3 ms·
> Open-source is free like puppies are free. You don't write a check to get it, but you have to support it for life. Your employee's time is not free. Working
by scotty79 17y ago
> Open-source is free like puppies are free. You don't write a check to get it, but you have to support it for life. Your employee's time is not free. Working around bugs is not free. Having nothing but the Web of Lies Internet to rely on for tech support is not free.
Nice piece of FUD.
- smartbear 17y agoDepends on the open-source project. For e.g. Apache, Linux, MySQL, you're right it's unfair. For things like RoR, it's pretty accurate. For small projects, it's definitely true, but then again most companies don't depend on relatively unknown OSS projects.
- terrellm 17y agoI'm not seeing how RoR is any different than other OSS. Could you elaborate?
- smartbear 17y agoWhen you use RoR and, say, 10-20 gems, you spend a lot of time discovering bugs in those things, fixing them, contributing them back, and hoping the contri's are taken. None of that is free, of course. Whereas I've used Apache (both the C-based web server and Tomcat), Linux, and MySQL for years, and never once did I have to patch something myself. The quality of the software and updates were sufficient; certainly just as good as any commercial product. This is what I mean about it being different. Of course commercial software has bugs etc as well! The difference is there's a place to complain and other developers are responsible for making the fixes. Of course some companies are good about this and others aren't, and the same can be said for OSS projects. In the end, to SOME extent this is FUD, but specifically in the context within this post, it's not FUD, because the argument is specifically for a company who is CLAIMING awesome support for bug-fixes. You can't just take my quote out of context and then argue against it!
- terrellm 17y agoI wasn't trying take anything out of context - I was just trying to gain a better understanding of why RoR was mentioned. Thanks for the clarification and I agree it can be a challenge keeping up with any software that is modular and utilizes code developed by volunteers and hobbyists. Whether it by Python or even .NET using 3rd party components.
- hasanove 17y agoMy and I am sure a lot of others' experience with RoR and gems/plugins is completely opposite.
- pchristensen 17y agoAre you serious? He's role-playing the sales-pitch you would give if your positioning was 'most expensive'. It's supposed to be FUD - it's an illustrative pretend marketing campaign!
- scotty79 17y agoI'm aware of that. I don't claim that author is stupid or mischievous. I just say it's a nice piece of FUD. I didn't expect to be downvoted so heavily about it.
- mseebach 17y agoIt's only FUD when comparing with a similar non-open-source piece of software - i.e. Postgres vs. MSSQL, Apache vs. IIS, OpenOffice vs. MS Office. A standard shrink-wrapped version of the for-money options doesn't come with any kind of support that the open source versions don't have. But when comparing e.g. GitHub with Git+Linux+SSH+Nginx+Python+Trac+.... it's completely fair. And that's one of the easy setups.