4 ms·
The guess is slightly more compelling when considered together with the testimony of the sister that she viewed images of abuse on the computer. Like, the line
by maxerickson 11y ago
The guess is slightly more compelling when considered together with the testimony of the sister that she viewed images of abuse on the computer.
Like, the line of questioning could be, did you find any images on the computer, did you find any evidence of techniques used to obscure information on the computer, could the images that so and so observed be stored using those techniques. It isn't confirmation that the images are there, but it is more than guessing out of thin air that there might be images there.
- chillingeffect 11y agoSo all I have to do is testify I saw images of abuse on my sister's computer and she can be jailed indefinitely? That's not just. That's a repressive police state. The burden of proof is on the accuser. The accused bears no burden of proof. This principle goes back almost 2,000 years, across multiple cultures, includes the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, predates and includes the American culture as well. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Presumption_of_innocence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Presumption_of_innocence
- luso_brazilian 11y agoThe government doesn't have a case with that evidence alone, that's why they are trying to compel the defendant to decrypt the hard drive. Here is how that's an end run around the 5th amendment: > State: you are under arrest on suspicious of possession of child pornography. You have the right to remain silent, anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. Do you understand your rights? > Defendant: yes > Witness: I saw what he has it in that computer > State: now reveal the password > Defendant: I invoke the right to remain silent. Have charges been pressed or am I free to go? > State: no charges pressed, you are detained until you reveal the password Here is how that could play differently in the future: > State: you are under arrest on suspicious of murder. You have the right to remain silent, anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. Do you understand your rights? > Defendant: yes > Witness: I saw what he did to the victim > State: now reveal the whereabouts of the body > Defendant: I invoke the right to remain silent. Have charges been pressed or am I free to go? > State: no charges pressed, you are detained until you reveal it If the All Writs Act allows the government to do the first it also allow the government to do the second.
- wfo 11y agoThat's not really the issue that concerns me. If the state can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he is capable of complying with the warrant (but is choosing not to) then contempt and jail is wholly appropriate. Similarly, if the state could prove he knew where the body was beyond a reasonable doubt then that's enough to lock him up, sure, absolutely, 100%. Even if he didn't do it, concealing facts about it when subpoenad or served with a warrant etc is certainly illegal. But the difference here is, can the state prove the drives are encrypted? Probably. I'd assume that's the case (forensic examination could reveal file names, logs, etc that provide evidence of that volume having been decrypted, the vast majority of encryption systems are readily identifiable) Can the state prove he is capable and unwilling, rather than willing but incapable, of decrypting the drives? I don't think that could ever happen. What if he genuinely forgot the password? What if he never knew it (was storing them for someone else, a common lie/excuse to give to police but something that could be true, any number of other reasons)? Does every person have to be able to provide access to all encrypted data on their devices if served with a warrant, with the consequences of being unable to do so indefinite imprisonment? Is forgetting or losing a password in unlucky combination with an false accusation of wrongdoing grounds for a life sentence?
- zorked 11y agoWe know that at some point someone that has a shred(1)ed disk will be told to "decrypt" it or face indefinite detention...
- maxerickson 11y agoI wonder if it then makes sense to write 0s as part of a permanent deletion process. No ambiguity about remaining content or intent when you do that.
- mjevans 11y agoI frequently, but DO NOT ALWAYS, do this when I am erasing hard drives. When I do this it is more of a flag to remind my self that I have, in fact, finished scrubbing the device.