6 ms·
You can not understand this sort of thing if you model humans as idealized Vulcans. You have to understand that sex and nudity and such are all tied up not just
by jerf 11y ago
You can not understand this sort of thing if you model humans as idealized Vulcans. You have to understand that sex and nudity and such are all tied up not just with our forebrain, but with our irrational hindbrains, and we don't get to choose what "programs" those are running. I'm not saying I have a really easy answer, just that being mystified by these sorts of things is an indication that you're running on the wrong model of human minds. These issues are real, and the nudity is merely a player on a complicated game board of deep human currents of sex, power, hierarchy, and public morality, its need to be enforced, and it's need to be seen being enforced (important not to model those as the same thing!), playing out in a complicated iterated group social game.
Further, it's worth pointing out that the people painting the nudity were not Vulcans neutrally painting "just what reality is" either. The painters set out to push certain buttons with those paintings, and the fact that people react is a measure of the fact they succeed. It should hardly be a mystery that people have further responses to the fact certain buttons are being pushed; indeed, it would be a mystery if they did just consider it no different than a painting of a bowl of fruit.
- Torgo 11y agoContext matters too, I suspect some of those works when commissioned were meant to be enjoyed semi-privately, in someone's mansion or palace. Now they're placed in a public building behind people being photographed.
- Retric 11y agoNudity used to be far more common. Ex: Greek wrestling was a publics nude sport. IMO, it's simply religions creating a totally artificial prohibition to create relevance from thin air.
- Juliate 11y agoWe're talking about pieces of art that have been around for centuries - and about people of power who are in the same positions as those that commissionned this pieces before them. Who has the most thoughtful, the "right" "model of human minds" between those who commissionned these works, those who produced them and those who veiled them today?
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoPeople in that same position of power also killed rather a lot of middle easterners in the Crusades. I don't think we should use all their choices as a model for modern ones.
- Juliate 11y agoAnd? because people of power today do not? Besides, the same type of nude art works, were produced long before (even in prehistoric times), east, south, north, and west of the Mediterranean sea.
- jerf 11y agoYou seem to be asking questions about judging value or morality. I'm only talking about understanding. The original article didn't exactly come out and say that they found the whole thing mystifying, but I've seen enough similar things that it seemed relevant, and I do think that's the general tone.
- restalis 11y ago"sex and nudity and such are all tied up not just with our forebrain, but with our irrational hindbrains, and we don't get to choose what «programs» those are running" We can, however, train ourselves to pass more control on our forebrain and, like you mentioned ("painters set out to push certain buttons with those paintings"), those paintings were a very important tool to measure the success of that. When there is this dignitary empowered to act on collective behalf, it's only comforting to find out that he holds enough self-control to act cool and rational, that he is competent enough to deal with whatever social play, including the basic instinct attempts, without compromising whatever public business he's out to solve. Given the context, this pampering only unsettles me!