5 ms·
Stupid question. For any other use than a satellite where weight is critical, isn't it easier to protect the computer with a heavy enough layer of metal and not
by cm2187 11y ago
Stupid question. For any other use than a satellite where weight is critical, isn't it easier to protect the computer with a heavy enough layer of metal and not worry about radiations, or are we talking about radiations that are so high that it wouldn't help?
- Unklejoe 11y agoGood question. I'm not sure about the specifics of the stackoverflow poster's application, but for my case, they're used in space. It's my understanding that you would need a very thick layer of metal to actually protect a device. Generally, lead works, but the thickness required would mean that your device would be extremely heavy. However, like you said, this isn't a problem for ground applications. Also, apparently water works well too. This is all honestly beyond my knowledge though. Our customers do their own qualification since these are COTS devices, so any failures may be handled on their end by making separate enclosures or using another vendor's system as a backup. They haven't actually asked us to implement any software based risk mitigation, but I investigated it on my own.
- 0xFFC 11y agoAnother stupid question, can you suggest a reading about reliable software development ? (I prefer book) BTW thank you for excellent information in your comment.
- Unklejoe 11y agoSadly, I don't know of any good resources. It's kind of a specific topic, and it wasn't really part of my task to consider these issues, so I only spent a small amount of time researching it myself. I believe most of the studies were conducted by NASA, so incorporating that into a search should help.
- StringyBob 11y agoIronically the lead itself is sometimes the source of the radiation causing problems (Pb-210). One small benefit of lead free electronics! Some experiments have used 2000 year old Roman lead to avoid this http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100415/full/news.2010.186.html http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100415/full/news.2010.186.ht... See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-background_steel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-background_steel
- iliis 11y agoMostly, but there are always cases where this is not pratical. For example, the detectors at CERN (or any other particle accelerator probably) contain a lot of electronics (to capture and pre-filter the data) which cannot really be shielded (otherwise you don't have a detector anymore) or moved elsewhere (which would incur a lot of inconvenient delays and additional noise. Also, you don't wan't to lay a few meters of cables for every pixel ;)). Most of the computing power sits in an adjacent cave however where it is quite safe.
- adrianN 11y agoIn most hard rad environments where you want to use a CPU you also want to move the CPU around (eg robots in a reactor). At least in the scenarios that I can think up right now. Weight and size are also important there.
- cshimmin 11y agoOne rad hard environment is detectors at particle accelerators/colliders. There are at least two problems: 1) You'd need a lot of lead to totally shield the equipment, like meters thick. Of course partial shielding reduces the radiation load but unless you can lower it to a negligible amount, you still need to have radiation tolerant code. 2) We generally want to minimize the amount of material in a particle detector, especially at layers nearest the collisions (where radiation is most intense). These inner layers (called trackers) are used to track light charged particles, while the outer layers (called calorimeters) are used to absorb and measure energy. So we need less material throughout to ensure we get good energy measurements by the time particles get to the calorimeter. In addition to using radiation hardened components, a lot of this is mitigated by doing as little computation as possible on the front-end readout electronics. Most of it is switched capacitor arrays, asics, and the occasional FPGA, which can be made fairly reliable since they're basically just responding to clock signals and measuring voltage (or something), and buffering these measurements. The raw data is then piped away from the detector at absurd bitrates to another part of the cavern (called the "counting room") that is much less radioactive and has lots of standard computers/electronics to do further processing.