3 ms·
Note that OP is being very coy and is not disclosing the fact that the proposed rules benefit his own Apply HN submission. The OP is referring to Pinboard whic
by minimaxir 11y ago
Note that OP is being very coy and is not disclosing the fact that the proposed rules benefit his own Apply HN submission.
The OP is referring to Pinboard which was a joke submission.
- idlewords 11y agoWhat basis do you have for claiming it's a joke?
- minimaxir 11y agoPinboard is not eligible for the YCF because it is not an early-stage startup. Otherwise the submission is perfectly fine. :p
- idlewords 11y agoFrom https://fellowship.ycombinator.com/faq/ https://fellowship.ycombinator.com/faq/: "The only restrictions on acceptable teams are founders must be willing to work on their ideas full-time, and teams can’t have previously taken money from investors."
- minimaxir 11y agoHuh. It appears I have been lawyered.
- abhi3 11y agoFrom the same page: What if we haven’t yet received investment, but we have a ton of traction, users, revenue, etc.? We want YC Fellowship to really help teams that are just starting off, or have been struggling to get traction. If you’re doing really well, we’ll likely ask you to apply for the next batch of Y Combinator.
- idlewords 11y agoThis says nothing about eligibility. It only suggests that such teams—which are allowed to apply—are unlikely to be selected. In this case, the normal selection process has been changed by throwing the decision to Hacker News. And the people have spoken!
- CameronBanga 11y agoWhat are you using as a basis to say that Pinboard's submission was a joke?