3 ms·
The issue some people have (those at the other end of accidents) is that unless the accident involves major traumatic injuries it costs too much money and time
by mc32 11y ago
The issue some people have (those at the other end of accidents) is that unless the accident involves major traumatic injuries it costs too much money and time (for the investigators) to get the records from the phone companies and to make sure they synchronize event times, etc.
So, this, presumably, would make that aspect cheaper and afford this evidence for less severe accidents and allow those who believe they should pay less in insurance because they drive more responsibly (as could evidenced by this method) to enjoy those benefits and at the same time presumably drive down the incidence of distracted driving induced accidents.
- analog31 11y agoThat's understood, but I think the expenditure of money and time are not just to get records, but also to ensure the oversight that protects our rights. For instance a search warrant issued to the phone company could be limited to time-stamp data, thus preventing the police from conducting a broader search without cause. Also, the warrant creates a record of what was searched. I believe that the public interest in oversight of the police could be reasonably balanced against the cost of that oversight. If it's actually desirable that the fact of an accident be treated as probable cause for such a search, then the warrant would not be all that hard to obtain. In general, warrantless searches need to be justified by some kind of immediate need, not just cost and convenience.