3 ms·
"Four big clubs -- Manchester United, Chelsea, Manchester City and Arsenal -- have won all the titles in the past 20 years", but they "all had appalling seasons
by toyg 11y ago
"Four big clubs -- Manchester United, Chelsea, Manchester City and Arsenal -- have won all the titles in the past 20 years", but they "all had appalling seasons: Chelsea, [...] Manchester United [...] and Liverpool, the other big club, is seventh."
Er, so Man City and Arsenal are not "big clubs", apparently. Nice "submarine" insult there.
EDIT: another gem: "All teams have always counterattacked, but few have based their game so completely around it."
That's utter drivel. Go read up on Italian teams of the 60s, which were pretty successful at doing exactly that. With all due respect to Claudio Ranieri, he's not really close to the genius of Nereo Rocco or Helenio Herrera.
The innovation of Leicester City is that they used statistics to identify players who could fit this style better than the average, and they recruited a manager who knows how to manage this style of play better than the average. Whether this combination was an accident or not, I think it's still open for debate -- they had a very successful run of games with the previous manager as well.
- radicalbyte 11y agoNo, he's saying that neither Arsenal or Man City are having appalling seasons. They're both doing pretty well. The funny thing is that Spurs are also having a fantastic season, if it wasn't for Leicester this article could have been written by a Spurs fan about their amazing rise up the league.
- ed_blackburn 11y agoWho are incidentally top of the league by most metric other than the one that matters most.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "No, he's saying that neither Arsenal or Man City are having appalling seasons. They're both doing pretty well." As an Arsenal fan, I couldn't disagree with you more. Arsenal have had an awful second half to the season, if they hadn't had a strong start they'd be mid table: http://metro.co.uk/2016/04/14/revealed-arsenals-terrible-league-form-since-christmas-5815262/ http://metro.co.uk/2016/04/14/revealed-arsenals-terrible-lea... Many Arsenal fans are somewhat livid with how this season has played out, with the majority of the anger being directed at the manager and the board.
- macca321 11y agoand Theo.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoThere have been a couple of players who have got some stick, but it's nothing compared to Wenger and Kroenke. Why Wenger seems reluctant to play on form players and is reluctant/unwilling to buy another first class centre back and striker is beyond me.
- blowski 11y agoBlimey. A full on football debate on HN.
- ameen 11y agoAs a Man City fan, I was sure you guys would finally win it. It's as if our managers don't really want to win the PL. Pellegrini and Wenger's stubbornness is an important reason for Leicester and Spurs to lead the table.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoThanks. For what it's worth, don't know what's happened to Man City this season, you were probably missing Aguero early on, but you have enough quality in your squad it should've been easy enough to adapt. What changes do you want Pellegrini to make next season?
- ameen 11y agoI guess you don't follow the EPL closely. Pellegrini announced that he was leaving at the original date his contract ended (end of this season), thereby forcing the club to pre-emptively announce Pep Guardiola. The reason we lost key ties against West Ham, Spurs and Liverpool was fielding players that are defensive liabilities vs. defensively sound ones – Kolarov and Yaya rather than Clichy and Fernando. He also didn't adapt to the game and stuck with his gameplan so there weren't any comebacks in the league. Surprisingly we came back more than twice in our CL campaign, against Sevilla and Borussia Mönchengladbach.
- blowski 11y agoI'm not sure what you mean. He's saying there are 5 big clubs. 4 of them (Man Utd, Chelsea, Man City, Arsenal) have won all the titles in the last 20 years, but all 5 (including "the other big club" Liverpool) had appalling seasons. I don't think he was insulting anyone.
- tomlong 11y agoDon't know why you're getting modded down here. Especially re: counterattacking - Ranieri is an Italian born in 1951! He was brought up watching precisely that kind of counter attacking football, it's in blood. Almost everyone at Leicester I've heard talk about their success attributes it in some part to Nigel Pearson as well.
- ameen 11y agoAs a Man City fan, it's somehow acceptable that we're never considered a big club. We've finished top 3 in the last 5 years, won multiple domestic titles and on track for a 6th yet you'd have English media dubbing our historic CL tie against PSG, El Cashico. The amount of pundits (former Liverpool, United players) in the media is indeed an important reason for that narrative.