3 ms·
> Coder are soldiers paid to do a job. If the army fails, blame the generals that totally do not care about quality and will prefer to pay dozens of obedient co
by eropple 11y ago
> Coder are soldiers paid to do a job. If the army fails, blame the generals that totally do not care about quality and will prefer to pay dozens of obedient coders lower and lower that do not care than be eventually facing opposition based on concern in quality.
"But I was just following orders" isn't an acceptable excuse in any situation. You are inextricably tied to a set of moral obligations by your decision to build things that affect other human beings, and you cannot shirk them or push them upward. They are yours, they remain yours, and attempts to rationalize the abrogation thereof are at best gross.
Own your shit. If you cannot do good and do well, then quit. (I have done this; it is not that hard.)
- carapace 11y agoThat just leaves the field to the incompetents. They are not going to stop inflicting this crappy code on the world just because you quit.
- eropple 11y agoThen own it, and fix it, and be with a clear conscience. I couldn't, at that particular job, and I could do good elsewhere. So I made the decision to do that. "We're just coders, it's not our fault" is not an excuse. Either own your shit (and, implicitly, fix it) or refuse to participate. There is no middle ground.
- SFJulie 11y agoTrying to change job here to avoid taking part in this buffoonery. I can't. Nowadays so much jobs are regulated per diploma/certifications that it is hard beginning again and regain while "older" the momentum for credibility. The funny part I see breadmakers, cooks, construction is also suffering the same problem. I am currently in France, restaurants for average people are so bad, they do stuff that intoxicate people. I can do bread, cooking, fixing bikes and I do better than "pro" nowadays" without a diploma in their field. Something systemic seems to be going on. Like people are just taught to execute and required to obey, and bosses don't know the craft of the people they should lead. Basically being a boss boils down to the capital you can have, and competition seems rigged in favour of people being born wealthy. I don't think that birth merit outweight a sane competition. I find the Figaro monolog that inspired French and US revolution about the old monarchic regimes to be very actual. Weirdly enough author's right says it should be in public domain, but it is impossible to find a link to this essay that is very actual.
- pferde 11y agoThe systemic thing is called "professional managers". In the past, only people "from the trenches" were promoted to manage and lead others. Nowadays, we have managers who studied nothing but management. And it shows.
- SFJulie 11y agoKarl Marx analysis was that through education you can capture the praxis (savoir faire) and transform it into both stealing it from the craftsman and also making expert in doxein (savoir faire) that knows nothing (Donning Kruger effect). I think that it has always fueled my intuition that a profession should be defined by the craftsmanship and not he education.
- carapace 11y agoYou are preaching to the choir: I have quit jobs in the past because they were not serious about doing good work. But my "clear conscience" doesn't help the overall situation. How can we make the industry as a whole less bullshit? That's the question that I want answered.
- SFJulie 11y agoeasy. Be honest without bitterness. And I found asking questions a better way to make people aware. People will first deny we all have shit in the eyes. And say you are exaggerating. But, ask them about their experience in IT, but also every days inconvenience because of loss of quality in product. There is a pattern. People feels like industry don't care anymore about consumers. And let them tell their part. It makes people realize they miss the simple boring life that works. And maybe they saw something you don't see and they can help you and you can help them. My first way to improve this is to help people be better consumer by sharing simple way to spend less and get better products by focusing on rational choices. I also sometimes learn. I also sometime am bullshited. But, you know: trust but check.
- rwallace 11y ago> "But I was just following orders" isn't an acceptable excuse in any situation. On the contrary, it's an acceptable excuse in lots of situations. The finding at Nuremberg was that there is a line beyond which it stops being acceptable, and murder is on the far side of that line. But most things in commerce are on the near side of it. In other words, a moral obligation to give up your job rather than tolerate sloppiness, applies when you're dealing with safety-critical stuff such that sloppiness could get someone killed. It doesn't apply when the sloppiness will cause minor inconvenience.