4 ms·
Isn't taking all reasonable steps to ascertain consent what the affirmative consent thing is all about? It's one of those sensible things, like recycling, rene
by ZeroGravitas 11y ago
Isn't taking all reasonable steps to ascertain consent what the affirmative consent thing is all about?
It's one of those sensible things, like recycling, renewable energy, belief in evolution, or decent medical coverage, that somehow becomes a very bitter political issue for no logical reason.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Steuard 11y agoIt doesn't have to be verbal! I'd consider a big grin while pulling your partner into position to be a perfectly lovely form of affirmative consent, just for instance. (That's why it's not called "verbal consent", eh?) "Affirmative consent is a knowing, voluntary, and mutual decision among all participants to engage in sexual activity. Consent can be given by words or actions, as long as those words or actions create clear permission regarding willingness to engage in the sexual activity. Silence or lack of resistance, in and of itself, does not demonstrate consent. The definition of consent does not vary based upon a participant's sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, or gender expression." -- http://system.suny.edu/sexual-violence-prevention-workgroup/policies/affirmative-consent/ http://system.suny.edu/sexual-violence-prevention-workgroup/...
- nailer 11y agoIs requiring consent at every sexual escalation practical? Do affirmative consent campaigners encourage women having sex with men to obtain affirmative consent when the woman escalates?
- Steuard 11y agoWithout question, yes! That's the whole point.
- nailer 11y agoSo from talking to flirting? Flirting to lightly touching arm? Lightly touching arm to sitting closely? Sitting closely to staring into eyes? Staring to kissing? Kissing to hands on body? Each escalation of foreplay? I understand what you're saying, but I don't see the granularity as being clear at all. Nor have I ever seen anyone else pressure women into obtaining explicit consent at each escalation. You mention in another thread consent could be given non verbally. Non verbal cues are easily misunderstood - and we're taking about using this as a basis for determining guilt for a serious crime here.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoIf the person remains totally passive at each of these stages, or repeatedly says or does something not affirmative, like "I really need to go" or turning away from you, what do you think you should do next? Is this really that hard? The only way what you're saying isn't really creepy and odd, is if you have a version of affirmitive consent in mind, that doesn't correpsond to reality. edited to add: It's worth bearing in mind the history of this, were a person doing the above would be told that it didn't count, that they were expected to "fight off" their rapist, because that's what good victims would have done, and clearly they weren't a good enough victim because they just remained frozen in fear, or were nearly unconcious through drink or drugs. Both the potential victims and the potentially accussed are better of with this extra clarity, that silent, passive, borderline unconcious acceptance of what you are doing is not enough to avoid later accusations.
- nailer 11y agoThat's an excellent example. If a man is initially unsure about sex - he says he needs to go, but still stays - and a woman changes his mind and they have sex, do you consider her a rapist?
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoDid he want to have sex with her? Then she's in the clear. If not, then that's one more bit of evidence that could come up if he accuses her. Just like if I initially didn't want to lend you my car, and then you 'changed my mind' and I end up accusing you of theft for taking it. It makes it look bad for you if there's any evidence that I turned you down initially, so you really should be certain you actually have changed my mind before taking my car.
- reso 11y agoYeah, it's pretty shocking to me too. I don't know how it happened, but somehow people interpret affirmative consent as meaning we're going to start prosecuting rape cases with presumption-of-guilt. In my brain these are actually two different things. One is how we teach consent to teenagers and young adults, the other is fixing extremely well-documented biases in how rape cases are tried in court. Key phrase being "extremely well documented".
- golemotron 11y agoThe real problem isn't consent it is that there are no witnesses. It becomes "he said, she said" in the heterosexual case. In a crime with no witnesses and no physical evidence there is nothing the law can do justly. Right now the societal balance is moving toward always believing the woman. As verified cases of false accusation accumulate that balance may swing backward. There are no easy answers and it makes it obvious why societal norms in the pre-modern era had tighter restrictions on sexuality outside marriage.
- trhway 11y ago>The real problem isn't consent it is that there are no witnesses. It becomes "he said, she said" one can see how, like condoms had, cell phone recording may become a part of the safety ritual...
- tomp 11y agoI don't think affirmative consent is sensible at all. If it were made law, then I would have been raped, and been raping at the same time, during pretty much all sex I've had in my life! Obviously it's possible to have amazing consensual sex without affirmative consent.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoI think you've just been misled (or are actively trying to mislead) about what affirmative consent involves. This is the rhetorical equivalent of "but it's snowing, so much for global warming!", a ha-ha-gotcha cliché, maybe you should try to engage with the topic on a deeper level.
- tomp 11y agoMaybe we need a clearer definition then...
- Steuard 11y agoI literally cannot imagine amazing sex that doesn't easily pass the threshold of "affirmative consent". As I quoted elsewhere in the thread, the definition that pops up on Google reads, "Affirmative consent is a knowing, voluntary, and mutual decision among all participants to engage in sexual activity. Consent can be given by words or actions, as long as those words or actions create clear permission regarding willingness to engage in the sexual activity." [http://system.suny.edu/sexual-violence-prevention-workgroup/policies/affirmative-consent/ http://system.suny.edu/sexual-violence-prevention-workgroup/...] Any attempt I make to imagine "amazing sex" involves my partner being every bit as excited about what's going on as I am, at every step along the way. That means that when I'd signal interest in doing something new, she'd be expressing delight about it in one way or another (and vice versa). Anything of the sort would satisfy this definition with flying colors.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- yarou 11y agoWhy stop there? Why not install a video camera on every street corner, in every home, and deep packet inspection on every network hub? Panopticon seems really nice in theory, and it's easy to support if you think you're the watchman. But in reality you are one of the watched.
- cperciva 11y agoIsn't taking all reasonable steps to ascertain consent what the affirmative consent thing is all about? Yes. But if you take those steps and still end up being mistaken -- to take a deliberately bizarre hypothetical, suppose you're in bed with someone who has a brain tumour causing them to say "yes" when they mean "no" -- then you might believe that you have that consent when the "experience of the victim" is that they did not consent.