13 ms·
One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt
- icelancer 11y agoThis is exactly how I feel as a small business owner. The total amount of tax paid is paltry; I could afford to pay more (and indeed I generally vote along liberal lines). But the constant nagging, begging, and hands out from 20+ different government departments for money and my time while providing absolutely terrible customer service in return... I can easily see why small business owners vote Republican, even if that won't even solve the problem.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoHas it gotten considerably worse in the last, say, 15 years? Or am I just more aware of it? (I am not a small business owner - I'm looking at it from the outside.)
- emodendroket 11y agoI mean, OK, yes, regulation costs money. So? "It costs money" is not, in and of itself, a reason not to do something.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoWell, when "things" (regulation, or taxes, or transport, or transaction costs, or whatever) cost less, then more things become economically viable, so more things happen. That is, the overall economy grows. We've had a stagnant economy for the last 6 years (at least). It is my impression that we have also had an increasing burden of regulation in that time. Are they related? I can't prove it, but I suspect yes, at least to some degree.
- emodendroket 11y agoAnd what is that impression based on?
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoIt's primarily based on working in business. But it's hard for me to tell if the regulations are becoming more burdensome, or if I'm just becoming more aware of them as my role becomes more senior. It's also somewhat based on my perception of how many regulatory hoops I'd have to jump through to start a business. Again, though, I don't know if the hoops were always there and my awareness of them grew, or if the number of hoops increased.
- jameshart 11y agoBut when regulations are absent, amon the things that happen, more bad things happen. So if removing regulation increase the amount (or value) of things that happen, but it also increases the cost of the things that happen, then - depending on the balance of cost and value, removing that regulation may be a net negative.
- pm24601 11y agoIn this case the stagnation was caused by a lack of banking regulations. Look up Glass-Steagall Act ( http://www.nytimes.com/topic/subject/glasssteagall-act-1933 http://www.nytimes.com/topic/subject/glasssteagall-act-1933 ) The act was repealed and banks blew up the economy - the same way they did in 1929.
- curun1r 11y agoMy view of this is obviously colored by having worked as a developer, but I see the legal code as being analogous to writing source code. They both establish rules by which processes run. It's almost like source code that's being run by millions of humans rather than machines. And similarly when you write source code, adding a couple of if clauses or function calls to verify data doesn't really impose a performance penalty or make the code unreadable. But, over time, if you continue to litter your code with these small conditionals, it becomes harder and harder to reason about and the combined weight of those little changes can introduce some performance penalty. This is often referred to as technical debt and requires that the programmer delve into all of the various conditions that have been added and attempt to understand and simplify them such that the overall behavior is more or less unchanged. I see this article as not a call for reduced regulation but, instead, as a call to address our legislative debt. We need our representatives to stop simply piling on new regulations and, instead, distill everything we currently have into something that makes compliance easier without losing the spirit of the legislation. This won't be easy for many reasons, not least among them that laws don't have refactoring tools and unit tests to ensure that the simplified version maintains the existing behavior and our combative, partisan system means that refactoring our laws would introduce opportunities for partisan politics and debating over the existing behavior, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try. Because the alternative is all the bad things listed in the article. And from my experience with technical debt, the longer it's allowed to accumulate, the harder it is to fix and the less likely people are to even attempt a fix.
- emodendroket 11y agoIt seems to me like the problem is the complexity of the laws; the author complains about enforcement/compliance issues. I don't know how you can really more efficiently ensure employers aren't cheating workers of their breaks.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- benbenolson 11y agoI agree completely with this article; as the son of a contractor, I've heard countless stories about how city regulations, without exception, cause good business practices to become frustrating. Not only is it frustrating, but even in principle such regulations are definitely overstepping the bounds of government; no government should regulate how a business should operate. The market will decide that.
- teddyh 11y agoIf there are no regulations preventing it, a business will externalize¹ all its costs to be paid by the whole of society instead of the costs being paid by the business itself. Society naturally has an incentive to not allow any and all parties to impose costs on it, so regulations are created which disallow externalizing costs. In the long run, having regulations is cheaper for a company than having all other companies in existence heaping externalized costs on it — this is why we live in a society instead of a jungle. ① https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality
- burkaman 11y agoThere's always a balance, but the market only decides how a business should make the most profit, right? The market doesn't naturally motivate anyone to adopt fair labor practices or environmentally friendly policies. If you're getting pressured to fix those things, the market would probably tell you to hire a better PR firm.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoCan you share an example of a good business practice that is frustrated by any city's regulations?
- icelancer 11y agoSure. I wanted to build a frame for loading things in my facility (don't want to disclose too much, but I work in sports science). I took plans to the local office and someone there said "Can't have anything load-bearing from the ceiling otherwise you need permits X and Y." Fair enough. Building codes being what they are, that's fine with me. I suggested a modified free-standing frame and took plans to the office. Same employee said: "Yep, that works. No load on the ceiling, no permit needed." Perfect. Contacted the local welder and paid X tens of thousands of dollars to have it designed and built for me. Go back to the local bureaucratic office and say "Hey, thanks for the help. Here's some pictures, it turned out great." Office now says: "Oh no. That's too tall. You need permit X, Y, and Z now. Estimated cost is now $10,000 for those permits (instead of $0)." "What? I gave you the plans ahead of time, you approved them, and it had the height on there and everything." "Yeah, I misread them apparently. Sorry. You still need the permits." So, there you go. Just one of about 10 hassles I've had with city government here. I could go on and on, but ironically enough I have permits for something unrelated to fill out.
- nathan_long 11y agoThis reminds me a lot of the tax code. One special case is painless. A whole pile means that millions of worker hours are wasted trying to fill out the forms correctly, and millions of dollars paid to CPAs to do what any citizen ought to be able to do in minutes. Both with taxes and regulations, it's death by a thousand cuts. If you try to fix it, you'll hear "but soy farmers need tax breaks" and "but workers need to have good office chairs". Individually, each claim sounds reasonable. Collectively, it's a mess. I sometimes fantasize of ways to limit this. Eg, have all laws sunset, so we have to prioritize renewing the most important. Or set absolute size limits on areas of regulation - like a one-page tax code (with specified font and margins). But likely none of it would work, humans being so good at exploiting systems for personal gain.
- kspaans 11y agoThe UK is for-real working on simplifying their tax code: https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/office-of-tax-simplification https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/office-of-tax-si... At the moment they are trying to harmonize income tax and National Insurance (which is not entirely unlike income tax (especially because it all goes into the same pot), but it has exemptions for various groups which income tax does not (e.g. seniors collecting their pensions). So any change will invariably throw some group under the bus, which is why it's politically hard to do.)
- nkurz 11y agoI appreciated this description of the difference between American and Swedish tax preparation by some who files both: Our US federal and state forms tax forms were more than 30 pages long last year, downloaded completely blank. During the two weeks we'll spend in Wisconsin this summer, our main job will be to get our taxes done. I'll wade through stacks of bank and credit card records line by line, documenting all professional income beyond our wages and scanning for every possible business or charitable deduction. Once this is done, we — like the majority of US taxpayers — will hire a tax professional who charges us $500 to review and co-sign our work. Tax-preparation services cost American taxpayers more than $32 billion per year. My wife, Betty, and I each have a PhD, but that's not enough to understand IRS instructions. Finally, with a great sigh of relief, our marriage still intact, we'll sign the forms and send them to the IRS. Of course, despite our great efforts, we don't know whether the IRS is going to be happy or not. We might get audited and have to dig up all this stuff again, because the government has three years to check and revise our returns. In Sweden, the four-page tax form comes in the mail already filled out. On a Saturday morning, Betty and I take our coffee to the couch and review the forms. Seeing they look reasonable, as they always do, we "sign" with a text from our phones. In 15 minutes we are done. We don't have to hire a tax consultant, and we avoid fights about whether a print cartridge bought at the drugstore is a business expense or not. http://www.vox.com/2016/4/8/11380356/swedish-taxes-love http://www.vox.com/2016/4/8/11380356/swedish-taxes-love
- 3pt14159 11y agoYou can have both a safely regulated economy as well as a non-burdensome one. America has it particularly bad because a good portion of the population doesn't believe in regulations _at all_. A smarter strategy would be to see what other countries in the world do that is both effective and efficient.
- emodendroket 11y agoAmerica's case is particularly complex, I think, because of the extent to which rules for everything vary between states or even municipalities.
- kspaans 11y agoCanada is in the same boat, with taxes and regulations changing between provinces. Yet they don't manage quite as much complexity in their tax code!
- emodendroket 11y agoYes, there are a handful of federal systems like this, but I think they end up increasing costs pretty significantly for people who want to operate nationally.
- maxxxxx 11y agoThat's because the political dialog in the US supports only extreme viewpoints. "Regulations are good and no change needed" or "Regulations bad and all need to be abolished". There is no place for saying that some work and some don't and need to be tweaked.
- wtbob 11y ago> America has it particularly bad because a good portion of the population doesn't believe in regulations _at all_. I don't think our crappy regulations are properly blameable on the people who believe regulations are crappy, but rather on the sort of people we hire and retain as civil servants. 'Good enough for government work,' I'm told, used to be praise; it sure isn't any longer. Nowadays both civil servants and employees of large corporations are bureaucrats first, servants second (if at all).
- lsiebert 11y agoI think a fair bit of regulation around employment has stepped up as unions have been weakened. Strong unions allowed people to band together to prevent unfair working conditions, but since the unions were dependent fundamentally on the business, they had to keep in mind real business requirements in their asks. Governments trying to protect workers from unfair situations don't have the give and take of collective bargaining. I feel like most businesses would probably prefer to pay workers more because of collective bargaining and worry less about compliance, but a variety of legal and social changes keep collective bargaining from happening. Unions in California were criticized in a recent forbes opinion piece I read for wanting to exempt union run shops from the minimum wage, but frankly, that seems like a sensible position to take. Unfortunately most advocates of the free market seem to hate unions, so any advantage collective bargaining might have over government regulation in terms of giving employees a fair deal while keeping regulatory costs low gets downplayed. edit: I put a space between any and advantage to fix a typo.
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago> Unions in California were criticized in a recent forbes opinion piece I read for wanting to exempt union run shops from the minimum wage, but frankly, that seems like a sensible position to take. I can sort of see that, because those employees (supposedly) have the union to take care of them. But if below minimum wage isn't enough to live on, below minimum wage plus having to pay union dues isn't enough, either. And "it's legal to do that to union employees but not to non-union employees" reeks of double standard.
- lawpoop 11y agoIt allows them some leverage over their constituents. For instance, in Michigan, a big union state, there is no state law mandating lunch or other breaks. That way, unions can say to employees, "Without a union, your employer can deny you a lunch or bathroom break." From a naive perspective, it has historically been ironically anti-union politicians who have backed worker protections, precisely because it takes ammunition away from unions. Why do you need a union if all the benefits are already written into law? Less union shops mean less union voters. But, to argue for the unions, not only do they negotiate wages, but also benefits. Maybe you aren't getting the minimum wage, but you might be getting better health care, a retirement account, overtime, paid vacation, sick time, flex time, etc. Whereas a non-union employer can say "We're paying a $15 minimum wage so we can't afford health insurance, vacation, etc." With a minimum wage, all you're guaranteed is that wage (other state laws aside).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ThomPete 11y agoAs someone who both has done business in Denmark and in the US I am always reminded how relative it all is. So yes it's burdensome but it shouldn't be something that you as a business owner should deal with. You have lawyers and financial advisors and staff for that when your business become too complex. On the flipside you have access to a huge huge market which every other country in the world is envying. The problem is that because employees don't have proper representation as most unions have been wiped out, or have too much representation through too powerful unions, the government is forced to go in and implement regulation. Denmark have something called the Danish model which basically ensures that the employers and the unions on their members behalf negotiate the basic terms only with the government as an intermediary. It's not perfect and it's showing signs of erosion because unions across the world are loosing the battle against the employers. But it would probably be a good thing for the US system to implement something like that on a state basis.
- caseysoftware 11y ago> So yes it's burdensome but it shouldn't be something that you as a business owner should deal with. You have lawyers and financial advisors and staff for that when your business become too complex. But how do the lawyers and advisors get the information? Someone has to collect it. Then, as someone collects it, it must be validated and/or reviewed in some way to be considered "trusted" in some regard. Then the other side - regulators - must have a way to spot check and confirm/validate the information which implies investigators and potentially field investigators. Since most companies aren't going to allow strangers to roam around the office, these investigators probably need to be escorted while on site. Unless your underlying goal is really "full employment via regulatory burden" and then this is on the right track.
- ThomPete 11y agoProblems like these are opportunities. An opening to build a business which helps making complexity easier. It's actually in many ways a feature not a bug.
- 11y ago
- duaneb 11y agoWhat is the OP suggesting instead?
- emodendroket 11y ago"Just let me do whatever I want; trust me."
- danielweber 11y agoGeorge McGovern, Democratic Presidential candidate in 1972, wrote in 1992 about trying to run a business after getting out of politics http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052970203406404578070543545022704 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240529702034064045780705... (google the headline for the full article) "I also wish that during the years I was in public office I had had this firsthand experience about the difficulties business people face every day. That knowledge would have made me a better U.S. senator and a more understanding presidential contender." and "The problem we face as legislators is: Where do we set the bar so that it is not too high to clear? I don't have the answer. I do know that we need to start raising these questions more often."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Bluestrike2 11y agoA huge part of the problem is that many legislators and regulators don’t understand the economic theory behind regulation and government intervention in the first place. Generally speaking, the goal is to price in negative externalities. In some cases, that can extend to disincentivizing certain behaviors as well. You also have to acknowledge that, just as certain market forces can cause distortions, so too can government actions. Regardless of your school of thought, there’s no escaping the realization that regulation is an incredibly nuanced issue. It’s not black and white, and never has been. There’s also a ton of room for abuse, both willful and through neglect. In general, this is probably what most people are thinking of when they talk about regulations being bad. As an example, and apologies in advance for the length, my dad’s family is in the cemetery industry. Over the past few months, a few members of the Pennsylvania Senate have pushed a bill—Senate Bill 874—that changes how cemeteries handle funeral merchandise (caskets, vaults, bronze markers, etc.). Currently, 70% of retail price of pre-need merchandise is put into a trust fund until the merchandise is delivered. It’s been this way since the 60s in Pennsylvania and most other states, and there have never really been any problems. The money sits in trust, earns interest, and when the merchandise is ready to be delivered, is used to pay for the merchandise. Very, very simple stuff. Among other things, SB 874 would change that funding requirement to 100%. The biggest problem with that is that there are costs associated with the sale—offices, marketing, sales staff, etc.—that can’t be deferred. So you have two options: (1) you quit selling pre-need merchandise altogether, or (2) you raise non-merchandise prices (lots, mausoleum crypts, etc.) to compensate. And you start making significant cuts, starting with the sales staff. The significant hit to a cemetery’s cash flow also means it’s harder for them to pay for maintenance costs without tapping into their perpetual care funds (a big issue for smaller cemeteries and those that are mostly full), meaning that money isn’t there earning interest for the future. SB 874 also makes some other changes like ending constructive delivery on caskets and vaults and applies the FTC Funeral Rule to PA cemeteries. There’s an argument to be made about constructive delivery of caskets, but existing regulations still apply and the practice is rare to begin with. So even if you’re worried about a casket “rotting away in a warehouse” as one person put it, the cemetery is still responsible for it as it’s under their care. If the casket is damaged, they have to make good that damage. And as for vaults, they’re large concrete boxes that go in the ground. They’re very tough, hard to damage, and installing them in bulk leads to significant cost savings. By not permitting cemeteries to constructively deliver them, you wind up raising the cost of both the vault and the installation to the detriment of consumers. As for the Funeral Rule, even the FTC says that “[many] of the disclosures required by the Funeral Rule make little sense if they are imposed on cemeteries” and that “there is insufficient evidence that commercial cemeteries, crematories, and third-party sellers of funeral goods are engaged in widespread unfair or deceptive acts or practices.” They advised the PA Senate that SB 874 would “lessen competition, resulting in potentially higher prices and fewer options for consumers, without countervailing benefits to consumers.” So basically, we have a bill that would make significant changes to the cemetery industry for no verifiable reasons. There’s no evidence of any malfeasance in PA cemeteries over the course of decades, and no benefit to the consumer for the changes. And any benefit there might be would be wiped out by the increased costs elsewhere, to say nothing of the decreased competition as cemeteries exist the pre-need merchandise market. And the other regulations and contract law protect the consumer in the few specific hypotheticals that they’re worried about. So why push it? Well, that’s where it gets interesting. One of the senators sponsoring the bill happens to own a large funeral home near Philadelphia. With cemeteries not selling merchandise, people would have no choice but to go to the funeral director. The bill originally came up after a public company, StoneMor, signed a lease agreement to operate the Philadelphia Diocese’s cemeteries, including the right to sell merchandise for them. So Philly funeral directors came up with this bill as a means of fighting back, and the rest of the state’s funeral directors went along with it because it would benefit them significantly. At the very least, it’s a massive conflict of interest and a classic example of political corruption for private gain. Why should any elected representative be permitted to push legislation that would have a direct benefit on their own business’s bottom line? When people bemoan government regulation and intervention, it’s stuff like this that they’re thinking about. Every time a legislator jumps the shark with something like this, they make it that much harder for legitimate government intervention. The end result is the sort of gridlock we have now, where things are black and white and each side shouts slogans at one another. Sorry for the length.
- mistermann 11y agoTo me this is extremely similar to change control requirements on systems - yes there is a very good reason for them, but if in practice the people administering these rules lose track of why the rules exist, have a lack of understanding of the technology involved (therefore unable to properly judge risk), and then throw some political chicanery where some people are eager for any new tool they can use to "enforce their authoritah" on those below them in the organizational chain, and you end up with an environment where doing things takes twice as long, but you're not actually any safer than you were without the controls.
- ecobiker 11y agoWhile the tax code should be simplified, it's possible to automate most of the rules anyway. It should be as simple as upload W2(s), link your trading accounts, answer a few questions and be done with it for most people. The software need not satisfy every usecase for everyone in the country. Are there an free/open source tax filing software?
- dsp1234 11y agoNote that this is basically what the 1040-EZ[0] is. It has the benefit of being one page, with simple instructions and it covers a lot of people. • Your filing status is single or married filing jointly. If you are not sure about your filing status, see instructions. • You (and your spouse if married filing jointly) were under age 65 and not blind at the end of 2015. If you were born on January 1, 1951, you are considered to be age 65 at the end of 2015. • You do not claim any dependents. For information on dependents, see Pub. 501. • Your taxable income (line 6) is less than $100,000. • You do not claim any adjustments to income. For information on adjustments to income, use the Tax Topics listed under Adjustments to Income at www.irs.gov/taxtopics (see instructions). • The only tax credit you can claim is the earned income credit (EIC). The credit may give you a refund even if you do not owe any tax. You do not need a qualifying child to claim the EIC. For information on credits, use the Tax Topics listed under Tax Credits at www.irs.gov/taxtopics (see instructions). If you received a Form 1098-T or paid higher education expenses, you may be eligible for a tax credit or deduction that you must claim on Form 1040A or Form 1040. For more information on tax benefits for education, see Pub. 970. If you can claim the premium tax credit or you received any advance payment of the premium tax credit in 2015, you must use Form 1040A or Form 1040. • You had only wages, salaries, tips, taxable scholarship or fellowship grants, unemployment compensation, or Alaska Permanent Fund dividends, and your taxable interest was not over $1,500. But if you earned tips, including allocated tips, that are not included in box 5 and box 7 of your Form W-2, you may not be able to use Form 1040EZ (see instructions). If you are planning to use Form 1040EZ for a child who received Alaska Permanent Fund dividends, see instructions. As for free offerings, these can also be found via the IRS[1], but generally apply to lower income amounts. [0] - https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1040ez.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1040ez.pdf [1] - https://apps.irs.gov/app/freeFile/jsp/wizard.jsp?ck https://apps.irs.gov/app/freeFile/jsp/wizard.jsp?ck
- crazy1van 11y agoRegulations are great for handling tragedy of the commons scenarios. Eg, it's in a single business's best interest to dump chemicals in our shared water supply, but it is in the common people's interest to have clean water. So we regulate polluting the water. However, most regulations I encounter are more of the Baptists and Bootleggers variety. They both want highly regulated liquor for totally different reasons. Just like many large businesses are fine with extra regulations that well intentioned Do-Gooders suggest because the big businesses know it will block small innovative competitors from entering their market. It's so frustrating to see the anti-Corporate crowd cheer for more regulations. They're just cementing their place in society.
- x1798DE 11y ago> Regulations are great for handling tragedy of the commons scenarios. I have never seen any actual evidence for this. There is strong reasoning to say markets are bad at handing tragedies of the commons, but it does not follow from that that government is good at it.
- crazy1van 11y agoI think there's a difference between regulating something and using government over markets to solve the problem. For example, if the goal is a cleaner river, the inefficient way of solving the problem would be mandating a certain cleaning technology or giving a tax break to companies that install specific purification systems. That leads to a mindset of box checking compliance and the most politically well-connected companies winning out. The better way is to impose a fine or maximum on the externality -- water pollution in this example -- and let the market work. Now the polluting company has an incentive to find the best anti-pollution techniques at the lowest cost and other companies can compete by developing different anti-pollution methods.
- enraged_camel 11y agoMarkets may be good at preventing tragedies of the commons, but they may also fail to do so. Consider the case of a lake fished by several fishing boats. Each fishing boat consumes a percentage of their daily catch and sells the rest for profit. The nature of the lake makes it a zero-sum resource: if one fishing boat catches more fish, it means less fish for the others. The problem: every fishing boat has a short-term incentive to overfish, since more fish lead to more profits. This incentivizes every fishing boat to catch as much fish as possible, until there's no more fish. That's the tragedy of the commons, and there's nothing the market can do to fix this. By the way, I didn't make up this scenario. There's a ton of examples of this exact same thing happening all over the world, not just with fisheries but with any kind of shared resource ("the commons"). You can read more here: http://www.dummies.com/how-to/content/ten-reallife-examples-of-the-tragedy-of-the-common.html http://www.dummies.com/how-to/content/ten-reallife-examples-...
- rayiner 11y ago> But it also falls most heavily on smaller businesses, which cannot afford staffs of pricey compliance specialists to make sure that their desk chairs meet the new California workplace seating requirements. This may help explain why the number of firms is falling, and markets are consolidating. The inefficiency with which small businesses deal with regulatory compliance is just one example of a general phenomenon. Small businesses are inefficient at pretty much everything. For example, there is no way cab companies, the largest of which may have a few hundred drivers, could ever deploy the kind of software infrastructure Uber has developed. Mom-and-pops can never compete with Amazon's or Wal-Mart's integrated and unified systems for warehousing, picking, shipping, and logistics. As technology makes it easier to manage increasingly-large enterprises and unlocks economies of scale, consolidation will continue apace, with or without the impact of regulatory compliance. At the end of the day, someone has to make sure workers aren't being abused by being forced to work for more hours than they are paid for. As long we consider that a legitimate burden we put on businesses, we have to face the fact that the relative difficulty of compliance is just one of the many disadvantages of being small.
- icebraining 11y agoFor example, there is no way cab companies, the largest of which may have a few hundred drivers, could ever deploy the kind of software infrastructure Uber has developed. No, but a small business could build and support the software for many of them, as a service. In fact, there are plenty of startups doing just that. Scale doesn't have to come from building up, it can come from building horizontally, in a web of small businesses supporting each other. Unless you're facing a stupid number of regulations, which scale linearly with the number of firms, encouraging the centralization and monopolization of markets.
- rayiner 11y agoSo some company builds the software. Can cab companies afford to run that software on their own server farms? Of course not. So the software company sells it as a service, running everything on its own AWS instances. At that point, there is zero reason for that company to not just be Uber.
- jxramos 11y agoThis is precisely the focus of the 10000 commandments: https://cei.org/10KC https://cei.org/10KC, which says regulation is tantamount to a backdoor tax more or less. "Ten Thousand Commandments, points out: regulations impose enormous burdens on American consumers, businesses, and the economy. Unnecessary and meddlesome overregulation and intervention create uncertainty that slows innovation and economic growth. But unfortunately, regulations get little attention in policy debates. Unlike taxes, they are difficult to quantify because they are unbudgeted and often indirect."
- joesmo 11y agoBusinesses cannot be trusted. If they could be trusted, you wouldn't need all this regulation. Even as it stands, many businesses don't follow regulations and there are generally no repercussions for that. It's the employees who always suffer, who don't get their lunch breaks or health insurance or whatever it is they are legally allowed by law but denied by their employers. Sorry, it's impossible to side with businesses on this one given the track record of most businesses.
- strommen 11y agoSo California requires employers to document their employees' lunch breaks. Does anybody think that this law was passed simply on a whim? Of course not. And the same is true for nearly other regulation that is taking up business' time and money. The people at fault here are those employers that did not let their employees have lunch breaks. And the companies that did not provide safety gear, and that refused to hire non-whites, and that wantonly dumped toxic chemicals in the rivers. We need regulations because some people are scumbags.
- good_sir_ant 11y agoJust not the regulators.
- CydeWeys 11y agoI can't believe how far down in the comments I had to scroll to see this sentiment, and that it's sitting partially grayed no less! To me it's completely obvious; if businesses could be trusted not to abuse their employees, then nannying regulations mandating lunch breaks wouldn't be necessary. Since businesses repeatedly abuse the power imbalances they have over their workers (including removing lunch breaks), there you have the regulations.
- wtbob 11y ago> The people at fault here are those employers that did not let their employees have lunch breaks. > We need regulations because some people are scumbags. I'm not certain why we need lunch-break regulations at all. If one doesn't want to work under one set of working conditions, choose a job with another set. After years of hopeless complaining and misery I did so awhile back and I've never been happier. Be active, not passive.
- dbcurtis 11y agoDocumentable, reasonable, compliance costs should be a tax credit. (Yes, "reasonable" is quantifiable. Think about courts awarding reasonable attorney's fees. There are decades of history around this concept.)
- sxcurry 11y agoIf you'd like to know more about the libertarian blogger who wrote this piece, check out her profile on the S.H.A.M.E (Shame the Hacks who Abuse Media Ethics) page: http://shameproject.com/profile/megan-mcardle/ http://shameproject.com/profile/megan-mcardle/
- emodendroket 11y agoExcellent. I love the SHAME Project.
- good_sir_ant 11y agoTIL people who claim to be 'smart' on this site (of all sites) thing regulations == solutions. Too cute.
- natrius 11y agoEveryone is familiar with the idea that companies pay politicians to weaken regulations, but more people need to realize that they pay politicians to strengthen regulations as well. Expertise in regulatory compliance is a competitive advantage that all incumbents have. They can create barriers to entry by making regulatory compliance harder. Companies bribe politicians who hate regulations to remove regulations they hate. Companies bribe politicians who like regulations to add regulations that they can comply with more easily than their competitors. Centralized democracy is fundamentally flawed because votes can be bought.
- partiallypro 11y agoRegulatory Capture and Public Choice Theory should be taught in high school. It's counterintuitive on the surface, but makes a lot of sense when you see it in action. Regulations are incredibly hard to remove and very rarely are removed; on any level, state, local or federal. It's much easier to write new regulations and starve your competition.
- tn13 11y agoThere is nothing surprising about this. All government regulations are like this at one point people simply stop giving fucks to these rules. I am pretty sure everyone company out there violating some kind of regulation. Do you know that it is illegal to throw a dry cell in your usual waste basket ? In such systems people who have complete disregard for law, who are exploitative who are willing to bribe or threaten government official tend to succeed at faster rate than usual law abiding citizens leading to India or China like situations.
- pm24601 11y agoLets see. The poor Mr. Warren Meyer is crying about being forced to document and prove he is not taking advantage of his employees. Or in other words, California is doing the job of government: protecting those who cannot defend themselves from being ripped off. Mr. Meyer needs to understand that businesses have been engaged in wage theft for a very, very long time. ( read more here: http://www.wagetheft.org/ http://www.wagetheft.org/ ) No business owner should cry crocodile tears about the government doing its job of protecting citizens from being forced to work off the clock or being denied lawfully entitled breaks. The regulations were put in place because businesses ripped off workers. This is the same reason why minimum wage is needed, child labor laws, health and safety regulations, etc.