6 ms·
"Would I survive a crash? They're very tiny..." Isn't the real test how likely you are to be injured/killed per mile driven? Larger vehicles like SUVs might be
by arethuza 11y ago
"Would I survive a crash? They're very tiny..."
Isn't the real test how likely you are to be injured/killed per mile driven? Larger vehicles like SUVs might be safer if you are in an accident but that could be offset if they are more likely to actually be in an accident.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIts pretty much assumed the rate of accident is proportional to the driving miles. Does that comment mean, because of the limited range, electric vehicles have smaller exposure to accident risk? I guess a bicycle would do even better then.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoIt is true that the more people who cycle, the lower the number of transport related deaths and injuries. Only some of these effects, e.g. less deaths from air pollution, apply to EVs though.
- arethuza 11y agoWhat I meant was that discussions of vehicle safety always seem to start with assuming you are in an accident - what if some kinds of vehicles are more or less likely to be in accidents (all other things being equal). NB I have no idea what the answer is and I've driven everything from large(ish) SUVs to the old style minis.
- tim333 11y agoSmall electrical vehicles like that are going to be used mostly in slow moving urban environments and your chances of being killed are massively affected by impact speed so probably quite low.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoYet traditionally most accidents occur quite close to home. So they will be in many more accidents? Its the severity-probability product S(a)*P(a) that yields the 'suffering coefficient'
- tamana 11y agoRemoving long distance trails makes your trip mix biased toward short trips, but doesn't increase the rate of short trips.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoNo, the real test is how survivable the vehicle is in a collision. Probability of suffering an accident is a separate discussion. If your family is T-boned in an intersection by a drunk driver who ran a red light, are you going to say, "Well, at least the odds of that happening were very small, since she rarely drives!" No, you're going to be dealing with serious injuries or possibly deaths and you're going to be saying, "I wish they'd been in a larger vehicle that was more survivable."
- WJW 11y agoI'd prefer that they would have been not hit at all, which a more maneuverable vehicle with a shorter stopping distance might help with. Also, the probability I'm interested in is not the survivability in an accident, it is the total survivability over my lifetime, discounted by some percentage for cost etcetera. In your argumentation, everybody should drive around in tanks on the off chance that somebody else might get drunk. In reality, nobody does that and tradeoffs are made. Have you ever tried driving in an old European city in an average (American) SUV? You literally would not fit in most parking spaces, let alone fit in some of the smaller streets.
- grandalf 11y agoI recently drove a European mini-van through Paris and it was a very tight squeeze... some streets were too narrow, and in one case a moped was parked 6" beyond the designated zone, which made the street impassible for me. It was quite a fun experience, but in the future I'll rent a smaller vehicle.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoLarger vehicles have larger crumple zones and more steel all around. Are you saying larger vehicles are no safer than smaller ones? This runs counter to decades of conventional wisdom based on thousands of crash tests. See Edmunds, Consumer Reports, and other reputable organizations for corroboration of this.
- blisterpeanuts 11y ago
- AdrianB1 11y agoSo 'drive an 18 wheeler' is the solution?