4 ms·
Oh, completely ignoring the fact that most people who get Type-2 diabetes are genetically predisposed to it and it can also be caused by things like repeated bo
by busterarm 11y ago
Oh, completely ignoring the fact that most people who get Type-2 diabetes are genetically predisposed to it and it can also be caused by things like repeated bouts of pancreatitis and EPI.
But no, let's shame everyone who is fat for being overindulgent.
Maybe having diabetes wouldn't be stigmatized so much if so many Type-1s didn't participate in it as well.
(Non-diabetic here, I have no dog in this fight.)
- forgetsusername 11y ago>most people who get Type-2 Do you have any evidence that it's most? >let's shame everyone who is fat for being overindulgent. Being overweight is tied to many diseases, and costs me a lot of money in health care costs. I have a say in this.
- busterarm 11y agoSkinny people get Type-2 diabetes too. The beautiful thing about figuring out a treatment is that it'll help you if you're Type-2 diabetic and should ease your suffering from the disease regardless of your fitness level.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>Skinny people get Type-2 diabetes too. I didn't say they didn't. The OP said "most" people who get type 2 aren't fat. I merely asked for any evidence. Edit: OP didn't actually say that. But: >Just look at family and ethnic correlation. "People of different racial and ethnic groups are more likely to develop type 2 diabetes, heart disease, and stroke. African Americans, Mexican Americans, American Indians, Native Hawaiians, Pacific Islanders and Asian Americans have a higher risk for these deadly diseases. This is partly because these populations are more likely to be overweight, have high blood pressure and have type 2 diabetes. - See more at: http://www.diabetes.org/are-you-at-risk/lower-your-risk/nonmodifiables.html#sthash.eOkMBpmR.dpuf" http://www.diabetes.org/are-you-at-risk/lower-your-risk/nonm... I'd say "family" is much the same, since eating habits are learned at home. I realize not everyone with Type-2 can help it. I also realize there are many overweight people who can.
- busterarm 11y agoI am the OP and that's not what I said at all. I said that most people who get Type-2 are already genetically predisposed to it. Just look at family and ethnic correlation. (rare) Monogenic diabetes is even hereditary!
- DanBC 11y ago>Being overweight is tied to many diseases, and costs me a lot of money in health care costs. I have a say in this. If you have a say in this you might want to look at effective ways to push your message. We know from lots of research that merely yelling "GO FOR A JOG FATTY" does nothing to help fat people lose weight, and probably makes things harder for them.
- tosseraccount 11y agonothing to help ? While some people respond to a pat in the back, others respond to a kick in the butt.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>We know from lots of research that merely yelling "GO FOR A JOG FATTY" does nothing to help fat people lose weight Sources? That'd be some weird research. Regardless, it isn't my job to "fix" overweight people. They are welcome to their indulgences. I just do want to pay for the ill effects of bad habits. I have a feeling if they were on the hook for related costs, we'd have a different looking society.
- busterarm 11y agoWhy not go to the source then and stop taxpayer subsidy of sugary, addicting foods? It's like we live in a world where all of the inner aisles of the grocery store are stuffed with $3 liters of Vodka and the outer aisles $20 20oz bottles of water and then blame and ridicule people for boozing...
- DanBC 11y ago>Regardless, it isn't my job to "fix" overweight people. It's not your job to make judgemental comments on every single thread that mentions weight, but you never fail to do so.
- vonmoltke 11y ago> Oh, completely ignoring the fact that most people who get Type-2 diabetes are genetically predisposed to it and it can also be caused by things like repeated bouts of pancreatitis and EPI. Considering MonadQueen said "* 60%* of type-2 diabetics" and "Obese Type-2s" (emphasis mine) I wonder where you got the idea that she as "completely ignoring" anything. > But no, let's shame everyone who is fat for being overindulgent. When and why did telling fat people that being fat hurts their health become "shaming"? Why does telling someone that always jump to a presumption of moral judgment?
- busterarm 11y agoNot everyone is fat because of issues of self control. Hypothyroidism, Cushing's syndrome, PCOS, complications of depression. The accusation was that these cases are self-inflicted. It's WAY more complicated than that.
- vonmoltke 11y ago> Hypothyroidism Accounts for about 10 extra pounds on a normal-sized human. Didn't stop me from losing 35 pounds in four months when I was 100 pounds overweight. > PCOS Same as above, assuming PCOS is a cause and not an effect. There seems to be some debate on that in the Ob-Gyn community. > Cushing's syndrome Cushing's is fairly rare, and is usually curable. > complications of depression Yes, depression is a big psychological cause of overeating. Been there. Disentangling the depression from the food is part of the therapy, though. Particularly since it becomes a self-reinforcing cycle where depression begets comfort eating which begets more depression. > The accusation was that these cases are self-inflicted. It's WAY more complicated than that. Always self-inflicted? No. More complicated? Yes. However, except in rare circumstances every underlying condition is treatable or curable. There are synthetic hormones for hypothyroidism. There are cortisol blockers, surgeries, and other treatments for Cushing's. PCOS is incurable but treatable, ironically considering the subject by weight loss. Depression is treatable, though it can be a struggle. Obesity may not be self-inflicted in all cases, but it is almost always resolvable. I'm resolving it, despite having two of the things you listed. You can't just throw your hands up and complain about "conditions" as an excuse to not do anything about the problem. Hell, everything you listed has potentially serious problems if untreated even if it doesn't cause weight gain.