5 ms·
> RMS is sometimes disparaged as a loon and an extremist. The Free Software movement as a whole is often disparaged as impractical and out of touch with reality
by golergka 11y ago
> RMS is sometimes disparaged as a loon and an extremist. The Free Software movement as a whole is often disparaged as impractical and out of touch with reality.
> People using free software criticizing RMS as an extremist.
I agree with these views, but it doesn't mean that I don't respect him.
- justinlardinois 11y agoSame.
- the_af 11y agoI don't know about you, but I consider it pretty hard to hold both views simultaneously: to respect someone and consider him/her an extremist loon who is out of touch with reality. "I respect this lunatic whose views are divorced from reality"... isn't this damning him with faint praise, and therefore confirming user _RPM's first sentence?
- tropo 11y agoHitler was quite the orator. Had you been there, you'd have been cheering.
- the_af 11y agoSpeak for yourself; I would have been shot or gassed. Even if I hadn't been Jewish, I would have found his xenophobic, warmongering views repulsive.
- dang 11y ago> Hitler was quite the orator. Had you been there, you'd have been cheering. Please don't make Hacker News miserably worse by posting things like this.
- tropo 11y agoCould you clarify? I don't understand the extreme reaction. I was responding to this: "hold both views simultaneously: to respect someone and consider him/her an extremist loon who is out of touch with reality" I gave an example of someone generally considered to be an extremist loon, yet obviously (he did in fact gain power) with unusual skill. Is it just that people are uncomfortable with the idea that his supporters were normal regular supposedly civilized people, and how this implies something about most of us?
- forthefuture 11y agoI think it's a matter of scope. You can respect Stallmans contributions to technology and "no thank you" his views on politics and society.
- CuriousSkeptic 11y agoI don't think you can. Some (most?) of those contributions were made exactly to promote those views on politics and society. To separate those contributions from that is disrespect in and of itself, almost by definition.
- twr 11y agoIt's quite possible to comprehend, admire, and appreciate the labor and discoveries of renowned scientists and technologists, without sharing in the motivations and beliefs they possessed. Science is intertwined with the accomplished legacies of hated figures whose beliefs were shaped by prejudice, yet whose works became recognized and included in established theory. Computing fields tend to venerate their idols with a religious-like fervor, unfortunately.
- CuriousSkeptic 11y agoI dont dispute that. Comprehend, admire and appreciate are all words that would fit in the paragraph I objected to. It was precisely the word respect I objected to.
- mastazi 11y agoSo you're saying it's impossible to respect a person you don't agree with? Be careful; saying that disagreement and disrespect are the same thing takes you on a very very slippery slope. Plenty of tyrants around the world justify illiberal laws and cruel policies citing such assumptions.
- CuriousSkeptic 11y agoNo no, I respect a lot of people I do not agree with. What I'm saying is that even if you disagree you can respect only if you recognize the motivations behind someones labor. To say that GNU is good technology but don't agree with its premise is disrespectful because, by definition the design has failed if you don't agree with the agenda. So you could say that you respect the effort but think it has failed, or you can say that you like the result but don't really respect its origins.
- golergka 11y agoHe's out of touch with economical and political realities of modern society, and his views on these matters are complete lunacy - however, I still respect him for strength and sincerity of his convictions. He's also a great programmer and software systems designer.