12 ms·
College Sex-Assault Trials Belong in Court, Not Campus (2014)
- roywiggins 11y ago(2014)
- striking 11y agoWith all the hoopla going on about it nowadays, you'd think this article was published in reaction to what just happened. No, apparently someone saw this coming. I wonder what we could have done to avoid this.
- lagadu 11y agoIt seems I'm out of the loop: what just happened?
- dang 11y agoAdded.
- FreeInternet 11y agoBernie sanders agrees http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/jan/12/bernie-sanders-college-sexual-assault-cases-police http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/jan/12/bernie-sander.... I don't want to make this a political platform but nothing exists in isolation. Hillary is buying anonymous commenters on reddit and facebook and threatening internet freedom in the worst ways possible. http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/04/21/hillary-pac-spends-1-million-to-correct-commenters-on-reddit-and-facebook.html?n=2 http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/04/21/hillary-pac... Under Hillary, expect large corporations to grow larger and forget net-neutrality, and "offline" neutrality.
- klinskyc 11y agoHate to say it, but you are making this a political platform
- ryan-allen 11y agoWelcome to Silicon Valley 2016.
- FreeInternet 11y agoDo you exist in isolation? Can you live a life without any politics? Use your head please
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Sevrene 11y agoI don't necessarily disagree with you, but you are aware your comment looks like propaganda as well, right?
- FreeInternet 11y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=define+propaganda&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8 https://www.google.com/search?q=define+propaganda&ie=utf-8&o... > information, especially of a biased or misleading nature Which part of my information is misleading?
- Sevrene 11y agoI didn't read all of your article, I didn't have to read it to see that your comment looks like propaganda; new user, highly politicised comments, abrasive attitude to questions, comments with very similar content, etc. I don't really know if your comment is propaganda — I don't really care, actually. It's probably not. But we must be suspicious of suspicious acting narrators trying to lead conversations on sites like reddit and hacker news, no?
- FreeInternet 11y agono, we must do our research and not form quick judgements. No excuse to not read all the article. If you don't have time to learn, please save time by not speaking.
- Sevrene 11y agoHaving a healthy amount of suspicion suspends judgements in the first place. I skimmed the article as I had already heard most of it. No need to be so righteous. You could save yourself time (and everyone else for that matter) if you just worded your original comment a bit better; that's all I wanted to say in the first place. It's ironic that your post looks like propaganda when that's what you are so concerned about in the first place.
- dang 11y ago
- smegel 11y ago> why not impose a simple set of rules to work with the criminal-justice system It's really simple. First you just need to figure out who's telling the truth.
- lmm 11y agoWhich is the justice system's whole job, and they've gotten pretty ok at it.
- vlehto 11y agoIn rape cases about 1,5% proven guilty, about 1% proven false. But I guess ~97% failure rate can be considered OK in such situation?
- venomsnake 11y agoCourts start from presumption of innocence. Which is something that is not compatible with the "victim's story should not be questioned or challenged" approach that some advocates like.
- xlm1717 11y agoWho has time for due process when such misogynistic injustice is taking place.
- smegel 11y ago> and they've gotten pretty ok at it By that do you mean "pretty mediocre" or "pretty good"?
- deciplex 11y agoIt wasn't long ago that I would have agreed with this article in full. I may have even posted here on HN to that effect before. I am still sympathetic to the point it makes. However: Universities boot people out for other reasons which are not actionable in a criminal (or even civil) court all the time. Getting shitty grades, being a disruptive asshole in a class on a regular basis, and so on, can end your university career. So, with that in mind, "creeps everyone the fuck out and is probably a rapist", isn't such a stretch. I would not put someone in jail for that for any length of time. But, I don't know if "deserves jail time" is the right comparison. Maybe "I would fire this person, if they worked for me" or "I would kick this person out of my social club" are more apt. Now, I think that someone so expelled should have an easier time getting into another university than they currently do. Right now it seems that getting expelled because a university tribunal found you responsible for an alleged rape carries, for the purposes of college admissions elsewhere, nearly the same consequences as being an actual convicted rapist. This puts too much faith in the judgement of some other university's tribunal, which bring me to my next concern: These tribunals are too often full of shit. There are a few horror stories going around and you've probably read a few. Some places I think are not requiring a high enough burden of proof. The regulations and standards at the federal and state levels ought to be improved, and in light of the fact that sexual violence on campuses is on the decline, the improvements should result in fewer students being expelled, not more. But, in principle, I think it's fine for a university to do this, even if the accused rapist could not possibly be convicted in a court of law.
- danieltillett 11y agoThe major problem with this is the person booted is “convicted” of a very serious crime. Getting kicked out because you have been found guilty of rape by some sham court is a lot more harmful to the person than getting kicked out because you are disruptive in class. I sometime think we should adopt the Scottish system of not proven [1]. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_proven https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_proven
- deciplex 11y agoYeah, I know. That's why I'm still sympathetic to the view. I would hope that we could still have the tribunals but treat their findings for what they are: the non-professional opinions of a few administrators, based mostly on informal testimony, hearsay, and perhaps a poorly-executed investigation. But, perhaps there is no way to accomplish that in a way palatable to most people attending a school. Maybe people are just going to take the obvious shortcut and say "this school admitted a rapist" instead of what actually happened. If we can't work that out, then maybe these tribunals shouldn't exist. I'm just saying I'm not opposed to them in principle.
- nickysielicki 11y agoSame author, more recent post [1] I really like the way that he expanded on this theory and talks about the authority that universities have accumulated and the effect that it is having on students. For more on this topic, I really recommend an article, Campus Protesters Aren’t Reliving the 1960s -- (Yesterday’s student activists wanted to be treated like adults. Today’s want to be treated like children.) [2] [1]: https://familyinequality.wordpress.com/2015/11/09/university-paternalism-and-the-outwardly-focused-student-movement/ https://familyinequality.wordpress.com/2015/11/09/university... [2]: http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/12/campus-protests-1960s-213450 http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/12/campus-protes...
- mc32 11y agoShould more of the disciplinary action [involving criminal activity] be moved from the purview of colleges to the courts? I can see this making sense not only for cases of allegations of rape but also allegations of censorship, bias, underage drinking, etc. Sometimes colleges exercise a little too much discretion in adjudication. On the other hand, if we move not only grievous allegations but other less grave cases to the courts altogether, the caseload may overwhelm courts. Is there a divide between commuter campuses vs more residential campuses?
- prdonahue 11y agoYes, because what we really need right now is the courts bogged down deciding whether Johnny Fratboy cribbed a few too many quotes without properly citing them.
- mc32 11y agoI've amended the comment to refer to criminal accusations --which is what I mean to specify.
- studentrob 11y ago> allegations of censorship Greg Lukianoff wants to sue the department of education [1]. He just needs a case. Here is his org's free speech case list [2], and here's another clip of him talking about it [3] Laws do not enforce themselves. People need to make an effort to bring cases to court when there are injustices. The video clips are from the time of BLM protests at Yale at the end of 2015. Students were upset about an email from a faculty member who suggested that, while certain racist halloween costumes were ill-advised, they aren't against the law and other students should learn to deal with them peacefully. BLM students were in an uproar and saw this email as an approval of costumes like black face. The Yale President came out in support of the protesters. Erika Christakis, the author of the email, eventually resigned, despite support from thefire.org and others. Greg predicted this [4] The same thing happened around the time of the Vietnam war at Yale. Some guy named Shockley was invited to talk about eugenics. The idea was to allow his bad ideas to be heard so that he could hang himself. But some students protested and would not let him speak. Here's the full story [5]. The culmination of that episode was a report from a newly created committee on Freedom of Expression, led by Vann Woodward, also known as the Woodward report [6]. Its final paragraph reads, > The conclusions we draw, then, are these: even when some members of the university community fail to meet their social and ethical responsibilities, the paramount obligation of the university is to protect their right to free expression. This obligation can and should be enforced by appropriate formal sanctions. If the university's overriding commitment to free expression is to be sustained, secondary social and ethical responsibilities must be left to the informal processes of suasion, example, and argument. So that all sounds good. Lukianoff and thefire.org argue that Yale's administrators haven't been living up to the actions suggested by the report. Contrast this to how Columbia handled a visit by Ahmadinejad. Many people felt very strongly he should not be allowed to speak at such a reputable institution. Yet, they allowed it, and now he's on record saying that Iran has no gay people. It was an absurd thing to argue. Those who invited him knew he was going to say it. They wanted him to share his true feelings, hear foreigners' reactions, and give more of the world a chance to hear and talk about that viewpoint. [1] https://youtu.be/qGnNKmR1EEc?t=57m02s https://youtu.be/qGnNKmR1EEc?t=57m02s [2] https://www.thefire.org/category/cases/free-speech/ https://www.thefire.org/category/cases/free-speech/ [3] https://youtu.be/qGnNKmR1EEc?t=20m40s https://youtu.be/qGnNKmR1EEc?t=20m40s [4] https://youtu.be/qGnNKmR1EEc?t=17m32s https://youtu.be/qGnNKmR1EEc?t=17m32s [5] http://scienceblogs.com/dispatches/2008/02/05/william-shockley-and-free-spee/ http://scienceblogs.com/dispatches/2008/02/05/william-shockl... [6] http://yalecollege.yale.edu/faculty-staff/faculty/policies-reports/report-committee-freedom-expression-yale http://yalecollege.yale.edu/faculty-staff/faculty/policies-r...
- CthulhuOvermind 11y ago"The legal verdict on whether sex is non consensual still often rests on the perspective of the alleged perpetrator rather than the experience of the victim." I'm not sure I entirely understand this quote to its fullest. It is being argued that it is the experience of the victim that matters if sex is consensual. Isn't this quote logically wrong? Consensual by definitions means both parties agreed. But is the author arguing that it is the victim's opinion that makes it consensual only? How would that work in a situation where both parties start having sex, then it stops being consensual half way (from the victim changing their mind). The victim changes their minds but says nothing, and continues as before during the act. From the authors opinion, the victim experienced rape, hence the perpetrator should be convicted. But from the perpetrator's perspective they have no knowledge the partner's consent was revoked. As far as I understand, an accusation should examine a perpetrator's perspective more, since that person is being charged with a crime. Why is the author arguing that the victim's experience is what the trial should hinge upon? If the victim raised an accusation, that is enough! It is the perpetrator that is being tried and attempted to be found guilty, hence the trial focuses on the perpetrator's actions and perspective. Can someone better weigh in? This seems like one of those thoughts that sounds profound, but does not stand up to scrutiny.
- gozur88 11y ago>As far as I understand, an accusation should examine a perpetrator's perspective more, since that person is being charged with a crime. It depends on the way the law is written. You can certainly be guilty of criminal offenses absent any understanding or intent.
- CthulhuOvermind 11y agoIn the case of sex, it is an action that is legal(or not) depending on consent. In the example I gave earlier, the female has obtained consent from her partner. The male changes his mind half-way through but does not stop or act in any different way. In cases such as these, my understanding(and gut feeling really) is that since knowledge of consent is what makes an action legal, the person had no knowledge consent was revoked, and cannot be charged for something that is impossible to avoid being guilty of?
- chris_wot 11y agoUh, isn't the headline obvious? Crime such as sexual abuse should never be prosecuted by anyone other than the government! This is precisely the reason why the Roman Catholic Church and other institutions were able to cover up child sexual abuse on a massive scale! Australia is learning the extent of this now because the much maligned former Australian PM, Julia Gillard, established a Royal Commission into child sexual abuse within Institutions. This has been painful but cathartic for Australia - and a key thing that is emerging is that institutions who investigate the incidents themselves almost always cover up the abuse. This isn't just the Catholic Church - it's the YMCA, Buddhist organisations, dance schools, the Salvation Army, and numerous boys and girls homes. The Catholic Church is probably the most egregious offender, and its illustrative to note that rather than report serious sexual crimes to police, they shamed the victims and moved the offenders to different parts of the country (or overseas!) thus spreading the abuse. I wonder how many Colleges have done similar cover ups?
- forrestthewoods 11y agoTitle IX requires schools to perform some level of investigation. This is backwards. Title IX should FORBID schools for investigating and mandate forwarding of information to the police.
- superuser2 11y agoThe purpose of internal disciplinary systems is to have a weaker burden of proof. Meeting "beyond a reasonable doubt" is very difficult when the victim and perpetrator are in something resembling a romantic relationship and behind closed doors, to the point that almost no rapists would be found guilty. Schools instead use the standard of "more likely than not" to return a finding of "responsible," which means the school can get rid of the rapist, even if there's not enough evidence to put him in prison. Lower certainty required for a less drastic action. If only cases that DAs think are winners get acted on, the vast majority of campus rapes are immune from punishment.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoPresumption of Innocence is considered a human right by the United Nations. Manipulating the system to implicitly lessen the burden of proof is horrific. But at least the intentions are noble. As the current police system's handling of rape cases is also horrific. However two wrongs don't make a right.
- DanBC 11y agoBalance of probability has nothing to do with presumed innocent.
- zo1 11y ago>"Lower certainty required for a less drastic action." If you consider what happens to male college students if they are accused of rape and found "guilty" to any degree by the university, then you wouldn't say it's a "less drastic action". They get expelled, likely have their reputations and lives ruined. This is the reason we have courts, and it is the reason we don't give judge/execution rights to police.
- cperciva 11y agoWe live under laws on sexual assault that, in large part, were not written with women’s interests in mind. [...] The legal verdict on whether sex is nonconsensual still often rests on the perspective of the alleged perpetrator rather than the experience of the victim. It would be contrary to the principles of fundamental justice to imprison someone who has done nothing wrong. If the alleged perpetrator of an offence has taken all reasonable steps to ascertain consent (and believes that consent exists) then any lack of consent is a tragic mistake, not a criminal offence. As far as I can see, this was written with everybody's interests in mind.
- cmdkeen 11y agoAn example of a law written with the (gender neutral) victim's interest in mind is that of statutory rape - you can contain all the consent you like but if the person is not viewed as being able to give it then an offence is committed. Attempts to move looking for consent towards it being "engaged and enthusiastic" rather than posing a Yes/No question have potential - though it really needs to become a societal thing before a legal expectation. We don't live in the 50s where a woman was expected to lie back and think of England - it shouldn't be for a single partner to take "reasonable steps to ascertain consent", it should be something you are certain of or you stop and make sure. Not just because it's the right thing to do, but also because you're likely to have much better sex...
- cperciva 11y agoAn example of a law written with the (gender neutral) victim's interest in mind is that of statutory rape - you can contain all the consent you like but if the person is not viewed as being able to give it then an offence is committed. Almost. If they were not able to consent (due to age, inebriation, mental illness, etc.) then there was no consent. But if you had a well-founded belief in their ability to consent, then you are not culpable. In Canada it has been held to be unconstitutional for a criminal offence "where it is not open to the accused to exculpate himself by showing that he was free of fault" to have incarceration as a possible punishment; such absolute liability is valid for such things as parking tickets, however. Offences such as statutory rape are instead "strict liability" offences: The prosecution is not required to show intent, but an accused can raise the defence of due diligence. The situation is a bit murkier in the USA, but courts have accepted (see e.g., Kantor) a "good faith" defence even where the legislature has explicitly rejected the mens rea requirement.
- jmspring 11y agoI'll risk down votes...but...this is one of those posts that doesn't fair well here in the sense of balanced conversation...and the comments I have already read...I hope it disappears soon...
- mikekchar 11y agoI'll vote you up mainly because I also wonder a bit about why this article is here. I haven't been around HN for that long, but even a year ago I seem to remember that the articles voted up were mainly technical in nature or related to startups. I have noticed that as discussion boards get more popular they seem to move to being platforms for expressing opinion on political subjects. It may be my imagination, but these kinds of topics seem to be becoming prevalent to the point where I'm seriously thinking of not checking in any more. One may wonder why I am looking at the comments for such a topic, if I am not interested. To be honest, I'm wondering if I am the only such person. Possibly not.
- ryan-allen 11y agoThe comment is topical on HN because of previous incidents of sexual assault allegations at/after tech conferences that were not dealt with by the criminal justice system, but rather by internet mobs and character assassination. I'm of the opinion that this kind of stuff should be reported to the police and be dealt with there, rather than via blog posts and twitter, but the argument "police don't care" seems to trump my position. I live in Australia where the police would give a flying shit, especially if you have corroborating witnesses (the case I am thinking of here on HN did). This all ties in with the "All White Men"/"Women In Tech"/"Male Privilege" microcosm that is not unique to startup web tech, yet has somehow crept in, in the last few years. I like to keep my peas and corn separate on my plate, but others like to mix them together. Oh well.
- zorpner 11y agoSocial/political issues are not orthogonal to technical issues -- in fact, the belief that they are orthogonal is fundamentally conservative (protective of the status quo).
- elcapitan 11y agoNot completely off-topic, but: Is there an api-based HN client/site that can filter out certain topics?
- n72 11y agoI've been mulling over creating such a thing. I would like something just about programming. No valley gossip and other off topic stuff. The biggest problem as I see it is that posts aren't tagged/categorized. I suppose one solution is applying some kind of bayseian filter to the linked article to figure out whether its a programming article or not.
- elcapitan 11y agoYeah, I was contemplating the same. I think for just filtering out, having rule-based blacklisting of keywords would suffice for 95%. Of course it would be much nicer to have classification and then also be able to positively switch between certain categories (say, AI, programming languages etc).
- known 11y agohttp://www.wired.co.uk/magazine/archive/2009/06/features/guilty/viewall http://www.wired.co.uk/magazine/archive/2009/06/features/gui... is better to solve such cases in campus
- ck2 11y agoOf course they do, just like when it occurs in the military. That's why we have a justice system. Anywhere else is a matter of other people trying to exercise political power over outcomes and corrupt the process so it has lesser impact. That's why when you pour money into third party systems like the VA, you weaken the original system (public hospitals) by taking funding away from them that could have helped everyone. Stop making circumventions.
- cm3 11y agoThere should only be one legal system to make rulings, nothing secret, nothing private. The only exception is that private councils or mediators should be opt-out, no strings attached, no questions asked, in order to easily gain access to a real court. This may be unpopular, and I've never been part of the military, so I don't know the drill there, but just as secret courts for the likes of Snowden, there is no place for a military tribunal. And just like a normal court has to rule on parking tickets and serial murders, it shall also rule on war crimes. Think Den Hague as somewhat of an example. I'm perhaps repeating myself, but a secret court nobody can discuss, attend or scrutinize, does not exist in the real world and is something else misusing the existing name (court). I think of it as good marketing for a system that wants to get rid of dissidents and is basically no different than any other show trial under dictatorships. If you cannot defend yourself properly, it's not a trial. If you're sure you're in the right, you have no justification to hide behind closed doors whose existence is denied as well.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]