15 ms·
When Bitcoin Grows Up: What Is Money?
- jbmorgado 11y agoThis seems quite an advertisement for bitcoin. When? and Growing Utility? Bitcoin has decreasing utility since the initial hype. 1. The few companies that accepted it are gradually stoping to support it (Microsoft for instance). 2. We have reached a standstill that shows every bit why highly unregulated systems are difficult to maintain (the miners care only about short term profit and are making bitcoin as a payment system unusable in order to secure short term profit). 3. Even great contributors for the project have come out against it lately explaining the total dystopian mess that is the bitcoin core team and exiting the project.[http://uk.businessinsider.com/bitcoin-has-failed-says-developer-mike-hearn-xt-censorship-2016-1?op=1 http://uk.businessinsider.com/bitcoin-has-failed-says-develo...] 4. Bitcoins are in the hand of a very few people that own massive amounts of them (see blockchain.info top wallets) that seem to be going around trying their best to get a few remaining uninformed people to believe in the system long enough so that they can offload their bitcoins. [http://www.bitcoinrichlist.com/top100 http://www.bitcoinrichlist.com/top100] I see very few people trying to get into bitcoin and a see a great deal of somewhat high profile people trying to keep the hype going just a bit more so that they can recover at least part of their investment in a failed experiment. Still, 2 good things came out of this in the end: the blockchain which is a great tool for a lot of projects; and an eye opener of what can happen for people that want the financial system to have even less regulation.
- brighton36 11y agoBitcoin's use in retail transactions has been steadily growing, and now accounts for around half of the coins mined each day. Need a link?
- jbmorgado 11y agoYes please because even the CEOs of payment systems using bitcoin have come out stating that no one is using bitcoin as a payment system: Taavet Hinrikus, CEO of international-payments app TransferWise, “Bitcoin, I think we can say, is dead. There is no traction, no one is using bitcoin. The bitcoin experiment, I think we can say, is over.” [http://finance.yahoo.com/news/bitcoin-is-dead-says-prominent-fintech-executive-taavet-hinrikus-transferwise-bitcoin-experiment-failed-191800988.html http://finance.yahoo.com/news/bitcoin-is-dead-says-prominent...]
- brighton36 11y agoYeah I don't know where Taavet's numbers are coming from. There's a lot of these studies, here's one of many: http://www.coindesk.com/dark-web-markets-processed-more-bitcoin-than-bitpay-in-2014/ http://www.coindesk.com/dark-web-markets-processed-more-bitc... For as long as the federal government wants to subsidize mining, bitcoin is probably here to stay. I don't see any of the competitors capturing these subsidies.
- emodendroket 11y agoProbably from his payment service? If the sole use of Bitcoin is buying illegal goods on the "dark Web" I think we can say that the various currencies of the world are not facing a serious threat.
- brighton36 11y agoBitcoin is for the underserved. Further, it's subsidized by the premium on fungible value. So it's necessarily not posing a threat to incumbent currencies. Taavet Hinrikus certainly drew from his own failed endeavor. But I don't know how he didn't extrapolate the state of the wider market.
- pg_is_a_butt 11y agotell that to the traces of cocaine on every $100 bill in circulation. you're an idiot.
- btcprint 11y agoYep..I didn't buy anything from newegg with bitcoin today..oh wait. Bitcoin dead for the 130th time. No conflict of interest with Hinrikus making that statement..his motives are purely altruistic - he's looking out for the people. Very intelligent post sir. You seem to be an expert on the fraud that is bitcoin.
- codehalo 11y agoTransferwise competes directly with bitcoin. Were you really expecting him to say otherwise?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Rmilb 11y ago>1. The few companies that accepted it are gradually stoping to support it (Microsoft for instance). Microsoft still accepts it. http://www.cnbc.com/2016/03/14/microsoft-stops-accepting-bitcoin-on-windows-10.html http://www.cnbc.com/2016/03/14/microsoft-stops-accepting-bit... Bitcoin's utility is still valuable for empowering those people stuck with a currency they don't want to hold like Argentina. http://www.economist.com/blogs/schumpeter/2014/06/bitcoin-argentina http://www.economist.com/blogs/schumpeter/2014/06/bitcoin-ar... Edit: Forgot to point out the lack of utility for us in the developed world is very true.
- roywiggins 11y agoQuestion: how does Bitcoin help you get around currency controls? Who is selling Bitcoin for Venezuelan money?
- brighton36 11y agoMost of the people in venezuela with bitcoin trade it for dollars. Typically by routing it to the states, though there is a small local network of exchangers that route paper dollars over the border. However, most of the underserved users are in the states.
- elorant 11y agoI don't know about currency controls but in Greece with capital controls imposed there were a lot of people who turned to Bitcoin to withdraw as much money out of their bank as they could. You can't withdraw more than 420 euros weekly per bank in cash but no one's stopping you from buying as much bitcoin as you like using credit/debit cards.
- emodendroket 11y agoI agree. I was pretty surprised when I saw this in the LRB.
- jhallenworld 11y agoYeah, no mention of inflation... no explanation of bearer bonds... I think a big problem of bitcoin is lack of inflation. Terry Pratchett makes the point in Making Money that lack of inflation is stagnating. You tie the entire society to the willingness of people with old money to spend it. Why would we want that?
- clarkmoody 11y agoOf course people with old money are willing to lend it for a fee.
- msellout 11y agoLending does not necessarily encourage spending. During the housing price collapse crisis, the US government lent money to banks at a cheap rate, expecting to spur more consumer lending. Instead the banks just kept the money under the mattress, so to speak.
- clarkmoody 11y ago> Lending does not necessarily encourage spending. And we're back to the old spending vs saving & investment view of economic growth. I'm squarely in the Austrian camp on this, so I don't really care about spending, especially if it's fueled by government intervention to "spur aggregate demand". I disagree that you have to have inflation, especially when we talking about gold & bitcoin. The past 100 years of economics has been tuned to a fiat money + fractional reserve banking + debt + inflation paradigm. Considering bitcoin within this framework doesn't even make sense, as it will (probably) not be the currency of a whole economy. Also, there is more to the story concerning the Fed's balance sheet [1] and the link to inflation. [1] file:///C:/Users/Clark/Downloads/market-outlook-2014-03-why-the-feds-4-trillion-balance-sheet-isnt-creating-inflation.pdf
- x1798DE 11y agoFYI that is a local link that will only work on your computer...
- homero 11y agoWrong, steam just went live with Bitcoin today https://imgur.com/N2oFy5Y https://imgur.com/N2oFy5Y
- boodm 11y agoStop. He made multiple points that "Steam just went live with Bitcoin today" does not dispute. There is no reason for individuals to buy/sell Bitcoins other than speculation. Drugs were a crutch to the temporary currency. I love the idea, but without a reason to convert my stable dollars to a speculation currency, I will not - nor will others. What would be the point in buying Bitcoin with cash/card only to use it on a service that also accepts cash/card? Steam is a drop in the bucket. The only market that will use Bitcoins is hackers that do not want their main acct banned.
- brighton36 11y agoDrugs are more than just a cruch, it's responsible for more than half of the bitcoin mined every day. It is bitcoin's killer app. People use bitcoin because it's as close as they can get to the dollar.
- pg_is_a_butt 11y agoStop. he made a point saying that the companies that took bitcoin have since stopped (microsoft was only given example)... it was then pointed out that microsoft actually didn't stop... and then the above poster further pointed out new companies are still getting on board (steam) you're an idiot.
- homero 11y agoStable dollars? Dude they lost half their value over 10 years.
- lkbm 11y agoUSD is down 15.3% from ten years ago. That's a far cry from 50%.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "We have reached a standstill that shows every bit why highly unregulated systems are difficult to maintain (the miners care only about short term profit and are making bitcoin as a payment system unusable in order to secure short term profit)." Bitcoin isn't completely unregulated. For example, I believe there's due to be a halving of the new block value soon, to slow down the rate of growth. This may have some negative consequences (such as reducing the number of people who mine for Bitcoin), but on the whole may help to stabilise the value of Bitcoin. http://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-prices-steady-as-subsidy-halving-inches-closer/ http://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-prices-steady-as-subsidy-hal...
- digi_owl 11y agoBitcoin was set up from day one to act as cryptographic gold mining. As such, it attracted a overlapping crowd of goldbugs and cypherpunks. Hilariously while both are highly anti-establishment prone, what seems to have adopted the tech with gutso is Wall Street. And you can't really get more "establishment" than that...
- IsaacL 11y agoI don't think bitcoin has much utility as a means to transfer value, over the existing solutions. It might be a superior means to store value. The theory is that is as the amount of dollars (or any fiat currency) constantly increases, anyone holding large quantities of dollars will want to exchange them for something with a more fixed supply. Usually this is stocks. Oil futures, property, and gold are also used as stores of value. (In countries with weak currencies, people also hoard dollars as a comparatively stronger source of value). So the purely monetarist argument says if there are only 21m bitcoins, and an ever-growing amount of dollars, one would expect that the dollar price of bitcoin will only be stable at 0 or infinity. E.g., either the network crashes and bitcoin becomes worthless, or the dollar collapses and bitcoin reigns supreme. http://nakamotoinstitute.org/mempool/im-hoarding-bitcoins-and-no-you-cant-have-any/ http://nakamotoinstitute.org/mempool/im-hoarding-bitcoins-an... - see here for more on this theory as regards bitcoin. The counter to this argument is that a. despite seeming logical, money supply inflation doesn't always seem to occur in reality. E.g., quantitive easing hasn't noticeably increased consumer prices. b. Bitcoin is volatile, which means it isn't actually a safe store of value. One persuasive argument I heard (from goldbugs) is that bitcoin, having a fixed supply, has no mechanism to stabilise the price, and so booms and busts become self-reinforcing. With gold, on the other hand, the amount mined varies depending on the market price, which smoothes out booms and busts. I'm expecting both gold and bitcoin to increase in value over the next ten years as the EU and US both lurch from crisis to crisis. This will bring a debate over the future of fiat currency into the mainstream, after which things will get very messy and political. (You can't run a welfare state on gold or bitcoin, for one).
- IsaacL 11y agohttp://coindesk.com/price/ http://coindesk.com/price/ It also seems like bitcoin is enjoying a rally, possibly in anticipation of the reward halving in 10 weeks (in theory the reward halving should already be priced in, but the bitcoin market is not the most rational).
- jbmorgado 11y agoSomething as volatile on price as bitcoin is not a superior means to store value. High capital hates risk, so forget about it ever putting their money into bitcoin to store value. Second, you are coming from the assumption that bitcoin is actually a secure and desirable asset to the world at large. Well, it's not, people just don't want into it and they are not getting into it, even the bitcoin exchanges are living with ever decreasing volume since the beginning of 2014. I can also tell you from a purely personal view, that there are very few people left using Localbitcoins anymore. I used to sell quite a few bitcoins there in 2014, now, nobody is interested anymore, there is no one buying.
- unfunco 11y agoThis almost seems lifted from the This American Life episode[1], but brought into the newer context of Bitcoin and other virtual currencies. [1] http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/423/the-invention-of-money http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/423/t...
- ThomPete 11y agoBut is it bitcoin that grows up or the blockhain? I don't think Bitcoing growing up is going to change what money is which is basically a trusted symbol of a certain value. The blockchain on the other hand will change everything from what constitutes a legal entity to how we deal with AI. So basically the question is more, what is value.
- brighton36 11y agoBlockchain without work is just a database, usually a really bad one, designed to take money from vc's.
- mark_l_watson 11y agoThat was a good write up. I am reading Vigna and Casey’s Cryptocurrency book right now. I am actually more interested in block chain tech in general than Bitcoin.
- brighton36 11y agoNo you're not. Blockchain tech is 100% snake oil.
- mark_l_watson 11y agoMay I ask why you think that? It seems to me that there are many good block chain applications, for example, voting systems that are more honest and transparent, virtual distributed (limited profit charter) corporations, etc.
- random28345 11y ago> it is impossible to factorize big numbers. For any number, there is no way of working out if a smaller number divides into it, short of actually doing the calculation. Yeah, the author doesn't understand the difference between the difficulty of factorizing large semi-primes and the elliptic curve discrete logarithm problem. It might be a little error, but lack of understanding of deep technical issues lead directly to specious statements that bitcoin and the blockchain are going to solve world poverty, privacy, fix the economy and neuter the surveillance state. It almost makes me wonder if Bitcoin was a "black-flag" operation to bring out the crypto-anarchist nerds who can't look past the fact that Bitcoin is innovative to see it doesn't work for most people.
- retube 11y ago> It might be a little error, but lack of understanding of deep technical issues lead directly to specious statements that bitcoin and the blockchain are going to solve world poverty, privacy, fix the economy and neuter the surveillance state. If people need to know or understand this stuff bitcoin will never work. Success rests on the what not the how. The end user doesn't care if your website was written in php or node. All he cares about is what it does.
- random28345 11y ago> If people need to know or understand this stuff bitcoin will never work. Success rests on the what not the how. Bitcoin is an inflationary private currency with $10 transaction fees that is mostly used for illegal activity. Its value and success is predicated on the ability to buy drugs and pay ransoms with Bitcoin. > The end user doesn't care if your website was written in php or node. The end user also gets their wallet stolen. So yeah, I'd say that not understanding the basics is critical when dealing with crypto-currencies.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- have_faith 11y agoA thought experiment I like to use when working on a new user interface is to imagine if my mum could use it, or if I could easily explain it to her in a way that made sense. (she represents the average non-technical person) I like to use this thought experiment when imagining Bitcoin adoption. And then I realise that after all the reading I've done and being fairly technically literate I can barely explain Bitcoin to myself in a coherent way. The conclusion I come to with this over-simplified view is that highly technical people are creating a larger divide of Us and Them. This isn't through malice, people are free to create and experiment intellectually as they see fit. But it would be nice if the average persons use-case was considered when planning your utopian money system that you have a head start on in accumulating wealth.
- brighton36 11y agoBitcoin is for the undeserved. It's unbelievably clunkly, but when you have no other choice - you'll learn to use it.
- PeCaN 11y agoExactly. Bitcoin is shit, but let me know when I can anonymously purchase an offshore VPS with anything else. I don't think Bitcoin is going anywhere, but it will perhaps regress to a niche and often illegal market. Alternatively, black markets are very volatile anyway, so moving to a better anonymous currency could happen if a worthy competitor steps up.
- brighton36 11y agoBitcoin will grow to precisely as large as is the vacuum of service for those that need it online. The size of that market might be very small (backpage, gambling, and VPS) or very large (improperly licensed direct to consumer drugs and capital flight) It depends entirely on the regulatory subsidy it receives from federal governments, in the form of credit cards cutoffs.
- Rmilb 11y agoYou make a good point, however I'd like to point out that explaining how money is created through the federal reserve system is no less complicated to the average person. They don't need to understand it, only trust it.
- LAMike 11y agoComparing Bitcoin to startups invented on the Web isn't the right comparison. The Internet is a better comparison for the Bitcoin network.
- jbpetersen 11y agoAt this point Bitcoin looks set in filling the role of the most standard cryptocurrency for some years to come. Now it's more a social experiment than a technological one. Ethereum has stolen the throne when it comes to advancing blockchains as a technology: Turing complete scripting, promising research into proof-of-stake and exponential scaling, etc...
- brighton36 11y agoNo one needs turing complete smart contracts, proof of stake is a perpetual motion pitch, and exponential scaling are just words on paper
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]