5 ms·
> I don’t know if this means I should not trust American Scientist in areas that are not my specialty. On something I know a bit about, the magazine has failed
by pavel_lishin 11y ago
> I don’t know if this means I should not trust American Scientist in areas that are not my specialty. On something I know a bit about, the magazine has failed miserably.
I forget the term for this - when we see media cover something we know about badly, but continue to assume that they cover other topics that we're relatively ignorant about fairly and correctly.
- spacemanmatt 11y agoOdd, when I see something that offends my area of expertise, it causes me significant skepticism on everything else from that source. I need it to be right about things I know are right, or I can't trust it on things I truly know less about.
- mikeash 11y agoIt's called the Gell-Mann Amnesia Effect.
- metaphorm 11y agobe careful with that. as far as I can tell from my own investigations into it, Murray Gell-Mann did not coin this term or have much of anything to do with it. Murray Gell-Mann himself was a quantum physicist and I don't think he spent a lot of time worrying about the news media. I believe the "Gell-Mann Amnesia Effect" is something created by the fiction author Michael Crichton as a plot device. It may be an interesting idea but as far as I know it is not a real researched effect in media studies or psychology.
- mikeash 11y agoI'm not sure what there is to be careful of here. A brief search will reveal that it was named after Gell-Mann in an attempt to make it sound better, and I don't see any particular implication from it that it's a scientifically supported phenomenon.
- chris_wot 11y agoYou only need to be careful because some smart-alek will point out it is an example of Stigler's law of eponymy.
- metaphorm 11y agoI'm saying you should be careful because it is easy to give a false impression that you are discussing a scientifically supported phenomenon where really it is basically the musings of a fiction writer. the name "Gell-Mann Amnesia" was, in fact, chosen by Crichton self-consciously so that this false impression would be more likely in discussions such as this one. Lack of context and a fancy sounding name serve to obfuscate the truth here.
- mikeash 11y agoIs it really? People throw around fancy-sounding names like Betteridge's Law of Headlines and Sturgeon's Law without any qualifiers and nobody seems to mistake those for scientific principles. I'm not sure it's worth defending against people taking a fancy-sounding name and taking that as an indication that it's scientific principle without even bothering to take five seconds to look it up.
- metaphorm 11y agoBetteridge's Law is named after Ian Betteridge, a technology journalist, who wrote directly on the subject. Sturgeon's Law is named after Ted Sturgeon, a fiction writer, who actually basically coined the phrase originally (I think he did anyway). Michael Crichton, on the other hand, did not call his idea "Crichton's Law of Media Analysis". He deliberately gave it an obfuscatory name and attempted to associate it with a well regarded physicist to give the impression that the law was scientific in some way. It was a deliberate misdirection, done for effect. Because of the intrinsically duplicitous nature of the name "Gell-Mann Amnesia" I think its inappropriate to continue referring to the effect under that name. Call it Crichton's Law or whatever. Lets not repeat the original misdirection though. It is fundamentally dishonest and does a disservice to the legacy of Murray Gell-Mann.
- 33W 11y agoWhile mikeash covered that badly, I'll continue to assume that they cover other topics that we're relatively ignorant about fairly and correctly.
- kragen 11y agoGell-Mann still is a quantum physicist. Don't scare me like that.
- sago 11y agoI know!, I was all "oh jeez, not Murray too, how did I not hear about that!". Okay, panic over.
- 1812Overture 11y agoA great example of Stigler's Law of Eponymy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stigler%27s_law_of_eponymy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stigler%27s_law_of_eponymy
- rrauenza 11y agoI learned this early as a child. I stood next to my dad as he was interviewed by a journalist for a community event where he worked. When I later read the actual article, I was somewhat astounded by the inaccuracy. And I was a child!
- lotharbot 11y agoI learned this watching TV coverage of a particular protest/rally I had been to. There were no shots of the diverse crowd of thousands, only a single close-up of an old man who was dressed oddly. The much smaller counter-protest of ~10 people got more airtime, but instead of showing them yelling and cussing at the children in our group, a well-dressed female lawyer from their side was interviewed, with a few others packed around her and a tight camera angle to make it look like she was in the middle of a huge crowd. Like, it wasn't just mildly inaccurate coverage as a result of the reporters not having good enough understanding. It was intentionally slanted coverage. And it made me think, if they can make something that straightforward look so different from reality, I have a hard time trusting their coverage in general. (See also: Babylon 5 season 4 episode 8 "The Illusion of Truth")
- rlonstein 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erwin_Knoll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erwin_Knoll First hand experience with Knoll's Law of Media Accuracy: Everything you read in the newspapers is absolutely true except for the rare story of which you happen to have firsthand knowledge I heard it first phrased (and probably before the above) that the accuracy of a newspaper article is inversely proportional to how close you are to the subject.
- jandrese 11y agoOne of the things I noticed in college was that the journalism major seemed to attract a class of people who are not good at comprehending complex systems. If you don't understand something, it's almost impossible to communicate the concept of it to another person. My dad was a chemical engineer and whenever News 7 had a story about the chemical plant my dad would mutter about how they got the details (and pronunciations!) all wrong.
- dmd 11y agoThis is why I can't read any of Bill Bryson's books. As far as I can tell, they're researched by copying "facts" off "DID YOU KNOW???" children's diner placemats, for all the things I actually know about, so I have to assume everything else is like that too.
- lukev 11y agoThis is even more true of the comment section of HN than it is in the media. For several domains I know something about, the comments here are painfully misguided and just bad, with the possible exception of some programming topics.
- logicallee 11y ago> For several domains I know something about, the [HN] comments are painfully misguided and just bad But in the case of HN, if you leave them that way in a way it's your fault :-P Meaning, that you could write a paragraph or two setting the rest of us straight. The exception is subjects that are extremely politically sensitive and controversial, in which your paragraph or two could be downvoted to oblivion and start a uselessly derailed thread, no matter how incredibly polite you are. If HN has 'groupthink' opinion that is completely wrong on kernel scheduling, you can set it right, politely and by sticking to the facts. If HN has 'groupthink' opinion that is completely wrong on a political or other controversial issue, I would politely abstain.
- chongli 11y agoIf HN has 'groupthink' opinion that is completely wrong on a political or other controversial issue, I would politely abstain. No way! I love commenting on political and controversial issues. Never let a fear of downvotes act as a chilling effect on your speech. If you believe you have something truly valuable to add then get it out there! I often find myself surprised that I'm upvoted for swimming against the current. It may turn out that there were multiple people who had the same idea as me but they were staying out of it until I commented.
- lotharbot 11y agoor, in many cases, people who agree but couldn't express the same idea as well as you, or even people who disagree but learned something. Upvotes aren't only a sign of likemindedness.
- 11y ago
- make3 11y agoTo me, this is basic credibility, not anything special. people will trust you less if you mess up the things they know something about, rightly so.
- mikestew 11y agoYeah, I don't know what the term is, either. But I learned the lesson early on. Even amongst those in the know, reserve accepting the words as truth as even knowledge people don't know when to quit when they reach the perimeter of their ignorance. Take a most recent example that has nothing to do the topic at hand: VW Vanagon camper vans. We took our '81 Westy to a campout that was a bunch of VW Westfalia camper vans (with the cute pop-top tents on the roof, for the uninitiated). Think these folks can bore you with the intimate details of Westies you never knew you didn't care about? Ohhhhh, yeah. These folks know their Westies, and they'll make you wish you never asked. A couple of ladies are admiring ours (as well they should, as it's in excellent shape). They were debating whether the rear air intakes should be metal or plastic. They were absolutely sure that an early Vanagon such as ours should have metal. They were mostly right. Except for the part where VW put out a diesel version in the middle of the '81 model year, at which time VW switched to plastic air intakes for all models. My point? Oh, I've got one, bear with me. The point is that even when knowledgable people get most of the details right, don't assume that every single detail is correct. In the example of the article, they got most of the way there and then...didn't know when to quit. It seems to me that they started the article with a decent, but not great, grasp of the topic. When they hit the parts that they were a little fuzzy on, they trudged on regardless, got it wrong, and now some question everything they've published. The authors were knowledgable, but not experts, but that didn't stop them from writing like they are experts. Or something something Dunning-Kruger, I'm not sure.