3 ms·
That's fine, but protecting you from other people doing ridiculous things isn't really the fault of modern C++ as it is possibly a feature of a GC language. I
by CyberDildonics 11y ago
That's fine, but protecting you from other people doing ridiculous things isn't really the fault of modern C++ as it is possibly a feature of a GC language. I think there is utility in not letting people out of a sandbox if they can't handle it, but I also think the fact that C++11 has a stark path that should be used is different than the high wire act of C and older C++.
- pjmlp 11y agoIt is a fault of C++, because there are other systems programming languages also without GC, that aren't as memory corruption friendly as C and C++. They achieve that by either being older than C, or never being copy-paste compatible with it. This is the biggest drawback of C++, even modern C++. C compatibility was a good way to achieve adoption, but also what hinders the language in terms of safety. It doesn't matter how many safety features the language has, you always have a few cowboys coders doing "C with C++ compiler" style. In the majority of typical enterprises where code review and static analyzers are foreign words, you get into horrible code bases. I like the language a lot, it is the language I liked most to use after Turbo Pascal, used to teach it to first year students and have a few jobs on my CV where I really enjoyed using it. Nowadays I rather use it in personal projects as infrastructure language alongside other ones where I can easily follow modern practices, rather than on the job in codebases where developers come and go.
- pcwalton 11y agoThose ridiculous things are things we find everyone does again and again, even in modern C++. C++11 doesn't really add anything in the safety department over smart pointer code that you could write in earlier versions of C++.
- pjmlp 11y agoQuite true, the only thing that C++11 does is make it part of the standard library and offer a few language features that make it more pleasant to the eye. I was already using smart pointers with COM in 1998, but of course most of the third party libraries we depended on, did not.