3 ms·
There are bad people in every profession. Unfortunately marketing seems to have a higher rate of them, and "growth hacking" is probably at 99%. Anyone who concl
by gk1 11y ago
There are bad people in every profession. Unfortunately marketing seems to have a higher rate of them, and "growth hacking" is probably at 99%. Anyone who concludes a test without sufficient information or consideration for side-effects—or worse, makes a change without testing at all simply because some other growth hacker claims it works—is just eager to claim another win without care for actual business outcomes.
(I say this as a customer acquisition consultant.)
With that said, engineers are notoriously more sensitive to marketing and sales than the general population, and therefore overestimate the negative impact of a marketing or sales tactic.
(I say this as a former engineer.)
Case in point:
I once consulted for a popular NoSQL DB company. When I came along, they were letting anyone download a trial of the DB without providing any contact information—not even an email. So even as more and more people learned about them, the sales team had no leads to sell to.
I set up a test in which a random 50% of people who clicked "Download" would be prompted for their email before the download could start.
We _knew_ the download rates would drop, but that's a tradeoff the company was willing to make to fill up its sales pipeline (and survive). After some discussion and back-of-the-envelope math, we decided that anything less than a 60% drop would be worth it if it meant the sales team got leads.
The test ran for two months. The drop-off rate was just 30%, meaning 70% of those who were prompted for an email went on to download. What's more, the average usage frequency went _up_ for the test group. It turns out the email form was mostly screening out the people with little interest in using the product, who would've only looked at it once or twice and never return.
With all that said, dark patterns and "growth hackers" are a scourge that I wish would go away.
- wldcordeiro 11y agoWhen the goal of the profession (advertising/marketing) is to signal a brand and influence you in ways to override your decision making skills it's no wonder that deceptive patterns pop up.
- gk1 11y agoThat's a rather cynical way of looking at... any profession. "The goal of the app development profession is to take money from phone users." "The goal of software engineering is to control users' computers." And so on... Reductio ad absurdum. You can do this to any profession you choose.
- phantarch 11y agoAdvertising/Marketing is unique in that it doesn't produce any byproducts. It's conceivable, and often the case, that software is developed because it's something useful and fun to do. The same is true for food, rockets, cars, novels, etc. Advertising/Marketing though doesn't exist for any other reason than to promote products and facilitate flow of money.
- tamana 11y agoMarketing is education, and advertising is art, which is fun and useful. You think people work at, say, McDonald's, because they like cooking?
- tamana 11y agoSo you lost 30%*x% of sales, to what benefit? Did it hurt you to have window shoppers growing your mind share? Your story sounds like a classic case of chasing bad metrics like conversion percentage instead of bottom line.
- gk1 11y ago> Did it hurt you to have window shoppers growing your mind share? Yes. The awareness was growing but sales was not keeping up. It was a business decision to focus more on sales and less on awareness. The sales team suddenly had 470% more sales leads to work with than the month before, for the price of 30% low-interest downloaders. I don't see how you can think that would result in _less_ sales.