5 ms·
Hm, kinda strange, I was always under the impression that we didn't quite yet have a public consensus that there's an expectation of privacy in email. Like, not
by SilasX 11y ago
Hm, kinda strange, I was always under the impression that we didn't quite yet have a public consensus that there's an expectation of privacy in email. Like, not everyone really expects that a given email won't be read by some third party.
- themartorana 11y agoOnly people that want to read your email without your consent believe that. Well, they don't, they just say it. They say it about everything, by the way, and make a judge explicitly invalidate it.
- rayiner 11y agoWe don't.[1] But expectation of privacy is a 4th amendment concept. Congress can extend greater protections to email by statute than the Constitution requires. [1] In fact, I think it's ridiculous to say that there is an expectation of privacy in something like GMail, which a third party not only can read but actively mines for personal data about you.
- dublinben 11y agoI think it's perfectly reasonable to expect that only Google has access to your stored emails. Not just any government agency whose lawyer drafts a letter. Would you permit the government, or any random person off the street to remove money from your bank account, just because you've authorized your bank to do so?
- coldtea 11y agoSnail mail is also sent by postmen (who can open and read it, or just read it if its a postcard), and telegraphs (still a thing?) are dictated to someone. That doesn't mean people expect or would like having them read by a non-involved person, outside of those necessary reasons for their delivery. If "expectation" is the criterion, how about actually asking people what they actually expect with a poll of sorts? The whole "expectation of privacy" as a metric is bogus. Then again, those are the same people who read gun laws regarding "militias" as valid for 20-21st century individuals (and I'm not saying this as someone anti-gun -- just that, if you like guns and want them, just pass a law saying that, not use some 3 century old unrelated law as an excuse with all the pomposity of the Supreme Court, as if some redneck with a liking for guns is part of a "well regulated militia").
- bitwize 11y agoBy "gun laws regarding militias" I assume you mean the Second Amendment itself -- few statutes concerning or mentioning militias are used to justify general gun use, but the 2A is and there's an important reason why: The founders envisioned a nation of citizen-defenders equipped and trained to protect their homes, farms, and neighborhoods from incursion by enemies, foreign or domestic. The Constitution states that the right to keep and bear arms is a prerequisite for a well-regulated militia, not the other way around. And it draws on prevailing notions from English law at the time (the UK, like the USA, didn't start moving to abolish or restrict gun rights until the beginning of the 20th century or thereabouts). This is more than some old, unrelated law; it is the supreme law of the land. If you do not think that it is applicable in the modern era, the solution is to agitate for repeal of the 2A, not to pretend that it doesn't exist or has been outmoded and complain when people act like it still is valid, active, enforceable law. I'm not even speaking as someone who favors guns. But the Constitution is what it is, and if we don't like it we change it. If the government can get away with ignoring the Second Amendment and deciding it's no longer relevant, think of what they might do to the First Amendment. Or the Fourth. Or the Fifth. Or the Eighth. Or the Thirteenth. Get the picture?
- coldtea 11y ago>The founders envisioned a nation of citizen-defenders equipped and trained to protect their homes, farms, and neighborhoods from incursion by enemies, foreign or domestic. The Constitution states that the right to keep and bear arms is a prerequisite for a well-regulated militia, not the other way around. It doesn't just state that the right to bear arms is a prerequisite for a well-regulated militia. It also uses the need of a militia as the _justification_ for that right. It says: "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." This means that the right to bear arms is not an end in itself -- it's justified in as much as it's a first step to a well-regulated militia. In an era without well-regulated citizen militias (except the National Guard, for which different guard laws apply anyway), there's no reason to hold the right to keep arms anymore. So, yes, arms are a prerequisite to such militias -- but (the arms) are only asked to be respected as a right precisely because they are such a prerequisite -- and not for another reason. Which makes the justification for guns and militias reciprocal. Without militias, and no role for them, no reason for the former either. >But the Constitution is what it is, and if we don't like it we change it. If the government can get away with ignoring the Second Amendment and deciding it's no longer relevant, think of what they might do to the First Amendment. Or the Fourth. Or the Fifth. Or the Eighth. Or the Thirteenth. I find keeping the "right to bear arms" in an era for which the justification for doing so given in the Constitution has expired, as the government already violating the spirit of the 2nd Amendment (to favor gun lobbies and such). E.g. that reading of the 2A is a selective reading that upholds the letter while violating the spirit of it, from politically appointed and non impartial judges.
- coldtea 11y ago>Hm, kinda strange, I was always under the impression that we didn't quite yet have a public consensus that there's an expectation of privacy in email. Like, not everyone really expects that a given email won't be read by some third party. Never understood those US ideas on such matters. Nobody would want/expect/wont be furious to find out their two party communication was read by somebody else who wasn't meant to get it (and I don't mean show to some third person by your correspondent). It's not gauging the public belief/sentiment on the matter, but BS ad-hoc "interpretations" of legacy laws allowed courts/pundits to even make such inane claims that people don't expect privacy for their mails. If we're talking about expectations, then how about them asking people what they expect DIRECTLY (eg with a state/national poll) instead of some court deciding.
- SilasX 11y agoI was being sarcastic, since everyone knows exactly how people would react to their emails being read by an unattended human, and exactly how much privacy the typical person expects, but Poe's Law and all...
- jessaustin 11y agoYes in this case you were too cool for school. You gotta give us some hint. Look at poor 'rayiner up there, sincerely defending your sarcastic proposition!
- rayiner 11y agoI think you fail to account for the fact that we are talking about Constitutional issues. We are not talking about what is an appropriate level of privacy protection under the law. We are talking about what is the minimum standard where a 200-year old document trumps the policies of a democratically elected government. We are also deciding that question on the basis of a phrase ("reasonable expectation of privacy") that doesn't even appear in that 200 year old document.
- briandear 11y agoThat 200 year old document IS the policy of a democratically elected government. The age of the document has no relevance. It's just as valid today as it has ever been.