2 ms·
And I, on the other side (or perhaps in the middle? Is there a middle?) see the AGW debate as important because it teaches critical thinking, it's a great examp
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
And I, on the other side (or perhaps in the middle? Is there a middle?) see the AGW debate as important because it teaches critical thinking, it's a great example of how hard science (such as the absorption spectra of CO2) can get muddled with softer sciences (such as paleoclimate research). It's even a great example of how the activist scientist is his own worst enemy, a lesson that we still seem to not have learned. It's a great discussion about causality -- surely the climate is changing, so the term Climate Change Skeptic is somewhat rigged. From there we can drag out Chomsky and Wittgenstein and talk about how language and definitions are critical to informed debate. And we can hit the Philosophy of Science concepts which usually causes all sorts of consternation.
But still it's not news. And still it's the same old discussion. And still the same people vote the same other people up or down based on their preconceived notions.
Green startups are awesome. Let's hear more about them. Hacking science measurements is also a great topic. I'll read stuff like the VASIMIR drive all day long. You're not going to find people trashing a startup because the startup is solving a problem that they may have political issues with -- at least not that I've seen. (They may ask if you are solving a real problem and if there is a real market, but they'll do that regardless)
Like I said, I'll go another hundred rounds if I have to. It's that important. But I know a topic that people aren't going to change their minds about, and this seems like such a topic. So I'm going to try to restrict my new posts to real news about AGW. Or about how this scientist-as-activist/standards-of-research story develops. But not the I'm-right-and-the-other-guys-are-assholes stuff.