4 ms·
We can see physical or psychological torture used effectively in many TV series. I have read that in real life, torture was very ineffective to make people tell
by reacweb 11y ago
We can see physical or psychological torture used effectively in many TV series. I have read that in real life, torture was very ineffective to make people tell something they want to hide. Generally people die without speaking or do not know any valuable secret.
Remember at school. When one child get punished, all the other childs of the class become quiet. The main desired effect of torture is manipulation of population. They do not care if the tortured guy speaks or dies, they want to inspire fear.
I think it is the only way to understand how something so barbare and so ineffective (in its direct purpose) is still used. TV series should stop disinformation (pretending torture works and presenting torture as acceptable).
Torture is unacceptable.
- RodericDay 11y agoZizek on Zero Dark Thirty was a pretty good take along these lines (http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/jan/25/zero-dark-thirty-normalises-torture-unjustifiable http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/jan/25/zero-da...)
- pessimizer 11y ago> We can see physical or psychological torture used effectively in many TV series. Almost exclusively by the heroes, and it always works almost instantly. It says something about the people writing them. I can't wait for the episode of Daredevil where he spends a month and a half torturing someone for information. Remember all of those scenes in movies from the 70s and earlier when halfway through the rape, the woman starts to get into it, and when we cut to the morning after she's like "never leave me," and now the viewer is expected to sympathise with the rapist and his victim against the world? It's a snapshot of the mindset of elites. > Remember at school. When one child get punished, all the other childs of the class become quiet. The main desired effect of torture is manipulation of population. They do not care if the tortured guy speaks or dies, they want to inspire fear. This is only way torture is effective. Except, in this context, the more accurate term for it is terrorism.
- vijayr 11y agoMaybe we have Jack Bauer to blame, he always seems to get information within seconds using fear of violence and torture.
- david927 11y agoWe like to think that propaganda was something the Soviets and Fascists did decades ago and doesn't happen in the modern world. But 24/Jack Bauer and films like Zero Dark Thirty are straight propaganda. The first step in fighting it is identifying it.
- krapp 11y ago>Remember all of those scenes in movies from the 70s and earlier when halfway through the rape, the woman starts to get into it, and when we cut to the morning after and she's like "never leave me," and now the viewer is expected to sympathise with the rapist and his victim against the world? Actually, no. I've seen plenty of old movies, but I don't recall many rape scenes, much less such rape scenes where the rapist is meant to be sympathized with, or where the rape victim takes pleasure in it.
- anarazel 11y agoOld James Bond movies at the very least come close to that. I was rather shocked watching over on a plane recently.
- pessimizer 11y agoJames Bond and Pussy Galore - is this rape? http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/1570613-James-Bond-and-Pussy-Galore-is-this-rape http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/1570613-...
- pessimizer 11y agoThey were common, and they still happen, rarely. Game of Thrones got in trouble for one last year: http://time.com/70829/game-of-thrones-rape/ http://time.com/70829/game-of-thrones-rape/ edit: http://www.ifc.com/2011/09/straw-dogs-sex-the-remake-of-a-rape http://www.ifc.com/2011/09/straw-dogs-sex-the-remake-of-a-ra...