4 ms·
Indeed, it is the purpose of a court to follow due process, but not of a private entity. Laws and courts constitute a minimum or a "floor" standard for civic a
by stcredzero 11y ago
Indeed, it is the purpose of a court to follow due process, but not of a private entity.
Laws and courts constitute a minimum or a "floor" standard for civic and commercial behavior. A society that has due process in its laws and on its books, but whose civic and commercial institutions all exhibit draconian knee-jerk behaviors is succeeding at being benevolent and just to the same extent that the Jim Crow south enfranchised black people. The comparison is unpleasant, but it is operationally correct. Laws on the books are only a skeleton. Values and principles have to be enacted by the flesh of civic and commercial society to be meaningful to people.
The values embodied by the laws on the books have also to be alive in civic society, or else they are not truly meaningful. It's not enough for only the government and courts to embody humanist and democratic values. Civic and commercial society has to embody them too. (Ask yourself, are you a part of civic and commercial institutions and intellectual movements that embody humanist and democratic values? Or are they authoritarian and withhold justice and free speech from those the group deems "unworthy?")
- pjlegato 11y agoThe idea that private individuals and businesses ought to conform to a prescribed set of moral values dictated by "society" is the very definition of "totalitarianism," no less because you give them nice-sounding names like "humanist and democratic," nor less because you attempt to create an emotional linkage of the reverse case to racism. Are people free, independent actors, or are they merely cogs in some vast social machine, constrainted to operate in their private lives and businesses according to the arbitrary dictates of some self-appointed group of sermonizing moralists?
- alanwatts 11y ago>Are people free, independent actors, or are they merely cogs in some vast social machine, constrainted to operate in their private lives and businesses according to the arbitrary dictates of some self-appointed group of sermonizing moralists? False dichotomy.
- pjlegato 11y agoIt's not. Given that there exist moralizers who propose that everyone ought to have to follow a certain set of values, you can either: A) accept their authority and adopt their moral schema, or B) reject their authority. There are no other options. All other possibilities are subsumed by one of these two, in one way or another.
- stcredzero 11y ago>> False Dichotomy > A) accept their authority and adopt their moral schema, or B) reject their authority. There are no other options. All other possibilities are subsumed by one of these two, in one way or another. Maybe you need to Google "False Dichotomy?"
- pjlegato 11y agoRather than simply insulting me, you could perhaps propose exactly what the other options are, besides those two, that you think I'm missing here. I will then either accept that you are correct and admit that I was wrong, or else show how the additional options you propose are actually subsumed into one of the two options that I've named above.
- stcredzero 11y agoYou can take the dialectic and synthesize an encompassing model. No authority need be accepted. No particular model need be wholly accepted. I can agree, for example, that certain forms of expression can make some people uncomfortable and exclude them from participation, yet not agree with the proposed dictate that all professional groups must now shun anyone who has ever defended such forms of expression. However, if the context of tolerance is expanded beyond such a narrow formulation, then my conclusion is that those forms of expression should also be defended and we should refrain from punishing the actors retroactively. (Even as we ask people to refrain from them in certain contexts.) You can expand such a discussion into emotional, psychological, and historical realms, as well as those of personal experience. It's always possible to expand the context of a discussion, since it's impossible for a person to understand every context at once. I did this once with my ex-girlfriend's right-wing Christian mom. She was willing to listen to the plight of a previous ex-girlfriend's family and it changed her outlook. I've also seen it happen with a homophobic woman from rural Oklahoma who became best friends with a gay activist man. It doesn't mean you have to agree on everything, but there is an exercise of self-awareness around the ease with which one human can "dehumanize" another in their own mind. Civil society is generally better served by civic discourse and less well served by shunning and actions usually shown to "the enemy." In fact, the root of social injustice is generally the propensity of people to do this in their minds. ("othering") I hope that is a good demonstration.
- stcredzero 11y agoThe idea that private individuals and businesses ought to conform to a prescribed set of moral values dictated by "society" is the very definition of "totalitarianism," A multicultural, inclusive society cannot tolerate intolerance, by definition. The rights of the individual, so long as they coexist peacefully, must be respected. you attempt to create an emotional linkage of the reverse case to racism. It's a functional and operational analogy. You had a situation where the letter of the law was respected, but the opposite was enacted in spirit. Have I touched a nerve? Are people free, independent actors, or are they merely cogs in some vast social machine, constrainted to operate in their private lives and businesses according to the arbitrary dictates of some self-appointed group of sermonizing moralists? I am advocating people as "free, independent actors." People who are free, independent actors and believe in humanist and democratic values can't afford to abrogate those values simply when it suits them. Even the vilest members of society should be accorded due process, at the very least. private lives and businesses according to the arbitrary dictates of some self-appointed group of sermonizing moralists? Democratic and humanist values are the very thing that prevents the establishment of the "self-appointed group of sermonizing moralists." The whole point of due process is to prevent the exercise of arbitrary power by a majority or by the loudest and richest. The whole point of due process is to ensure justice, even for the most hated part of society. The whole point is that society is imperfect and flawed, and must act with benevolent restraint, not from its unfiltered, hasty impulses. Philosophically, the insistence on the right to stigmatize, and punish others in the civic and commercial spheres based on what they think or said in the past is very close to the insistence that a baker can refuse to bake a cake based on personal religious beliefs and perceived sexual orientations. World history over thousands of years shows that to err on the side of increased interaction and commerce is the pathway to peace and greater harmony and prosperity. You fight violence through peace. You fight intolerance by tolerating. You can't easily fight violence with violence. You can't fight hate with more hate. As for kicking out booters due to a TOS violation, though, I'm pretty much for that, so long as there aren't any false positives.
- pjlegato 11y agoYou are rather proposing a vast curtailment of personal freedom, according to your personal interpretation of reified "democratic and humanist values" -- an extremely vague and nebulous concept that, once stripped of the layers of indirection and obfuscation, amounts to nothing more than "what I personally happen to think constitutes good and proper behavior." Moreover, you propose that not only the government, but also private entitites ought to be so regulated by your own arbitrary philosophical restrictions, a sort of Dead Kennedys "California Über Alles"-esque oppressive police state that not only promotes but mandates a particular narrow interpretation of liberal values. This is no different in character from any other totalitarian dictatorship, though the exact set of values you advocate differs to a greater or lesser extent. They've all always thought of themselves as "good" and "moral" and "proper," all sought to improve society and remodel others' thinking by force and coercion, and always in the name of "ensuring justice."