5 ms·
So this is where authoritarianism arose? And it propagated to other places how? Or is this mostly conjecture and lots of guesswork? I like fantasy and imagin
by mc32 11y ago
So this is where authoritarianism arose? And it propagated to other places how? Or is this mostly conjecture and lots of guesswork?
I like fantasy and imagination as much as the next person but I think drawing stark conclusions from architecture and "graffiti" should be taken with a grain of salt. And I guess ancient Egyptians were not authoritarian, or, what exactly were they?
- CapitalistCartr 11y agoI thought this was odd because, after the Agricultural Revolution, what society wasn't authoritarian? It seems to have spontaneously arose everywhere.
- mc32 11y agoYeah exactly. It'd be like thinking we can trace "fire" to a single location. These things arise with "need". The right conditions present themselves and these things (inventions, discoveries processes, rituals, etc, etc) arise to fill in the vacuum. Just like this archeologist probably feels some pressure to produce something exciting during his fellowship at the center.
- dschiptsov 11y agoThis is called science nowadays. We had a whole bunch of degenerates who publish papers which prove that so-called proto-Russians wrote Vedas because symbols similar to swastikas has been found on some excavations somewhere in taiga. Idiots, idiots everywhere. The formalized process of extraction of knowledge of underlying fundamental principles from surrounding Brahman is what we call scientific inquiry. The goal, emphasised by Buddha, is to see things as they are, without piling up meaningless abstraction and producing himeras and dogmas. According to the principle of similar environmental conditioning, similar social formations would emerge due to similar selection pressures. The notion of authority goes back to families with dominant individuals and to the collective child care as an effective evolutionary strategy. "Scientists" who have understood as little as this would never have published such nonsense like a single origin of phenomena which is a natural adaptation and is shared among many animals. Similarly, segregated societies could arrive at similar symbols and notions independently, by observing and reflecting on the similar (the same) environment, without any connection whatsoever.
- dredmorbius 11y agoI suspect the more immediate problem is with university publicity offices. Stanford's is particularly bad in this regard. Though much academic science has flaws as well.
- tomrod 11y agoI don't think the headline aligns with the article, at all. The article is reporting academic work that postulates the elements that moved people from bands to authoritarianism, and how this particular Lima, Peru site highlights this anthropologic theory, rather than identifying a specific location where, pandemic-like, authority began.
- mc32 11y agoTo some extent that's true but they still draw conclusions from inferring things from the architecture and graffiti and then they take that to make conclusive statements about what exactly was happening there and why.
- CapitalistCartr 11y agoThat is a much nicer interpretation of the article. I didn't get that out of it, but after reading your comment, and re-reading the article, perhaps the archaeologist meant that, but the reporter failed to make that clear. I can certainly believe that.
- drostie 11y agoI think the archaeologist almost surely meant this and the reporter completely screwed up the story. It would be functionally insane to think that authoritarianism came fundamentally out of a New World archaeological site that is 3000 years ago. For example, in order to sustain this belief you would have to believe that someone from this culture traveled to Africa and then invented time travel, so that they could go back to the mid-2000s BC and give the idea to the Old-Kingdom Egyptians. Just to give some numbers by rectal extraction: I am about 98% sure that a seasoned academic from Stanford would not be so clumsy with his speech as to say outright that he thought this had happened; I am only maybe 75% sure that a given reporter understands a given scientist's research, so given that we have this report I'd estimate .98 * .25 / (.98 * .25 + .02 * .75) = 94% chance that the reporter misunderstood the scientist, and only a 6% chance that the scientist really believes what the reporter was saying. It's possible but I definitely think it's highly unlikely.
- dfan 11y ago
- panglott 11y agoIt sounds more like this is an example of the rise of authority within a specific society, examined as a window onto social processes at the beginning of the development of authority. There is no way that cultural phenomena from Chavin disseminated worldwide.
- duaneb 11y agoThis just implies the first known appearance (archaeologically), not necessarily a, erm, common root.