9 ms·
Those situations are more edge cases and they are quite difficult because knowing what we know about the mind, it can play tricks. For example, we may feel ver
by mc32 11y ago
Those situations are more edge cases and they are quite difficult because knowing what we know about the mind, it can play tricks. For example, we may feel very happy at one moment, but something could transpire to change the feeling and that may cause us to retroactively view the initial consent (maybe they thought the person was initially someone else) in a different light --but at the same time, most people give the benefit of the doubt internally (that is, even if they are truly aggrieved, they are likely to interpret the violation as their own fault, rather than blame the perp) It can become murky.
To make the point less gender political, view this as something which happens to a same-sex couple, so that the dynamics are less obvious about sexual politics and more about either force, misinterpretation, misrepresentation or confusion or a mixture of all the above.
- CthulhuOvermind 11y ago> To make the point less gender political, view this as something which happens to a same-sex couple, so that the dynamics are less obvious about sexual politics and more about either force, misinterpretation, or confusion or a mixture of all the above. I like your suggestion about viewing this as same-sex couple situation. I wrote my post specifically gender-neutral so as to prepare for the inevitable accusation of sexism, and then reveal that in my example the female was the perpetrator. But I think your opinion is much better
- chris_wot 11y agoThough it's much rarer, it is possible for a woman to rape a man.
- danieltillett 11y agoIt is not that rare when using the current standard of consent. If you include any man who has sex while drunk (and is hence incapable of giving consent) then rape of men by women is very common.
- chris_wot 11y agoI could be wrong about how rare it is, I don't know the statistics and I don't have any way of knowing how many men don't report the crime. My point was that it can and does happen. I probably shouldn't have said anything about how often it occurs as I don't know.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoCan you define drunk as you intend it in this sentence? People seem to be very loose with this phrase recently and it's impossible to tell if they're doing so intentionally for political reasons, or if they're just not very good at communicating what they mean. Drunk can mean someone has had 1 beer (e.g. drunk driving in many locations). It can also mean aggressively or flamboyantly out-of-character after several drinks, or it can mean basically incapacitated and in danger of choking on their own vomit. Which part of this range were you ambigously referring to?
- thaumasiotes 11y agoAs made explicit in the sexual assault policies of various US universities, a female is unable to consent if she's had any alcohol (the "1 beer" model of being drunk). It is not a defense, or grounds for a counterclaim, that the male might have been equally or more drunk. (I say made explicit; the "any alcohol" threshold is what's made explicit. The wording of formal policies is generally scrupulously gender-neutral, but their application isn't.) In an actual US criminal court, I believe drunken consent is no different from any other consent.
- emp_zealoth 11y agoWhat the actual fuck. Are those people out of their goddamn minds? So any girl can basically claim she had one shot if she feels like ruining someone's life and make an innocent man into a "rapist"? What if it's two lesbians that shared a beer? Do the universe collapse or something? The arbitraryness and possibilities of malicious abuse just blow my goddamn brain.
- sambe 11y agoTechnically, under English law, I believe it isn't. The definition involves penetrative sex. It's normally something like sexual assault instead (arguably adding somewhat to gender politics).
- mc32 11y agoIt's still not entirely impossible for a person without a male reproductive organ to engage in active penetrative sex with the aid of well, sexual devices which mimic the shape or even cruder devices. That's to say, I don't believe, but could be wrong, they stipulate being naturally born or some such uneasy language.
- sambe 11y agoI believe it actually requires a penis too. Quick Google suggests this is still true.
- chris_wot 11y agoNot true. The FBI's definition is: "The penetration, no matter how slight, of the vagina or anus with any body part or object, or oral penetration by a sex organ of another person, without the consent of the victim." [1] 1. https://www.justice.gov/opa/blog/updated-definition-rape https://www.justice.gov/opa/blog/updated-definition-rape
- maaku 11y agoFBI's definition does not apply in England.
- chris_wot 11y agoTrue, I missed the "English law" bit. This means the definition of rape depends on the country you are in. For the UK I think it's really arguing semantics though, because it is defined as "assault by penetration" and has the same penalties as rape. [1] 1. http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2003/42/part/1/crossheading/assault/section/2 http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2003/42/part/1/crosshead...
- chris_wot 11y agoI hope those who are disagreeing with me are doing so because I wasn't precise enough about where this can occur. As has been pointed out, in England a woman cannot take a man, but can commit an act of penetration. In the U.S. there is no such distinction.
- malandrew 11y agoIt actually occurs at a much higher rate than most think, but the strategy used by female perpetrators more often takes the form of emotional violence and coercion as opposed to physical violence. http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01541620 http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01541620 I have personal experience with this with a former partner and the threats and coercive tactics can get really ugly, dark and traumatic.
- JadeNB 11y ago> Though it's much rarer, it is possible for a woman to rape a man. Given that it is in response to a poster who clearly knew that (as indicated by the intention of revealing the female to be the perpetrator), in a thread in which (as far as I can see) no doubt about the possibility had been expressed, is this remark adding anything?
- anu_gupta 11y ago> n. I wrote my post specifically gender-neutral so as to prepare for the inevitable accusation of sexism, and then reveal that in my example the female was the perpetrator. Not really interested in engaging with someone who merely wants to set traps for people.
- chris_wot 11y agoI have to agree. Don't do that.
- techdragon 11y agoHave you never used something surprising as a method to make someone think? Laying traps is implying malice that may be entirely absent.
- chris_wot 11y agoI don't need to. I just state my position and hopefully then they consider it, which normally requires some level of thought.
- Kenji 11y agoNo, sorry. You cannot retroactively retract consent. If you said a genuine yes at the time of the intercourse and at no point you signalled you were not okay with it, you cannot just say it's rape all of a sudden. It is not. Otherwise, any person (usually female, even if you want it 'less gender political', which I personally find insincere since it plays a big role in the discussion) can screw over the person they had sex with (usually male). This is just another form of authoritarian feminism, designed to shift control even more into the hands of women. False rape allegations are not the exception, they are common, and the punishment for such false allegations is either nonexistent or very minor despite the the fact that they can destroy the accused person's life. Where are we headed? Do men need to have the women sign a contract before sex to avoid the lies? Because that's what it's looking like to me. Kinda unromantic ;)