3 ms·
As someone who works in security operations, there is absolutely a need for people. Yes, a small number of experts could, given enough time, produce some small
by jcrawfordor 11y ago
As someone who works in security operations, there is absolutely a need for people. Yes, a small number of experts could, given enough time, produce some small amount of thoroughly secure components. But that's not the situation we're facing.
In real life, governments are some of the largest enterprises that exist, and use the same software and systems as everyone else. Complete replacement with provably correct systems is such a large task that it would never be completed, for just the same reasons as in private industry. The attack surface of a government ranges from sophisticated military hardware to mobile apps.
Deterring, detecting, and remediating security incidents is thus done the same way the private sector does it: testing, continuous monitoring, hunting, forensics, etc. All of these activities are person-hour intensive, and I don't think there's a security operations center in the world that wouldn't tell you right now that they are limited by the size of their staff.
That said, full-service security departments will include technical auditing and software security components, and I suspect the German government intends to include this. Of course, these functions are quite limited by being on the client end of the relationship, as I doubt the German government produces any more of its software in-house than the US government does (which is not very much).