4 ms·
When exactly were we brainwashed into believing that the best way to earn a living is to have a job? I don't buy this. Humans are risk-averse and a having a j
by mseebach 17y ago
When exactly were we brainwashed into believing that the best way to earn a living is to have a job?
I don't buy this. Humans are risk-averse and a having a job isn't the best way to earn a living - it's the easiest and to a certain extend the safest.
Founding a start up, or working as a freelancer isn't for everyone, and pointing fingers and yelling "you're brainwashed because you didn't make the same superior choices I did" isn't very constructive.
- sabat 17y agoI'm not sure Seth is going that far, although I can see how one might misinterpret his message. What he's trying to say is: you can do it (be an entrepreneur) if you really want to.
- awa 17y agoI somehow didn't get the message as you did, it seems to me that he is saying that we are brainwashed to be average and to follow the crowd and working at a job to earn a living is one of the notions that have been put in our head during our brainwashing.
- bricestacey 17y ago"it's the easier and to a certain extent the safest" I think that's half his point. That's what average is, right? Easy and safe such that everyone can do it. Perhaps it's not being brainwashed, but the net effect of all human interactions will ultimately be average, so it's important that anyone wishing to achieve better must work a little harder to get nudged above it. This reminds me of the language blub (ironically in an essay titled, "Beating the Averages"), except PG was very careful to prepare the reader for what he was about to say, "I don't want to hurt anyone's feelings, so to explain this point I'm going to use a hypothetical language called Blub." Perhaps Godin could've done the same, but that's not his style.
- DenisM 17y agoTaking risk aversion to its logical conclusion one will end up selling himself into slavery - a good slave owner will take care of housing and nutritional needs of his slaves in good or bad times because he has vested interest in the slaves being alive and healthy. It's easy to see drawbacks of slavery, and so it stands to reason that risk-aversion, like many other natural urges, must be controlled. Employment in that regard is the same story - you are trading in part of your autonomy in exchange of lesser risk exposure. It's rarely a good trade.
- foldr 17y agoTaking virtually anything to its logical conclusion is a bad idea. The logical conclusion of risk non-aversion isn't all that pretty either.
- DenisM 17y agoThe opposite of risk-aversion is not risk-seeking, as you seem to imply, but risk-management as I have explicitly advocated in my previous post.
- foldr 17y agoI don't share your intuitions about opposites. Risk-management is in any case a middle-of-the-road position. A person might rationally decide that the best risk/reward balance, given their particular goals, was to get a job. (Especially if these goals include doing a lot of stuff outside of work, since startups don't give you much free time.)
- stinkytaco 17y ago1. I disagree that risk aversion is not the same as risk seeking. If you are not avoiding risk, you are exposing yourself to it. 2. Even if I accept your premise, risk-management is, as foldr says, a middle of the road proposition. I choose to manage my risk by safely working a job and allowing myself, and my children, to pursue other interests fairly comfortably. Besides, someone has to work jobs. To paraphrase Office Space, "If everyone did what they loved, no one would be a janitor because no loves cleaning up shit."
- dasil003 17y agoWait a minute, you don't think a third party who you barely know having complete control over you sounds incredibly risky?
- DenisM 17y agoI should have made it clear - I was talking specifically about reducing economical risk by turning over your fate to a slave owner. The elevated risk to personal security is obviously a downside as you pointed out, although a sane slave-owner will never kill you because he has already paid for all your future work. In addition slave will forever forgo all chances of climbing out of that hole because he does not keep any of the surplus product he has generated. And hence my point is that someone seeking to reduce their exposure to risk can easily end up subjecting himself to a different risk he didn't think about. The parallel with employment is direct - by trading your economic liberty for a paycheck you are reducing your exposure to risk of there being nothing to eat. However you are also eliminating your exposure to the upside of your work. You are also picking up the risk of having loaded on debt and then being laid off, ending up in a dead-end career and work-place hazards. What Seth points out is that risk of there being nothing to eat is vastly exaggerated in our minds, thus many of us trade the very real upside of our labor for the risk-protection we didn't need.
- pkaler 17y ago"Humans are risk-averse..." Exactly. I think that's his point. That is what he means when he talks about the lizard brain. Our aversion to risk leads us into doing things that do not matter.