5 ms·
If we were to work out what makes a journal so prestigious, what are the objective measures that should be considered?
by chris_wot 11y ago
If we were to work out what makes a journal so prestigious, what are the objective measures that should be considered?
- kowdermeister 11y ago100 years of track record publishing the least amount of junk.
- chris_wot 11y agoWorst metric evar.
- parenthephobia 11y agoMainly it's a chicken and egg situation. A journal is prestigious because the papers it publishes have an allusion of quality, because they are published by a prestigious journal. A prestigious journal publishes high-quality papers because it can attract high-quality authors and reviewers, because it is a prestigious journal. A journal is prestigious because researchers choose to (try to) be published in it, because their articles will be widely read by other researchers, because it is a prestigious journal. If you were trying to bootstrap a new journal, you'd have a tough time; unless you didn't care about its quality. The bare minimum would be a staff who have the time and skill to sift through obviously junk papers and then know which reviewers to use for the legitimate papers. Your best bet would probably be to assemble a staff of well-regarded researchers in whatever field(s) you wanted the journal to cover.
- tomp 11y ago> If you were trying to bootstrap a new journal, you'd have a tough time; unless you didn't care about its quality. You could (should?) start by going through freely published (open access) papers, collecting the most quality ones, then publishing them in your journal. That's most of the value of journals, as well - informing the subscribers of noteworthy research.
- parenthephobia 11y agoBut how do I do that? I can interpret a paper and apply it to my problems, but I'm not qualified to tell if it's a good paper[1]. In my field -- computing -- research papers are often written in a language that only just makes sense to me. I'm sure it'd be easier if I was a computer scientist that regularly published, but that's why I suggest you'd need a team of actual scientists who are used to reading, writing, and reviewing papers. As Kernighan almost wrote: Reviewing the paper is twice as hard as reading the paper in the first place. Therefore, if you have to be as clever as possible to read the paper, you are, by definition, not smart enough to review it. [1] Although I can tell whether the code works, the quality of a paper is also about how well-written it is, whether the arguments are valid and supported by the data, and whether it provides something future research can be built on. A terrible paper that happens to contain code that works is useful for me, not so much for science in general.
- dalke 11y agoI believe tomp's suggestion is that you can bootstrap as an overlay journal (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overlay_journal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overlay_journal ) to build up that expertise. You don't need to have experienced people from the start, because they can learn while doing. At the start, no one is going to pay attention to the journal. Then as it gets known for being a good curator, people will start requesting to be reviewed for inclusion. Poof you've got a journal. You might even start with only yourself. And in 5 years if you want to distance yourself from your earlier, naïve efforts, then simply announce a name change. Here's the ugly truth - it's hard to tell if most papers are "good", and there are many types of "good".
- chris_wot 11y agoDistancing yourself from early failures is never a good strategy. Too often we flee from our past failures. For me, I don't shy from them but admit they occurred, and that I have learned from them since.
- 11y ago