3 ms·
I don't think the headline aligns with the article, at all. The article is reporting academic work that postulates the elements that moved people from bands to
by tomrod 11y ago
I don't think the headline aligns with the article, at all.
The article is reporting academic work that postulates the elements that moved people from bands to authoritarianism, and how this particular Lima, Peru site highlights this anthropologic theory, rather than identifying a specific location where, pandemic-like, authority began.
- mc32 11y agoTo some extent that's true but they still draw conclusions from inferring things from the architecture and graffiti and then they take that to make conclusive statements about what exactly was happening there and why.
- CapitalistCartr 11y agoThat is a much nicer interpretation of the article. I didn't get that out of it, but after reading your comment, and re-reading the article, perhaps the archaeologist meant that, but the reporter failed to make that clear. I can certainly believe that.
- drostie 11y agoI think the archaeologist almost surely meant this and the reporter completely screwed up the story. It would be functionally insane to think that authoritarianism came fundamentally out of a New World archaeological site that is 3000 years ago. For example, in order to sustain this belief you would have to believe that someone from this culture traveled to Africa and then invented time travel, so that they could go back to the mid-2000s BC and give the idea to the Old-Kingdom Egyptians. Just to give some numbers by rectal extraction: I am about 98% sure that a seasoned academic from Stanford would not be so clumsy with his speech as to say outright that he thought this had happened; I am only maybe 75% sure that a given reporter understands a given scientist's research, so given that we have this report I'd estimate .98 * .25 / (.98 * .25 + .02 * .75) = 94% chance that the reporter misunderstood the scientist, and only a 6% chance that the scientist really believes what the reporter was saying. It's possible but I definitely think it's highly unlikely.
- dfan 11y agoYeah, the headline should really be "Stanford archaeologist traces the origins of authority in the Andes of Peru".