3 ms·
I've only seen LCARS themes, but I do like the concept that everything is displayed on a screen, at once, with no overlapping windows. Overlapping windows are
by djsumdog 11y ago
I've only seen LCARS themes, but I do like the concept that everything is displayed on a screen, at once, with no overlapping windows.
Overlapping windows are the worst possible UI decision ever. I've been using tiling window managers for four years now and I never want to go back.
- barrkel 11y agoOverlapping windows in a cascade (so the bottom left corners act a bit like a tab selector) are my preferred window layout. Random overlapping doesn't work particularly well. Any time you have to manage the z-index of more than one window, something has gone wrong. Thus cascading. I can't stand tiling though. Either everything is too small, or you can't get enough stuff on screen at once.
- creshal 11y ago> I can't stand tiling though. Either everything is too small, or you can't get enough stuff on screen at once. Or everything has the wrong aspect ratio.
- r00fus 11y agoWhy would you want cascading windows over tabbed interfaces (e.g.: any modern browser)? What does it actually buy you?
- yoz-y 11y agoFor me overlapping windows are better for using two applications at the same time - copy pasting, drag and dropping between them etc. This is because their position is deterministic. Tabs are better when I have a boatload of unrelated pages (e.g.: tabs). This is also why I find tabbed interfaces in code editors useless.
- elsurudo 11y agoI find tabbed editors useful in that they allow you to open the current "working set" of files, and then disregard the rest of the project files. After I open up the working set, I usually close the tree view (Sublime, in my case) so my code has more room.
- barrkel 11y agoDifferent windows have different good sizes. For example, I don't run my browser maximized, because I don't want web pages in landscape; acres of margin or very long lines - neither choice is good. The viewport of my browser is nearly square (1500 x 1300). Terminals don't work great with very long lines either; man, less etc. adjust to terminal width making lines harder to read. My scratchpad app I keep for notes is generally notepad shaped, i.e. taller than it is wide, but not as wide as a terminal window. My password manager (KeePass2) is the only other really common app. I don't interact with it very often other than via hotkey. I keep Emacs/IDE maximized on a different screen.
- alphapapa 11y agoI use KWin, and it has configurable keyboard shortcuts for basically everything, so I have ones configured to effectively tile windows into halves or corners of the screen. This makes very good use of 16:9 monitors. But sometimes an overlapping window is very useful. For example, I'm watching a fullscreen video, but I want to chat with a friend in an instant messaging app. I can put the conversation window on top of the video in a corner of the screen where it doesn't block anything important. Or I'm doing some kind of graphical work, image editing, web design, etc, and I only need to see part of a window, but it needs to fill the height of the screen. I can put other programs on top of the parts I don't need to see. Tiling is great, but overlapping windows have their place too.
- digi_owl 11y agoHow i have pretty much operated the GUI since the early days of Windows 95. Run everything full screen and use the taskbar as a kind of tab switcher. The way i understand LCARS is that you would have a primary activity up front, and then a menu of other activities down the side.
- mjevans 11y agoOverlapping windows are wonderful in X-mouse style mode. When your soul interaction with a normally large window is just a tiny strip on the bottom, it's like you've divided a single display in to something normally thin and wide (a console for example), and another thing on top that is slightly smaller but otherwise that you want to interact with. The nice part about this layout over a purely tiling window one is that the console is entirely ready for you to switch to it being the full screen when you want to read the backlog or do more complex work with it.