7 ms·
What’s Inside a Black Hole?
- kinai 11y agoThere is a misconception: Light cannot escape a black hole for gravitational reason (not to mention that gravity does not exist, it is a not a force, read up General Relativity). The real reason is that the space-time curvature does simply not provide a way for the light to go back. Same reason you can't go to the end of the universe if the universe would be a sphere. Also if someone likes to talk about black holes it is good to remind people that it is not a hole...as the article mentions its a region, to be more precise it is a region in space-time that is cut off from ours. The whole issue is not just spacial but also temporal, that is usually the point when your brain gives up understanding the whole problem. A good description would be: a black hole is the collection of events that do happen outside our space-time/universe. This also explains some of the paradoxes near the event horizon.
- spriggan3 11y agoSo basically it's impossible to know what is "inside" a black hole because it's not part of this universe ? But aren't black hole formed by stars that collapsed under their own mass ? So black holes are created from objects that belong to this universe right ? I get the idea that black holes aren't like a sink. However all that matter or light that get "trapped" into it must go somewhere, in some form .
- InclinedPlane 11y agoYep. Black holes aren't phenomena of matter, they are formed initially from matter but they are phenomena of space-time. The event horizon is basically a one way door, there's no way, no route in space-time, to cross it and return.
- ajuc 11y agoBut black holes evaporate?
- zamalek 11y agoThe curvature is the cause of the event horizon, the mass or energy is the cause of the curvature. Remove energy and you remove curvature, remove the curvature and you remove the event horizon.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- contravariant 11y agoOnly if you go beyond general relativity. Once you include quantum physics there are some strong indications that black holes must somehow evaporate (although this hasn't been observed directly), but that model is still incomplete.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoYup, and that's a problem that hasn't been fully worked out yet.
- zubspace 11y agoSo, it's an 'information' black hole, right? But matter, energy, whatever is trapped inside it with very high density and does not simply vanish right? .. Or am I completely wrong?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- x5n1 11y agoNot necessarily. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_information_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_information_paradox
- spriggan3 11y ago> Information is stored in a baby universe that separates from our own universe I like this idea, but then it means that there is no universe but multiverses, yet these multiverses need to be part of a greater structure or container, right ? do we have clues that strongly suggest the multiverse theory ?
- x5n1 11y agohttp://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/black-holes-are-a-passage-to-another-universe-says-stephen-hawking-10471397.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/black-holes-are-a-... We have many theories but little evidence of any of the theories having to do with black holes.
- Ruud-v-A 11y agoFrom a practical point of view, the baby universe theory is no different than the “information is lost” theory. Although it might be satisfying to think that information is not “really lost”, there is no way in which we -- in our universe -- would be able to tell the difference. The distinction is philosophical, not physical. There is a different theory not mentioned prominently on that page that in my opinion provides the most useful resolution: Black Hole Complementarity. In a sense it is not a satisfying resolution, because it basically states “the paradox is not a paradox”. It is very counter-intuitive, but that is a problem with intuition. The wave-particle duality of light, which is nowadays not really considered a paradox any more although it was ~110 years ago, is a good analogy. As always happens with questions like these, in the end the answer is “that is a nonsensical question to ask”.
- vocatus_gate 11y agoBlack holes have always fascinated and terrified me, don't know why. Just something mysterious about them.
- dschiptsov 11y agoIf one consider that exactly opposite is true - gravity actually do exist as a "function" of a matter, but space-time doesn't (especially a curved one) being a conditioning of our "serialized", self-centered perception, everything, it seems, falls to its places.
- petewailes 11y agoI'm pretty sure this doesn't make any sense. How are you explaining away spacetime?
- kinai 11y agoGravity is not a function of matter, and proving that curved space-time is real is trivial. So not sure where you are going with that idea...
- dschiptsov 11y agoCould you, please, give me a link for the proof of existence of time. Not some processes in the Universe, but time itself.
- Koshkin 11y agoYou can find a wealth of information at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time
- dschiptsov 11y agoI am afraid I don't quite understand you, my friend. Are you trying to suggest that existence of this particular page or any part of its content constitutes the proof of existence of time as an independent from an observer phenomena? May be it somehow related to Kantian view mentioned there about time as a mode of perception, being, as he said, prior to all perceptions, as a condition, but not of observable phenomena, but of sequential mode of perceptual machinery of an observer? But, as far as I know, in Russia "Kant - lokh".
- Freaky 11y ago> The real reason is that the space-time curvature does simply not provide a way for the light to go back. Same reason you can't go to the end of the universe if the universe would be a sphere. Or the same reason you can't travel to yesterday - there are simply no directions in which to point yourself in order to get there.
- nkrisc 11y agoIs not gravity just what we call the effects of the curvature of space-time and more or less equivalent?
- b34r 11y agoNot really. My personal belief is gravity is directly proportional the amount of space between particles. An object with extreme particle density will correspondingly have extreme gravity and vice versa. This has been observed in neutron stars, which are tightly packed. Extrapolating out this theory, I think black holes are so gravimetrically attractive because they feature a kernel of maximum-density matter at their core.
- azazqadir 11y ago>>Outside the horizon, an object can escape the black hole’s gravitational pull if it’s moving sufficiently fast; inside, it would need to move faster than light-speed, something forbidden by the laws of nature. Are they trying to say that if there was something that could move faster than light then it can escape? If that's is forbidden by laws of nature, then how did they determined that this is possible?
- erelde 11y agoIt's an equation with one unknown. Even if it can't be "done", maths can calculate it. It will just give you the absurd result you'd expect that you need faster-than-light velocity.
- kqr 11y agoAll things have a constant speed in spacetime: the speed of light. If you stand completely still, you travel through time at "the speed of light". If you start moving faster in space, you'll lose a similar amount of speed in time. Go fast enough, and your life will pass in slow-motion. Go at the speed of light and your time stops. Go faster than the speed of light, and your time will start going backwards. Since you can't get out of a black hole normally, the only way to get out is by reversing time. I.e., going faster than light might be an option to get out of a black hole. Of course, doing so is nonsense, but the maths work out.
- petewailes 11y agoTo clarify the physics here a little: The constant speed is actually the speed of a massless object through spacetime. It just so happens to be that photons have no mass. Also, going at high speed wouldn't make your life pass in slow motion to you. It would simply look that way to an observer who was moving vastly slower than you. The dilation in time is as a result of difference in relative velocities, rather than the speed of time changing. This is also why the part about "go faster than the speed of light" doesn't make sense in physics. Motion is a four dimensional vector, with three points giving a point position, and the forth giving velocity through spacetime. Thus you wouldn't be travelling through "time" backwards, but through spacetime backwards. Hope that helps. For more information, you may want to read up on the geometry of Minkowski spacetime.
- fvargas 11y agoCould someone suggest some books or reading for someone interested in learning about general relativity, black holes, and quantum mechanics/physics?
- augustl 11y agoAbout Time by Paul Davies is amazing! http://www.amazon.com/About-Time-Einsteins-Unfinished-Revolution/dp/0684818221 http://www.amazon.com/About-Time-Einsteins-Unfinished-Revolu...
- kinai 11y agoimo best for that: The Black Hole War by Leonard Susskind
- petewailes 11y agoAs a basic introduction which explains some of the actual maths going on, Why Does E=mc2? by Brian Cox and Jeff Forshaw is excellent.
- snarfy 11y agoEinstein's original book is a good read. For quantum mechanics I recommend Feynman's QED. Wiki has some decent articles too. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Introduction_to_general_relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Introduction_to_general_relati...
- ivanb 11y ago"The Fabric of the Cosmos: Space, Time, and the Texture of Reality" by Brian Greene.
- djaychela 11y agoLove the stat buried in there, that voyager 1 is 17 light HOURS away, and the nearest known black hole is 8,000 light years. That will put my youngest (9) step-son's mind at rest, he was worried about them when he heard about them first, despite my saying there was nothing to worry about, having concrete facts is always better!
- arca_vorago 11y agoMy theory is that it's the other side of the dual universe. (as opposed to multiverse). It goes something like this: membrane theory, universe a broke into our universe, big bang, but from a single point, causing quantum entanglement on all matter in this universe, which seeks a return of it's original state in universe a, and therefor gravity is actually a second teir effect of matter seeking to return via building up and entering a blackhole. Eg, quantum mechanics and entanglement are stronger than gravity based upon the fact it works at longer distances. Thats my non-physicist version of the grand unifying theory, but I'm not sure how to create a falsifiable by humankind version of it. I suspect dark matter discoveries will be the key.
- iofj 11y agoThe weird thing is that it differs from your perspective. If you're looking in from "infinity" (ie. where the gravity field of the black hole is negligeable) there appears to be a region where nothing can get to : the event horizon. After all, what does one see when looking at a light source falling into a black hole. That light source slows down as it approaches the event horizon. When it gets close you'll see it dim. That's because time is going slower for that light source. Also it becomes smaller and smaller. It will never cross the event horizon, which is the point where time would stop and it's size would be zero. Because of the amount of time it takes to actually get there, one can semi-accurately refer to it as the end of time. The weird thing is that the end of time is a spherical region of actual space, not a point in the future. Because this only happens close to the black hole it'll likely look confusing : it would fall very quickly to the event horizon, ever accelerating, then suddenly every 50% reduction in distance between it and the event horizon takes 100% more time to happen. If you're the one falling into a (large) black hole you'll see the opposite : the rest of the universe will go faster, grow brighter, and grow bigger (since the universe is mostly empty space and you can't really tell the physical size of stars from a distance you'd mostly see the empty space being bigger and may think everything else is the same size. It's not though, you just can't tell the difference between 10e-50 degrees and 10e-48 degrees). The event horizon is a theoretical concept, there is nothing in space that corresponds to the event horizon. No obstacle, no marker, no force, no nothing. From up close, it's just empty space. Think of the path between you and the rest of the universe, that path is getting longer, and you can see and measure that. That's all that happens, nothing more. Everything you can reach is falling in as well, and you see the distance between you and other things falling in increasing just the same. If you were to go anywhere, you'd notice that the distance between you and wherever you're trying to go grows bigger with time. If that happens fast enough you can never get there, because the distance will never decrease. The weird thing is that that is true for us here on earth as well. The distance between us and everything outside of our local galactic group (everything contained by a few galaxies who are bound by gravity. Granted, this structure is several million lightyears across, but it is finite and very tiny compared to the total universe) is getting bigger and further away. The vast, vast majority of the universe is expanding, exactly like you'd expect to see if you were falling into a (extremely huge) black hole. Furthermore the edge of the universe is suspiciously close to where those "hallways" expand at superluminal speeds (ie. the rate of distance increase between us and the faraway object > c). The distance between the furthest object ever measured and the point where distance increase speed becomes superluminal is 400 million light year. That seems suspiciously close to be coincidental. So the answer for "big" black holes might be very simple. What's inside ? Look around you. That's what's inside. Certainly some black holes are of a size that you could conceivably throw a solar system inside, and nothing out of the ordinary would happen to it at all for a very long time, essentially for the lifetime of the black hole, which can be hundreds of billions of years. That leaves small black holes where you'd be torn to shreds by the difference in gravity between the closest part of you to the black hole and the parts further away. It'd be like falling while having rockets accelerating your feet downwards. At some point, those rockets accelerate fast enough to rip your feet clean off. However, small black holes evaporate through Hawking radiation. They quickly convert all their mass to energy. So there'd be a massive explosion happening below you, which will likely vaporize you long before the tidal forces become an issue.