10 ms·
I think it can get much worse than that. I don't know why people think the current levels of accumulation of debt are sustainable but there is a limit to what
by cm2187 11y ago
I think it can get much worse than that.
I don't know why people think the current levels of accumulation of debt are sustainable but there is a limit to what even the US can roll in term of debt. All developped nations are at around 100% debt to GDP, more than 200% if you include private debt, and growing at 3-5% per annum.
Now does anyone really think that sometime soon any developped country will start making public surplus and deleverage for 30 years? That's never going to happen.
I think one or both of two things will happen: 1. massive defaults of states and therefore of banks and insurance companies. 2. Long period of high inflation.
Either way savings from people now in their 30s will be wiped out. A little gift from the departing generation (baby boomers)...
- RobertoG 11y agoMassive defaults of states doesn't make sense. A country that have debt in its sovereign currency have not need to default. Inflation is not precisely the problem now, is it?
- cm2187 11y agoThen if you do not believe in default or inflation, what exactly do you think will happen? 1000% debt to GDP?
- RobertoG 11y agoI believe in inflation. I just said it is not the problem now. Inflation happens when there is more demand from the economy that economy can satisfy or when there are too much strong demand of imported goods. What it is a fiction is public debt in monetary sovereign governments: http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=31715 http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=31715
- cm2187 11y agoThe sort of inflation we are talking about here is when the government will print money to pay their debt. This type of inflation will be wiping out savings and pensioners.
- RobertoG 11y agoSo, we agree that default is not an issue? If there is any doubt here is in the words of Alan Greespan: "The United States can pay any debt it has because we can always print money to do that. So there is zero probability of default" http://www.cnbc.com/id/44051683 http://www.cnbc.com/id/44051683 Can we agree also that inflation is not a problem at the moment?
- cm2187 11y agoI am not sure what is the point of inflation being a problem at the moment. What I am saying is that savings will be wiped out by inflation. As for governments defaults, history is full of governments defaulting even on debt in their own currencies, particularly in time of political instability. I am not sure what gives you the confidence that now things are different and that this will not happen.
- RobertoG 11y agoMoney is debt. Debt is a promise of something. You default when you can't keep your promise. If you promise gold or another country currency in exchange of yours, you can be in a position where you can't pay. If the only thing you promise is to accept your currency back as tax payment, you are never in a position where you can't pay. That inflation is low now is relevant because it invalidate the quantity of money view of inflation. We are in the middle of a huge "quantitative easing" and we don't see inflation. In fact we see the opposite. For instance, the ECB is injecting (if I remember properly, I didn't check) 80000 millions every month. So, the "common sense" view of inflation have been proved wrong again and again but, we continue hearing the same thing again and again.
- msandford 11y ago"Technical default" and "Effective default" are obviously different, but if the purchasing power of the dollars you're paid in are only 1% of the dollars you've loaned, that's effective default. If the government practices effective default over a period of 50 years most people don't really get it. If the government practices effective default over 3-6 months, everyone will understand and it could be very destructive. It would definitely cause a lot of social unrest.
- gruez 11y ago>A country that have debt in its sovereign currency have not need to default. How did that work out for Argentina?
- RobertoG 11y agoArgentina currency was pegged to the Dollar, so not so sovereign. Also, a lot of their public and private debt was denominated in foreign currency. Again, not so sovereign.
- conanbatt 11y agoThe constant inflation made it only possible to issue bonds in a foreign currency. Sustained inflation does not solve public debt, because it also devalues the taxes the government gets back, creating a negative feedback loop of deficit and inflation (argentina's path in the last 10 years)
- RobertoG 11y ago"The constant inflation made it only possible to issue bonds in a foreign currency." Why is that? I think the problem in this discussions is that every side come from a different conception about what is and where money comes from. A sovereign govern with a floating currency don't need financing from private sources in its own money. That's a simple fact about how money is really created. If we don't agree in this first, all posterior discussion is pointless.
- Gmo 11y agoTheir debt was in dollars
- Amezarak 11y agoThe US federal debt was even higher in the wake of World War II. The US government did not run surpluses and deleverage in the following decades. The economy grew, without hyperinflation, and the debt became irrelevant. The solution to high levels of debt is sustainable economic growth, not deleveraging. Mass deleveraging would be an economic catastrophe.
- Retric 11y agoUS still has a significant chunk of WWII debt after one of the greatest sustained economic booms of all time. Growth really is not the answer. Inflation sounds great, just default without technically defaulting, until you actually see what it does to the economy. The real solution is to simply spend vastly less money accepting that pain now is better than letting the US become a failed state.
- chadzawistowski 11y agoIt sounds like you're suggesting austerity, which comes with its own set of problems. Between inflation and austerity, I don't think there's a clear absolute choice.
- jqm 11y agoIf you could really direct things on a massive scale that could work. But I fear each little piece will scream bloody murder if it's cheese gets cut off and it becomes feasibly impossible to do what needs to be done.
- Amezarak 11y ago> US still has a significant chunk of WWII debt after one of the greatest sustained economic booms of all time. Let's pretend this is true. (I doubt it.) Let's keep in mind that US debt is owed in bonds, redeemable in US dollars. If I get a 30 year mortgage in 1945 and simply rollover the debt whenever it comes due, but my wealth has increased dramatically, my mortgage does not matter. If I take out a 100k mortgage and then go on to found Apple and become a multibillionaire, then yes, growth was the answer. My debt may not have changed, but it is completely and utterly irrelevant when considering my financial situation. > Inflation sounds great, just default without technically defaulting, until you actually see what it does to the economy. Which is why the 50s and 60s were known as horrific economic times, right? Assuming by "inflation" you just mean an increase in the money supply - quintupling the money supply since 2009 doesn't seem to have led to the sky falling. > The real solution is to simply spend vastly less money accepting that pain now is better than letting the US become a failed state. No, the real solution is to spend more money now, taking advantage of historically low interest rates that at times have been negative in real terms, to do whatever you can to kickstart economic growth, and let the debt inflate away 'naturally'. Preferably you do this by investing in infrastructure projects, education, and science, and other things that produce real benefit, but if you want to fill mines with hundred dollar bills and fill them in so others can mine them out, that's fine too. In this case there is no pain. Spending less money now isn't accepting necessary pain, it's causing unnecessary pain. The US will not become a failed state because of mild inflation. Hyperinflation will never be a problem in the US barring a world war or huge resource or natural catastrophe. People have been preaching the doom-and-gloom inflation story for probably a century now. Every year, it's just around the corner. Well, it isn't. I can only speculate why the story is so popular. I can only assume that people have been taught to internalize all debt as a moral issue: less debt is Good, more debt is Bad, and there must therefore be dire consequences visited upon the guilty nations that don't treat debt as it must be treated. But the debt of sovereign, money-printing governments bears no resemblance to the debt of individuals, and there really are no consequences to a government being in debt forever. (Actually there's no consequences to individuals being in debt forever either - I am in perpetual debt to my credit card company, and spend the majority of my paycheck on it...but I pay it off every month.) It would in fact be a bad thing if there were no US bonds to purchase; you've suddenly eliminated a huge source of safe investment from the market.
- jbooth 11y agoPeople have been saying the same exact thing as you since 2008 though.. we're coming up on 10 years and no expected hyperinflation. I'd suggest we need to revisit the macro models that predict it, especially considering that common attitudes towards 'work ethic' and 'family budget' really bias people in terms of expecting more badness out of the debt situation than we seem to be seeing.
- hibikir 11y agoOf course we won't see deleveraging from countries. It's just not important at all for countries having their own currency, or a currency-issuing central bank that is committed to that country's health. As far as debt levels, talking about debt/gdp ratios by itself is not meaningful. What is important is how expensive is debt servicing, and the current rates are about as low as they have ever been. As far as inflation goes, look at TIPS spreads: they predict having very small inflation for many years. To expect high inflation is to think one is far better than the market at predicting the future: If you are the one person in the world that can really do that, riches await you. And finally, savings won't be wiped out, even in that scenario you describe. There are plenty of ways to keep wealth safe to every risk you mention, if you really believe in it, in exchange of far worse performance if the fears are imagined. If they become more likely, we'll see a shift in assets. We'd need a world war, a zombie apocalypse or an alien invasion to wipe out the wealth accumulated by a generation.
- jhoechtl 11y agoThe US profited enormous from Europe falling to pieces. Re-building Europe swept in money into US kofers for many, many years and is in fact still ongoing, albeit to a very small extend. Consequently thinking your thoughts ahead will inevitably results in either WWIII or massive poverty coming all over us the moment the first asks value for money and demands his money back. In fact we are already there as we are relying on fiat money rather than backing by "real" goods.
- Bombthecat 11y agoThat's why stuff like bitcoin is so interesting.
- rayiner 11y agoAs someone with a lot of student loans, I welcome the hyperinflation.
- vasilipupkin 11y agoall you need is gdp growth + inflation to be larger than debt service payment. So, back of the envelope, current debt service is about 1.3% of gdp. We are growing at 1.8% and inflation is 2%. So, we are easily going to be able to service our debts at current levels. So, there is no problem
- exclusiv 11y agoExcept spending is included in GDP which I think makes GDP about as useful as BMI calculations.