3 ms·
If the person remains totally passive at each of these stages, or repeatedly says or does something not affirmative, like "I really need to go" or turning away
by ZeroGravitas 11y ago
If the person remains totally passive at each of these stages, or repeatedly says or does something not affirmative, like "I really need to go" or turning away from you, what do you think you should do next? Is this really that hard?
The only way what you're saying isn't really creepy and odd, is if you have a version of affirmitive consent in mind, that doesn't correpsond to reality.
edited to add: It's worth bearing in mind the history of this, were a person doing the above would be told that it didn't count, that they were expected to "fight off" their rapist, because that's what good victims would have done, and clearly they weren't a good enough victim because they just remained frozen in fear, or were nearly unconcious through drink or drugs. Both the potential victims and the potentially accussed are better of with this extra clarity, that silent, passive, borderline unconcious acceptance of what you are doing is not enough to avoid later accusations.
- nailer 11y agoThat's an excellent example. If a man is initially unsure about sex - he says he needs to go, but still stays - and a woman changes his mind and they have sex, do you consider her a rapist?
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoDid he want to have sex with her? Then she's in the clear. If not, then that's one more bit of evidence that could come up if he accuses her. Just like if I initially didn't want to lend you my car, and then you 'changed my mind' and I end up accusing you of theft for taking it. It makes it look bad for you if there's any evidence that I turned you down initially, so you really should be certain you actually have changed my mind before taking my car.
- tremon 11y agoDid he want to have sex with her? Then she's in the clear And how are you going to prove that in court without a written (and preferably notarized) consent form? Should the form also enumerate the agreed-to acts and positions, for when one party only intends to go to third base? Should condom use be explicitly mentioned? if there's any evidence that I turned you down initially I'm not comfortable with that, because "playing hard to get" is a widely-used dating strategy.
- Steuard 11y agoYou've built the answer to your question into its premise: "a woman changes his mind", you said. So sure: she changed his mind, and thus the sex was consensual. No rape involved, and I don't think I've ever met anyone who would say otherwise. But some people seeing what you wrote might be imagining a more general situation. Rather than "a woman changes his mind and they have sex", they're instead picturing "a woman gets him to have sex anyway". And that has a lot more room for ambiguity. Maybe she did something to really turn him on and they wound up eagerly jumping each other (not rape). Maybe they had a heart to heart talk and he decided that even though he wasn't eager, this would be really special to her and he went with it (not rape). Maybe he kept trying to leave but she blocked the door and was physically threatening and he concluded the only way he could get away without injury was to let her take what she wanted (that's rape). Maybe she kept giving him alcohol until he wasn't able to process what was going on and got sexual once he was to that point (that's rape; given his initial refusal I'm definitely inclined to call it deliberate even if she was drinking too: this is a well-established serial rapist technique). Maybe she kept gradually pushing his boundaries and wearing him down, ignoring his clear lack of any positive reaction to what she was doing, and eventually escalated things to sex (borderline: I'd need more info to judge if it's rape, but she's definitely an asshole).
- nailer 11y ago> No rape involved, and I don't think I've ever met anyone who would say otherwise. I know many people who could consider responding to negative or neutral signalling to be 'coercion' and either 'rape' or 'rape-like', including both of: > Maybe she did something to really turn him on and they wound up eagerly jumping each other. Maybe they had a heart to heart talk and he decided that even though he wasn't eager, this would be really special to her and he went with it. Agreed on your views regarding all of those situations though.
- arkades 11y agoA moment ago the discussion was about requiring /affirmative/ consent at every escalation. But your example is "is the person giving moderately subtle-to-overt signs of non-consent." The example of "affirmative consent" I've been presented with generally include explicitly verbalizing requests for consent, so as to preclude things like reading body language, because... well, that's where things go awry.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoAffirmitive just means "yes", getting the other party to say it out loud helps if you're really that bad at body language and non-verbal communication but is not required. As someone else stated, if verbal consent was what was required, they'd call it "verbal consent" not "affirmative consent". Affirmative meaning, from a plain dictionary definition: "saying or showing that the answer is "yes" <He gave an affirmative answer.> ". Again, the history and context is people being raped who did not "fight back", and it was held against them, and people accused of rape who said in their own defence that they didn't think they were raping the person because they didn't do anything to stop them. That's not their responsibility, it's yours to get "affirmitive consent".