3 ms·

I see 1Password mentioned here, but not Dashlane. I use it personally across multiple devices and it has just been awesome. I was using KeePass before that for

by surds 10y ago

I see 1Password mentioned here, but not Dashlane. I use it personally across multiple devices and it has just been awesome. I was using KeePass before that for several years, but the inconsistent interface and performance across platforms became cumbersome. Has anyone used both 1Password and Dashlane? Which one would you choose? Also, how is Dashlane for Teams?

rob-olmos 10y ago
I've recently experimented with Dashlane for Teams and been using 1Password Teams. 1PW has much more functionality around teams from my experience. The team sharing within Dashline leaves much to be desired, even sharing of multiple items at a time is a bit rough, and I couldn't find a way to create vaults/groups. 1PW has a notion of vaults for grouping data, but anyone with access to the vault can see all of the credentials. This makes it really cumbersome with overlapping groups that results in vault explosion. Eg, Marketing & Finance vaults have overlapping users, so you create a Marketing/Finance vault, and so on. You can see several questions about this issue in the forums. Looks like the pricing is going to be $5/user/month for 1PW. I'm waiting for them to add individual item permissions and the ability to create custom groups. No 2FA either, which they have their reasons for. Auditing and reports would be nice. I might end up going with LastPass for the more granular permissions. I really wish I could find a decently priced company credential/identity manager that can assist with things like automatically rotating passwords/access so I can more easily prevent staff from copying passwords into an unencrypted file, and get an audit log of who's accessing what. Dashlane has some notion of password resets but there's no control to script it for your own or client websites. There's Thycotic but I don't think their Cloud version supports password changing (and I'm not interested in running a Windows server). There's also Manage Engine's PMP... but that interface also left much to be desired. Any suggestions or advice? Thanks

by surds 10y ago

rob-olmos 10y ago

I've recently experimented with Dashlane for Teams and been using 1Password Teams. 1PW has much more functionality around teams from my experience. The team sharing within Dashline leaves much to be desired, even sharing of multiple items at a time is a bit rough, and I couldn't find a way to create vaults/groups. 1PW has a notion of vaults for grouping data, but anyone with access to the vault can see all of the credentials. This makes it really cumbersome with overlapping groups that results in vault explosion. Eg, Marketing & Finance vaults have overlapping users, so you create a Marketing/Finance vault, and so on. You can see several questions about this issue in the forums. Looks like the pricing is going to be $5/user/month for 1PW. I'm waiting for them to add individual item permissions and the ability to create custom groups. No 2FA either, which they have their reasons for. Auditing and reports would be nice. I might end up going with LastPass for the more granular permissions. I really wish I could find a decently priced company credential/identity manager that can assist with things like automatically rotating passwords/access so I can more easily prevent staff from copying passwords into an unencrypted file, and get an audit log of who's accessing what. Dashlane has some notion of password resets but there's no control to script it for your own or client websites. There's Thycotic but I don't think their Cloud version supports password changing (and I'm not interested in running a Windows server). There's also Manage Engine's PMP... but that interface also left much to be desired. Any suggestions or advice? Thanks