4 ms·
Intelligence exists in human culture, not in individual humans. A high IQ has limited usefulness without a culture it can learn from and operate in. (Ask any oc
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
Intelligence exists in human culture, not in individual humans. A high IQ has limited usefulness without a culture it can learn from and operate in. (Ask any octopus.)
Human culture persists outside of individuals, so the occasional genius can change culture and culture stays changed because collective memory is altered. This doesn't happen with individual animal intelligence.
So I don't think we'll ever see a true AGI. What will happen instead is that collective cultural memory will improve, and connections between human brains will become faster and deeper - just as they have done for millennia.
If there's ever a singularity it will be created by human brains operating together in a new and vastly accelerated shared state, not by silicon brains that have been programmed to appear sentient.
- fossuser 11y agoYour first point is what I was trying to get at - basically the culture is the 'test data' and IQ would be the capability of the 'hardware' or genetic make up of an individual brain/person in this case. I think your point about intelligence not existing in an individual is too narrow, but ultimately that comes down to how you decide to define intelligence. Not sure I agree that AGI won't happen - in fact I suspect the computing power we have now is good enough to do it, but we're just missing some insight with how.