3 ms·
Mozilla of today is run by designers, webheads and "social" personas. As for encrypted email, it could be made very simple. When you set up an account in Thund
by digi_owl 11y ago
Mozilla of today is run by designers, webheads and "social" personas.
As for encrypted email, it could be made very simple. When you set up an account in Thunderbird, have it ask a simple question "do you have an encryption key?". If the user hits no, generate the key pair, and insert the public key by default.
Then starts harvesting public keys from incoming emails, and encrypt by default if sending to an address that has a known public key.
- stinkytaco 11y agoDoesn't this sort of abandon the trust model of PGP? If you make default encryption a part of the system and an elevator pitch bullet point, I don't think it's really fair to call it simple because a UI change would be needed to ensure that though email may be encrypted, users can't necessarily trust the identity of the sender.
- digi_owl 11y agoAnd how will software ever help with that? Put a signed image of the device user at time of sending? You are pretty much walking into the same issue that big media has had with DRM. You can't trust something user facing to be doing the "right" thing unless the whole chain down to the individual chips are certified by entities you control. Right now email is more like sending post cards than letters, yet people treat them like the latter. encryption by default would at least make them behave like letters while crossing the networks. Figuring out if the sender is who he or she claims to be is a very different issue, and one that has plagued humanity since the dawn of correspondence.
- stinkytaco 11y agoMy issue is not default encryption, which I think is a "good thing"™. It's that if you say "Thunderbird: Encrypted by Default"™, you give users a sense of security that is at least partially an illusion. This is something we would roundly criticize Google for if they were to say, for example, "your email and searching is secure because you are using SSL". I feel it's incumbent on an organization like Mozilla, one that I support at least partially because they are not building a platform to advance their own interests, to be very clear that email is encrypted en route, but not necessarily secure. I'm guess I'm viewing it from a communications angle.
- digi_owl 11y agoHere we are back at the varying definition of "security". The encryption will defend against NSA style "grab everything, sort it out later" attacks. but it will not defend against targeted attacks where someone had compromised the remote sender somehow. The former is a boon for most people vs the present state, the latter is a hairy problem that has been with us since we first started sorting ourselves into ingroups and outgroups (how do you know that the email is not sent by someone with a gun pointed to their head?). Or as i was reminded by a different comment: perfect becomes the enemy of good.
- pekk 11y agoIn the status quo nothing is verified or encrypted anyway. When we make the perfect the enemy of the good, we reinforce that status quo. As long as the trust model of PGP depends on everyone to get the same religion, we are stuck waiting for a messiah which will never come. If we have any hope of improving the status quo, we need some kind of bootstrap, and that bootstrap won't look exactly like the final result we want. Ubiquitous email encryption would improve on the status quo, and prepare the ground for further improvements. People who don't care would still be generating more verifiable information than the status quo. People who want to use encryption wouldn't be forced to drop it in order to talk to family and friends. People who want to carefully manage their identities and use signing to build a web of trust could build that on top of ubiquitous encryption. This would get us closer to the PGP trust model than anyone has been able to do purely by evangelizing the PGP trust model.
- digi_owl 11y ago> When we make the perfect the enemy of the good, we reinforce that status quo. Story of present day FOSS right there.
- anexprogrammer 11y agoAfter so many years of email that's entirely in the free and clear, I'd consider any steps nearer encryption as beneficial. Even if fundamentally weak improvements with annoucements littered with caveats for those in the know. I'd like for encrypted email to become a standard thing in my lifetime. We are no nearer than when I trialled PGP in the 90s. Then we can think about email that doesn't leak all your meta-data.
- dublinben 11y agoI seem to recall that this is exactly what a brand new installation of Thunderbird with Enigmail will do. I don't know if the newly generated public key is published anywhere, but that's a simple configuration change.
- digi_owl 11y agoYep, but Enigmail is not part of the default Thunderbird package. It has to specifically be installed by the user after installing and running Thunderbird.
- bad_user 11y agoEmail encryption isn't mainstream and it isn't Thunderbird's fault, but GPG's. It's an antiquated protocol with an antique implemention and it's hard to understand and hard to setup. Thunderbird including the implementation by default would only confuse users. Those who want Enigmail already know to search for the plugin. Those who don't know what it is wouldn't know what to do with it.
- icebraining 11y agoWhat's antiquated about the protocol?
- dublinben 11y agoI actually installed Thunderbird and Enigmail at the same time through my operating system's packet manager. You do not have to start Thunderbird before installing Enigmail.
- digi_owl 11y agoTurning a extension into a disto package, ye deities...
- icebraining 11y ago