4 ms·
I'd be curious to see gravitational energy storage built individually into each wind turbine. If you think about it you already have a lot of height from the to
by mrfusion 11y ago
I'd be curious to see gravitational energy storage built individually into each wind turbine. If you think about it you already have a lot of height from the tower.
Have the turbines directly lift a weight. And then lower the weight as needed to generate electricity.
- maxerickson 11y agoYou need incredible amounts of mass to store the amount of power a turbine outputs using the small change in height available with a turbine. This system doesn't need to fit that mass into a small structure and has a much longer working height.
- mrfusion 11y agoWhat if you drill a hole 500 meters down and raise and lower the weight through that?
- maxerickson 11y agoYou end up with an incredible amount of mass divided by 4 or 5, which most likely works out to an incredible amount of mass. In one of the patents, they work out an example system that can handle 30 megawatts, which might be the output of 10 or 15 turbines. The system absorbing the 30 megawatts for 30 minutes has a working mass of 1200 tons (conveniently, they use a working height of ~600 meters). So all you need is a system capable of lifting 100 tons a distance of 600 meters (to store 1/2 hour of output). Which is probably something we are capable of building (there are cranes that lift much more significant distances), but it probably isn't something that would be economical.
- onetimePete 11y agoWhat if the mass is water and you transport it back up with the capillary effect? Over a stairway?
- pjc50 11y agoThere's an old paper by Salter on the possibility of doing this through hydraulic pressure, having the turbine drive a pump, the weight being a piston within the turbine tower, and the output of the system being a hydraulic generator. This was back before modern developments in inverters meant that turbines had to have either a gearbox or a hydraulic torque conversion system like a car's automatic gearbox. http://www.artemisip.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/1984-Salter-Hydraulics-for-Wind-3_0.pdf http://www.artemisip.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/1984-Sal... (SH Salter, M Rea, proceedings of European Wind Energy conference 1984)
- thinkcontext 11y agoYou are referring to a hydraulic accumulator[0], such systems were built in the 19th century. There is a modern effort to use the technology in a massively scaled up fashion by Heindl Energy[1]. Their concept uses pumped water to raise a rock weight 100 meters or more in diameter. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydraulic_accumulator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydraulic_accumulator [1] http://www.heindl-energy.com/hydraulic-rock-storage/overview.html http://www.heindl-energy.com/hydraulic-rock-storage/overview...
- strommen 11y agoA typical wind turbine is 80m high and and generates 1.5MW [1]. Gravitational storage in Joules is (mass in kg) * (height in m) * 9.8 (gravity). Divide by 3.6 million to convert to kWh. Suppose we raise a 30-ton weight (i.e. a big shipping container filled to capacity with rocks) all the way up that 80m turbine. We've stored 30,000 * 80 * 9.8 / 3600000 = 6.5 kWh of energy. That's 16 seconds worth of energy from the turbine spinning at full speed. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine#Design_and_construction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine#Design_and_constr...
- usrusr 11y agoImpressive way to put the power generation capability into perspective. Also makes me wonder how a spring (instead of or in addition to those 30 tons) would scale to turbine tower size. Just don't think of the destruction when something breaks!
- beamatronic 11y agoCatastrophic energy release doesn't care if you're a spring, a flywheel, a lithium battery, or a chemical bomb - in fact all those things start to look pretty similar at high enough energy levels.
- seanp2k2 11y agoBut you must admit that an 80m (~262ft or ~24 stories) wind turbine blasting off like a giant pogo stick into the sky is by far the most comical. Maybe gravitational doesn't make sense, but compressed air might. Big compressor directly driven by the turbine (so as not to waste energy converting to electricity to turn an electric compressor motor) being used to compress normal air into large tanks inside the wind turbine tower which can later be used to spin another turbine-based generator using the same air. Not a physics major, but this seems feasible. Not sure of the potential energy storage, but I feel like the direct conversion of rotational energy to spin the pump has to be much more efficient than converting it to electricity first, then using that [many miles away] to compress air or drive a train up a mountain.
- imaginenore 11y agoIt would make a lot more sense to fill that space with flywheels. Or better yet, good old Li-ion batteries.
- Someone 11y agoThere also is this idea: https://www.ecn.nl/news/item/floating-train-at-2000-kmh-set-to-store-10-of-dutch-electricity/ https://www.ecn.nl/news/item/floating-train-at-2000-kmh-set-.... It would store 20 GWh in a maglev train riding at 2000 km/hour on a 15 km circular track. More or less an enormous flywheel.