6 ms·
Has anyone got a breakdown of actual costs incurred by Elsevier? Note I don't include marketing their journals, I mean a breakdown labour costs, rent for buildi
by chris_wot 11y ago
Has anyone got a breakdown of actual costs incurred by Elsevier? Note I don't include marketing their journals, I mean a breakdown labour costs, rent for buildings (where the building are located) and other production costs.
I'd like to know their revenue, and a full price list per journal they publish.
I very much believe that if we looked at what they make in profits, we'll see that they can't justify how much they charge. I, for one, have no sympathy for them.
- youngbullind 11y agoCompletely without source and no breakdown, but I read recently that their margins are in the 20-30% range.
- Blahah 11y agoIn 2014 Elsevier's profit margin was 34% http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/93138f3e-87d6-11e5-90de-f44762bf9896.html http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/93138f3e-87d6-11e5-90de-f44762bf98...
- philjohn 11y agoWonder what the margin on their e-journals are like, vs printed journals. They get the research papers for free, the editors don't get paid ... it's such a scam, and always has been.
- tomp 11y agoWell, they do need to employ a highly paid CEO... /s
- chinathrow 11y agoYeah and with that setup, 37% seams somehow very low. I wonder what accounting stunts they pull...
- Blahah 11y agoI've done a lot of work on tools that interface with the academic publishing infrastructure. Elsevier not only make a huge profit margin, but they operate at a staggering level of inefficiency. They are haemorrhaging money and producing precisely nothing of value, and still making profit for their investors hand over fist. Quite incredible.
- chris_wot 11y agoCan you give examples of the inefficiencies you discovered?
- secfirstmd 11y agoHmmm...it seems like the space is ready to be disrupted. How might that look? I mean purely publishing isnt just ideal as it lacks the so-called quality control and prestige of established publications. What might be a middle ground for disrupting this crappy monopoly on the world's knowledge?
- zazen 11y agoAcademics in some fields have been starting independent open-access journals, sometimes with the explicit goal of replacing Elsevier journals in particular. https://gowers.wordpress.com/2013/01/28/the-elsevier-boycott-one-year-on/ https://gowers.wordpress.com/2013/01/28/the-elsevier-boycott...
- Blahah 11y agoPersonally, I think it has at least these important aspects: - built on a foundation of open source software - new ways of presenting and consuming should be encouraged and easily discoverable - completely outside the influence of the current publishing industry There's a community of us working on this stuff. We hang out on gitter (https://gitter.im/codeforscience/community https://gitter.im/codeforscience/community).
- VMG 11y agoAs long as you have government power (public funding) in academia, you'll have rent-seeking.
- VMG 11y agoWikipedia: > In 2015, Elsevier reported a profit margin of approximately 37% on revenues of £2.070 billion. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elsevier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elsevier
- awendt 11y agoI'm wondering if they'd make more money with very cheap subscriptions (a.k.a. "long tail") and no legal department.
- return0 11y agoThey charge $5000 if you want to make your article public access (i.e. they won't put it behind paywall). So that's a ballpark value of how much it costs +their profits. Whatever they may claim their costs are, the money does not add meaningful contribution. The meaningful contribution (writing and reviewing) is done by scientists themselves, almost 100% independently of elsevier. Elsevier employs some senior editors who decide which reviewer gets to review which paper, and that's about their entire contribution to scientific process. The rest is their website costs, PR and fluff which is not relevant to the science itself.
- akjj 11y agoI once looked into their financial statements and came to the conclusion that per article published, they had about $2500 in costs and $5000 in revenue, so 50% profit margins. If you look at the price of comparable PLoS journals (i.e. not PLoS ONE), the publication costs are also about $2500, so I think this is in the right ballpark.