8 ms·
How America can end its war on drugs
- partycoder 11y agoMarijuana was made illegal so the government could raid movements related to war opposition (e.g: hippies) and ethnical minority rights. They wanted an excuse to raid them and they found it in marijuana usage. Then, DEA help comes with infiltrators. Among people sent to combat drugs, there are spies that carry out a large deal of espionage.
- melling 11y agoI believe it was illegal before the 1960s. Do you have any supporting information? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_history_of_cannabis_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_history_of_cannabis_in...
- bryanlarsen 11y agoThe "War on Drugs" was declared in 1971. Here's the source for the 'war on hippies and blacks' meme: https://harpers.org/archive/2016/04/legalize-it-all/ https://harpers.org/archive/2016/04/legalize-it-all/
- eldenbishop 11y agoAgreed, although I suppose LSD regulation could fit the proposed narative; "Weed" has been a political target for far longer than hippy culture. This quote is often attributed to Harry J. Anslinger, the head of the Bureau of Narcotics as far back as the 1930s. “There are 100,000 total marijuana smokers in the US, and most are Negroes, Hispanics, Filipinos, and entertainers. Their Satanic music, jazz, and swing, result from marijuana use. This marijuana causes white women to seek sexual relations with Negroes, entertainers, and any others.”
- jessaustin 11y agoWell! Those seem like valid reasons for marijuana prohibition. Sorry to question the status quo!
- kristopolous 11y agoIf you do a web-search for "marijuana illegal race" you'll see many people having this perspective (including https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_the_War_on_Drugs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_the_War_on_Drugs). I've heard the idea of anti-drug laws as dog-whistle politics (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog-whistle_politics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog-whistle_politics) from a few people. As far as "evidence" here, I don't know what kind is suitable. The 1875 San Francisco Opium Den ordinance law is widely seen as anti-chinese[1]. There's certainly historical people, like Harry J Anslinger (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_J._Anslinger#The_campaign_against_marijuana_1930 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_J._Anslinger#The_campaig...) who justified drug prohibition through racist prejudice. The world isn't black and white of course, and how much race played in this can't be quantified reasonably. However, it's safe to say that it's non-zero. IMHO, all the war on drugs is doing is inflaming a constant Streisand Effect for drug use. Also, I think that notionally, all drugs would be illegal under the current mindset. The reason that some are not has less to do with race I believe than it has to do with the billions of dollars alcohol and tobacco has to carve legislation in their favor.[2] -- 1. California is the starting point for quite a bit of anti-drug legislation. Although now, in 2016, we ostensibly live in relative racial harmony, the state has a notoriously terrible history of regrettable regressive racialized politics. This completely factual history runs up against most people's current perception of the politics of the state. 2. It's worth noting that when you ban the sale of something, in ways you are creating a more "free" (nominally in the pejorative sense) market then if you sunlight it. If you search "marijuana easier than alcohol" you'll see many saying that, for children, pot is easier to buy than beer. Basically by the state not acknowledging the market, they lose out on the opportunity to influence it. Prostitution-based STD transmission being much higher in places of illegal prostitution is another supporting argument for this. And finally, in markets such as liquor and tobacco, competing firms don't resolve dispute through violent armed gangs of militias cartelling territories like is done through gangs and illicit drugs. Can you imagine someone working for PBR murdering someone in the competition to gain market penetration?
- drawkbox 11y agoBut it didn't get really strict until The Controlled Substances Act (1970), which got really crazy in '73 when Nixon basically created the DEA. In 1973 President Richard Nixon's "Reorganization Plan Number Two" proposed the creation of a single federal agency to enforce federal drug laws and Congress accepted the proposal, as there was concern regarding the growing availability of drugs. As a result, on July 1, 1973, the Bureau of Narcotics and Dangerous Drugs (BNDD) and the Office of Drug Abuse Law Enforcement (ODALE) merged to create the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA). On December 1, 1975, the Supreme Court ruled that it was "not cruel or unusual for Ohio to sentence someone to 20 years for having or selling cannabis." It always blows my mind that literally right after the end of alcohol prohibition (1933), marijuana prohibition began (1937 though lighter than the '70s kind of illegal). Basically historical mistakes repeated within literally years of one another. That second error is still not corrected 40+ years later. Criminalizing drug use is absolutely barbaric and has wreaked more havoc than any drug could on society.
- jseliger 11y agoDo you have any supporting information? The parent commenter is overly mood-affiliated, but Eric Schlosser's book Reefer Madness: Sex, Drugs, and Cheap Labor in the American Black Market is good on this topic (http://www.amazon.com/Reefer-Madness-Drugs-American-Market/dp/0618446702?ie=UTF8&tag=thstsst-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957 http://www.amazon.com/Reefer-Madness-Drugs-American-Market/d...). I don't have a copy of it at hand, but making weed and other drugs illegal was wrapped up in racial fear and fears of what become known as counterculture. Wade Davis's One River is about many things, including the ways hallucinogens came to the U.S., how they fit many indigenous religions, and why they're far more legitimate than the US makes them out to be. It's also an adventure story about the exploration of the deep Amazon and other South American rivers.
- dinkumthinkum 11y agoPeople that repeat these "marijuana was made illegal because ..." stories should really get their stories straight. These stories are a dime a dozen and there is truth to many of them but it is more complicated than one thing.
- kafkaesq 11y agoBut it doesn't want to. It's too central to its overall operating ideology -- specifically, the need to have a steady supply of marginalized groups, internal and/or external (the exact definition and composition of which may change over time) to arbitrarily and vindictively punish, in order to demonstrate the state's omnipotence, and keep the rest of the population not completely terrorized, but just moderately and optimally terrorized -- pretty much all the time. (That, and because a significant portion of the population actually still genuinely believes in the need for it. The war on drugs is a complex phenomenon, like any long-ranging civil conflict, with multiple factors behind both its inception and its continuance).
- kogus 11y agoI like how "most people want it" is somehow a secondary reason to a vague theory of Orwellian mind control. People want it. Therefore it is policy. Period. As for why they want it, and the politicians who manipulate their fears... now that, I think, is real.
- nacs 11y ago> a secondary reason to a vague theory of Orwellian mind control A look at parent's username makes it clear why the Kafkaesque reason takes precedence.
- rjbwork 11y agoDepends on what exact policies you're talking about really. Marijuana prohibition especially has been majority-unpopular for a long time, and legalization majority-popular for anywhere from 4-7 years now, depending on the polls you use. Other drugs are definitely more controversial.
- Loughla 11y agoDepending on what polls you use. When you use the type of polls that matter - actual voting, it's the elderly and conservative that vote, so it's the elderly and conservative who have a voice. Hence, marijuana prohibition continues. We're only seeing a lightening of this prohibition because our elderly are more and more from the baby boomer generation - the generation that made smoking pot cool.
- Ericson2314 11y agoThe third option seems clearly the best. Too bad there's little appetite for the distribution of drugs by the state. Either illegality or commercialization seems to be the American way :(.
- tn13 11y agoState getting into business is end of private enterprise. It is not governments job to run business.
- Ericson2314 11y agoUm really? I'm saying there should be either a brutally regulated business or none at all. The government employees in charge of distributing the drugs should in no way be incentivized to distribute more. Markets can only work when the agents (roughly) act in accordance with their interests. I don't want to pedal the fallacy that all drug consumers are addicts, but heavy consumers make up a very large and disproportionate portion of the alcohol (let alone tobacco) industry's sales.
- PopsiclePete 11y agoAmerica can do lots of things. Doesn't mean it will. The prison-industrial complex will not allow falling incarceration rates to eat into its profits - too many executive bonuses depend just the opposite. And not just private prisons - there bloated police budgets and military gear that will otherwise - gasp - go to waste. And don't get me started on the DA's who must always appear "tough on crime" to get re-elected by an ever-fearful populace that is convinced that various boogeymen are planning its demise 24/7/365. But ultimately, it's about money. Always has been. And this country values profits above all else. And if a few more thousand innocent people need to get imprisoned and have their lives destroyed - well, that's a price that we, as a society, are willing to pay. As long as WASP-y suburban white America doesn't feel the pinch. As soon as some unannounced no-knock raid by a SWAT team decked out like it's Fallujah circa '05 busts in and shoots up a bunch of 18-year-old "all-American" kids, prom queens and cheer-leaders and judges' daughters and sons and all. Then and only then will you see a real outcry.
- fucking_tragedy 11y agoIt's funny that "police brutality" entered public discourse right after it became common knowledge that SWAT teams can break into your home unannounced and shoot your dogs without accountability. Never mind that this has been happening for decades to other groups and it ended with dead people and not pets. > As long as WASP-y suburban white America doesn't feel the pinch. As soon as some unannounced no-knock raid by a SWAT team decked out like it's Fallujah circa '05 busts in and shoots up a bunch of 18-year-old "all-American" kids, prom queens and cheer-leaders and judges' daughters and sons and all. Then and only then will you see a real outcry. In my area, an upper class and upper middle class region near a large city, a prescription opioid and heroin epidemic has been sweeping up affluent white children. There is a big difference in how drug related offenses are handled now, the consequences are much less severe and many go home uncharged.
- dsfyu404ed 11y agoI think if the guys kicking down doors over here had the same restraint, rules of engagement and accountability as the guys kicking down doors "like it's Fallujah circa '05" then that would solve a lot of the problem...
- beat 11y agoA serious question... is there anyone reading this who thinks they might become addicted to heroin or cocaine if the drugs were legalized? Is illegality the main reason you don't use hard drugs? More to the point, is there a flaw in the reasoning that legalization would lead to a significant increase in addiction, or social dysfunction due to drug use? After all, alcohol is legal and readily available, but most alcohol users are not alcoholics. This article offers solutions all based on the assumption that legalization and ready availability would drive up addiction to dangerous levels. I'm not at all convinced this is so. I wouldn't start shooting heroin even if it was socially acceptable and only cost as much as a coffee. Neither would most of the people I know.
- dinkumthinkum 11y agoIf you think more access to heroin will not lead to more addicts, you are really unaware of human nature or reality. It definitely will. Now, the question for you is the fact at least it is "free" is better for society and some notion of "freedom" that having more addicts in society. You cannot compare the "addictiveness" of alcohol and heroine, although there happen to be many addicted to alcohol and many alcohol related deaths. I'm not sure why you are not convinced, is it because you don't want to be? There are already tremendous amounts of people addicted to legally obtained opiates, I think this is a terribly naive view. If you believe the only thing that matters is for all drugs to be free then just say that but don't pretend the quantity of addicted decreases because the accessibility goes up. Imagine if you were a gambler, would you really make that bet?
- beat 11y agoI'm not saying the addiction rate would go down if it were legalized. Undoubtedly, it would increase. But there are still questions... how much would the addiction rate increase, and what is the social cost of that addiction, relative to the social cost of our current policy of criminalization? Certainly, violence among dealers would disappear. Liquor stores don't have drive-by shootings to settle their turf. America's absurd incarceration rate would drop tremendously. Incarceration is a major contributor to child poverty. Moreover, a felony criminal record makes it extremely difficult for many adults to find productive work even after serving their time, which begets more crime and more cycling of the system. The incredible militarization of our police forces, the costs of civil forfeiture (which doesn't require a conviction to take someone's property), the racism, the myriad other ways the "War on Drugs" damages our society and our souls - are you certain that an increase in addiction is so profoundly evil that it's worth this price?
- ufmace 11y agoWhat seems funny about this is the idea that we can pick a huge, broad policy, implement it entirely as-is, and leave that be for a while. I don't think that's likely to work. How it'll actually work is gradual change at multiple levels, as we're already seeing with the trend of Marijuana legalization. It's sometimes useful to think in terms of a total broad policy, but we also need ideas for smaller steps to take that we can actually get through various congresses. It seems like the political environment might become more amenable to broader change after considerable small-scale changes and clear changes in public opinion.
- tn13 11y agoWar on drugs is extremely useful for all levels of administration - How else can you confiscate private property without charges or conviction and just share the money among yourself ? https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/04/25/how-oklahoma-cops-took-53000-from-a-burmese-christian-band-a-church-in-omaha-and-an-orphanage-in-thailand/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/04/25/how-o... - How else can you run a multi-billion dollar prison industrial complex ? - How else can you run a surveillance state where state actively encourages to snitch on fellow citizens ? - How else can you create vote banks of Blacks, Latinos and other who need to feel marginalized and victims ?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]