2 ms·
Your phrase a mildly interesting discussion to be had, about a little-understood phenomenon that might have some minor repercussions over the next few hundred y
by btilly 17y ago
Your phrase a mildly interesting discussion to be had, about a little-understood phenomenon that might have some minor repercussions over the next few hundred years makes it clear that you have failed to understand what the mainstream of science is saying.
Even with small temperature changes there are large projected impacts from changing weather patterns causing drought in some areas and flooding in others. Think of the regular El Niño/La Niña oscillation to see how much small temperature changes change weather patterns. This is on top of ocean acidification which is already damaging coral reefs and could widely threaten all kinds of shellfish (and ecosystems dependent on shellfish) in our lifetimes. And there are small changes in ocean level projected, which have a disproportionately large economic effect because we have so much important commercial activity at the ocean/land boundary.
In truth there is a fascinating discussion to be had about how much and when. There are a lot of open questions and that discussion is hardly one-sided. For instance look at http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/01/100127134721.htm http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/01/100127134721.ht... to see scientists projecting that the projected rate of increase of CO2 due to global warming (yes, increasing temperature releases natural CO2 which increases warming some more) is much less than had been projected. This will push us towards the lower end of what has been projected. Which, contrary to the yelling you hear from climate deniers, is far from nothing, and is not economically unimportant.
In short there is a fascinating scientific discussion going on about significant impacts that are likely within the coming decades. And if you subtract out the yelling on both sides, you might be able to hear it.
- cgranade 17y agoI agree wholeheartedly, modulo your very last sentence. I think that "yelling," as you put it, is a valid, defensible and necessary response to the yelling of the denialists, provided that one only yells things which are true. The other side has not been playing nice for quite some time, and that scientists have done themselves a disservice (along with the rest of society) by being unwilling to respond to denialist canards repeatedly and loudly. It's a tiresome and thankless job (just as the biologists), and one that I find myself poorly cut out for, but I do think it's needed.