3 ms·
Someone told me in a lot of other countries, there aren't dedicated prosecution and defense attorneys; that in places like the UK a pool can be drawn from to re
by djsumdog 11y ago
Someone told me in a lot of other countries, there aren't dedicated prosecution and defense attorneys; that in places like the UK a pool can be drawn from to represent both. Is this true?
I feel like the win/closure rate is a huge part of the problem.
- arethuza 11y agoWell, there isn't really a single legal system in the UK. Here in Scotland, which I think is fairly similar to England even though the terminology is completely different, the public prosecutor is the procurator fiscal who directly employs solicitors to prosecute cases in the lower courts (Sheriff Courts). Defendants will typically be defended by solicitors working criminal defence firms - often paid for by the state through Legal Aid. However, for more serious crimes there is a completely separate court - the High Court of the Justiciary before which normal solicitors can't appear - you need to be a specialised advocate and they can't be employed directly by clients but only by solicitors (you do get Solicitor Advocates but apparently they don't appear nearly as often as you might expect). You might be getting the idea of a shared pool from this idea of an advocate (barrister in England) who in theory will take any side of any case. In practice there are advocates working for the public prosecutor for a stint and others who focus on criminal defence. However I suspect most advocates have no desire to do criminal work unless they want to be Sheriffs or Judges.
- tripzilch 11y agoDo you have this "jury of peers" thing as well? Cause that's such a scary notion in the US legal system, I'm happy we do without (in the Netherlands). It's such an obvious part of the problem. Yes it's nice they're peers or something, but they're pretty useless considering how easily they get wooed by any expert speaking with a sound of authority and the fact that they're a 100 times more familiar with the CSI:Fairytales on TV than they are with the actual justice system. The big difference is that a professional working in this system will actually get a notion of how trustworthy tea-leaf readings actually are when determining objective true facts (or something similarly scientific, like polygraphs--they don't seem to get much use outside the US either, weird). Well, unless of course the incentives for the professional are wrong, and again it's this "jury of peers" idea that gets in the way, the incentives become about populism and convincing the jury, about the show. Not what's really real, but who can produce the biggest superstimulus of hyperreality. Thanks a lot, Baudrillard :-(
- arethuza 11y agoYes - we have jury trials - juries picked purely at random with no vetting (I've been selected for jury duty a few times and never actually been picked): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_by_jury_in_Scotland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_by_jury_in_Scotland
- int_19h 11y agoIt's the difference between this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inquisitorial_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inquisitorial_system and this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adversarial_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adversarial_system
- taejo 11y agoI don't think that's what GP's refering to. In an adversarial system you can either have dedicated prosecutors, or have the state hire an attorney to prosecute the case just as the defendant hires an attorney. Both would draw from the same pool of criminal attorneys. AIUI, this was historically the case in England and Wales.