4 ms·
There is no fact of the matter, for the recoverability of what someone believes to be encrypted files. The state has one subjective belief—that the files are re
by derefr 11y ago
There is no fact of the matter, for the recoverability of what someone believes to be encrypted files. The state has one subjective belief—that the files are real, but encrypted. You might have a different belief—e.g. that the files never existed, and your disk contains random data with a disk-encryption header prepended. The concern is that you can be held in contempt for what the government believes to be true—that real data is there, under encryption, which you are not revealing—without that necessarily having any connection to reality.
By analogy: the government can compel me to open a safe, but it shouldn't be able to compel me to open something that—for all examinable intents and purposes—is a block of concrete with the facade of a safe door attached. I could certainly be held in contempt for refusing to open something that has been proved to be a safe; but holding me in contempt for refusing to open a concrete block, because they believe I have some magic power to turn it into a safe, is Kafkaesque.