find the URL right now), about 10% of p2p connetions over STUN/TURN require relaying all packets over the TURN server. So that means for every ten nodes, at least one will need a supernode to connect to the others. At first glance, the requirement of "supernodes" seems to impede the proliferation of true p2p networks, because it introduces a point of failure into the system controlled by one entity but relied upon by many. The problem is that "supernodes" cost money, and somebody needs to pay for them. So you end up with companies like LogMeIn, happy to provide a "p2p" solution, as long as you pay them to maintain the requisite supernodes. However, there is no requirement that one centralized entity supply the "supernodes" in a network. It's 2016, we have "the cloud," and anyone can launch a "supernode," aka a cloud server with a public IP that can assist in NAT traversal. I hope we will see more business models based around a combination of "p2p" and "federated" network architectures, where they are federated in the sense that a group of "super-peers" provides the "supernodes" required for functional NAT traversal on the rest of the strictly p2p network. [0] http://ipop-project.org/ http://ipop-project.org/ [1] https://github.com/ipop-project https://github.com/ipop-project (Shameless plug: You should also check out my senior thesis, TorCoin: http://dedis.cs.yale.edu/dissent/papers/hotpets14-torpath-abs http://dedis.cs.yale.edu/dissent/papers/hotpets14-torpath-ab... -- I've been thinking about this a lot since then, but that was my first real exploration of the ideas I'm trying to express here.)