4 ms·
Ask HN: Is anybody doing something productive with IBM Watson or is it just BS?
I have lately been through several pitches from companies and "architects" where they were talking about using IBM Watson but they rarely get into detail what they get from it. Is this just a buzzword for sales guys or are people doing something productive with it?
- Irishsteve 11y agoFrom what I've seen watson is just the branding and they put a bunch of companies they've acquired working in the general data / analytics space under the hood. It's not the solely the setup that won on jeopardy all those years ago.
- chatmasta 11y agoThe coolest thing I've seen is an internal IBM project that organizes the news: http://news-explorer.mybluemix.net/ http://news-explorer.mybluemix.net/
- daveloyall 11y agoI dunno about Watson, but it is my (inspecific) opinion that at least one state government and at least one upper-middle-sized corporation have a bunch of IBM big iron laying around that they don't need. The real burn is, that's not JUST an upfront cost... You pay per month. At the corp, I could not find anyone except the CEO that thought the investment was a good idea. I figure IBM gifted him a car or something. Complete speculation, but it's the only thing that makes sense! Elsewhere, inspecifically... At least the machines are used. But honestly how many giant black modern IBM boxes does it take to fully emulate every single AS/400 machine that existed within the entity back in 1996? A quick look at the specs tells me: 1. There's no way it would take more than one.
- davismwfl 11y agoOutside of some niche areas right now I think what you are hearing is people trying to pitch others to pay for their time to experiment and build something with Watson. Not that they already have a solution, again except for some niche industries and groups. Overall, IBM is having to reinvent itself (again), and IBM people themselves are pushing in new directions and pitching new ideas which fit their longer term plan. At the same time they have this huge legacy dragging behind them, so it can't be easy. Personally, I have never been a huge fan of some of the total crap (consulting mainly) they put out there, but then they do some crazy amazing stuff with their research groups. And I have seen a few really stellar software consulting gigs they have done too, but that seems to be the minority. But at least I'll say for them, they aren't Oracle, and they will complete a project.
- danso 11y agoI've posted my results with using their speech-to-text system: https://github.com/dannguyen/watson-word-watcher https://github.com/dannguyen/watson-word-watcher I think it's actually very good and could be of great use to people needing to mine and organize audio -- not for perfect transcriptions, but as a first pass solution...but I don't think that's the small vision that Watson purports to cater to...that is, if you fed the results of the speech-to-text into Watson's various language processing APIs, you'd get diminishing returns, though to be fair, I haven't really used those other APIs in bulk programmatic fashion yet [1] [1] http://www.ibm.com/smarterplanet/us/en/ibmwatson/developercloud/alchemy-language.html http://www.ibm.com/smarterplanet/us/en/ibmwatson/developercl...
- chishaku 11y agoThis is great, thank you.
- nikkwong 11y agoI personally thought their tradeoff api was pretty interesting, but until I hear/see some real world results, I will continue to be skeptical. If anyone here could shine some light on something that would be awesome.
- primaryobjects 11y agoI've used it for a prototype project for the news industry, though not in production. IBM Watson: Building a Cognitive App with Concept Insights http://www.primaryobjects.com/2016/02/01/ibm-watson-building-a-cognitive-app/ http://www.primaryobjects.com/2016/02/01/ibm-watson-building...
- cwe 11y agoI've looked into it for some past hackathon projects and a side project. Watson can take care of some of the heavy lifting of NLP, categorization, or parsing large volumes of text, et, in different ways, but it's not some jeopardy-winning AI you can just plug into something you already have (at least not yet). It can abstract away some tricky challenges if your needs fit what it can do.
- meesterdude 11y agoI had one company that used Watson flat out tell me that it was purely for marketing - they could have built their own solution just as easily, but used Watson because it had more marketability. From what I understand, it's really just a wrapper around IBM, or a collection of things IBM has built or offers. I have not yet seen anything particularly interesting - but i'm glad you asked this question! Hopefully someone will chime in with something worthwhile.
- giancarlostoro 11y agoIf what you're saying is correct then it could be seen as a sort of framework, though for marketing reasons that wouldn't sound as attractive I suppose? I have no experience in this field, though I would love to get into it someday.
- ohhoe 11y agoYeah. People are using it. -- For starters, Watson has taken residence at three of the top cancers hospitals in the US -- Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, and the Mayo Clinic -- where it helps with cancer research and patient care. -- In Australia, the company ANZ Global Wealth is focused on the latter. The company uses the Watson Engagement Advisor Tool, an NLP SaaS offering, to observe and field customer questions. Similarly, DBS bank in Singapore uses Watson to ensure the proper advice and experience for customers of its wealth management business. etc etc. -- http://www.zdnet.com/article/ibm-watson-what-are-companies-using-it-for/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/ibm-watson-what-are-companies-u...
- johansch 11y agoYou are on the Watson team, right?
- ohhoe 11y agosure am
- ryptophan 11y agoHow much of Watson's NLP success can be attributed to IBM acquiring AlchemyAPI (http://www.alchemyapi.com/ http://www.alchemyapi.com/)?
- ohhoe 11y agoI honestly can't answer this, I've been here less than a year and am just a front end person. My team is v small.
- maxxxxx 11y ago"helps with cancer research and patient care." What does that mean? I only hear good sounding phrases but nobody ever gives me any detail.
- ohhoe 11y ago
- sutro 11y agoIt's just BS.
- xutopia 11y agoMy brother is creating new chocolate confections with Watson's ingredient pairing. :-D It's called Chocolat Monarque and it's in Montreal.
- guiomie 11y agoCan you share more please? merci
- dragontamer 11y agohttps://www.ibmchefwatson.com/community https://www.ibmchefwatson.com/community Chef Watson is allegedly very good at what it does.
- alexc05 11y agoI've signed up for chef Watson as well! it's really cool. https://www.ibmchefwatson.com/ https://www.ibmchefwatson.com/
- nl 11y agoThis should answer your questions: http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/dced8150-b300-11e5-8358-9a82b43f6b2f.html#axzz479GitlGt http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/dced8150-b300-11e5-8358-9a82b43f6b... Tldr: mostly hype. The "solve cancer" claims haven't worked out. Now there are lots of big data/machine learning APIs being branded as "Watson" and some are quite good.
- martinni 11y agohttp://www.rossintelligence.com/ http://www.rossintelligence.com/ they use watson AI to simplify the legal system.
- alexc05 11y agoI am aware of some groups that are (at least planning to) use IBM Watson to analyse the outcomes and impacts of social policy research. As a (made up) example: feeding the AI data-sets of various social investments made (eg: education, mental health, social & medical support) alongside health and societal outcomes (crime, hospital intake, suicides, etc..) then overlaying it on a map and maybe getting Watson to "tell you" which investments had the best impacts. That particular example is actually an amalgam of a number of projects my girlfriend has undertaken recently in her career as a social-policy analyst BUT she is also enrolled in a university Master's program next year where one of the possibilities for her placement is to work supporting the Watson team in figuring out how to use Watson to improve lives & outcomes in the real world. I've also heard about using Watson in analyzing health data (detecting cancers based on mass x-ray analysis) - but I don't know how much of that is currently working. Hope that helps - I know it's all anecdotal from my side and I can't link you to anything published on the topic, but you can take the example for what it is worth :) EDIT - I'll try and ask her if she got any more information about what she was going to do for Watson.
- larrydag 11y agoHere is a recent Dallas R Users meetup on the very of topic of using IBM Watson http://www.meetup.com/Dallas-R-Users-Group/events/229283377/ http://www.meetup.com/Dallas-R-Users-Group/events/229283377/
- meeper16 11y agoI'm successfully using it to supply a hedge fund with a new kind of edge.
- _spoonman 11y agoAre you hiring? :)
- clavalle 11y agoI've helped IBM explore some consumer applications around Watson. We were basically using it as a recommendation engine. In contrast with regular recommendation engines which require other users to feed it data on preferences and then try to match you with similar users, the project we were working on had Watson build a feature space on its own (something it is very, very good at) then match a user profile within that space. In short, it cut out the 'similar person' middleman. It showed what 'shape' a user was in a feature space, the overall shape of the full feature space, and where that user was in that space. Thus, if a person wanted to get from where they are to somewhere else in that feature space, Watson provided a map, more or less. Why is that important? Well, building a proper recommendation engine when it depends on a network of people is hard. Think Amazon and Netflix -- part of their competitive advantage is that recommendation network effect built by their users. The more people, the more value. The fewer people and it might be way off base and turn off your early users. What if you didn't need to move through the preliminary steps of building that network? What if you could jump to the end? Suddenly that moat dries up. That's what Watson offers, at least for that particular application type.
- tedmiston 11y agoThis sounds really interesting. Do you have a paper or more details?
- MattyMc 11y agoITT: People who have not used IBM Watson for something productive..