4 ms·
"The thing is that those vulnerabilities are all fixed in Debian as all provided packages are maintained and security fixes are backported." Why can't Canonica
by DyslexicAtheist 11y ago
"The thing is that those vulnerabilities are all fixed in Debian as all provided packages are maintained and security fixes are backported."
Why can't Canonical move these fixes to Ubuntu LTS then? Seems the majority of the work (finding the cause, patching the code) was already done and corrections are sitting on some development branches from other distros.
- rhinoceraptor 11y agoToo busy working on a mobile platform that no one will ever use?
- rlpb 11y agoUbuntu accepts contributed security updates for all packages, including for those in universe. Canonical only pro-actively monitors and pushes security updates for packages in main. Packages in universe gets security updates if and when they are contributed by the community. The "majority of the work" is done by upstream really, not other distros. The remaining work is backporting and QA which is distribution-specific, since the target versions (both of the package being updated and interactions with other packages that might be affected) are not necessarily the same.
- kijin 11y agoThat's the problem with frozen releases. Upstream just moves ahead with new versions, but the distro insists on keeping the same version and only backporting a few patches. This might make sense for core packages that need to present a stable API throughout the lifecycle of an LTS release, but it creates a whole bunch of needless work for maintainers of other packages (who are often the same people who work upstream). Frozen distros are essentially telling them to create a frankenversion of their own program, one for each distro, based on some arbitrary version from several months or even years ago. Until a few years ago, most distros shipped a frozen version of Firefox and only backported important fixes. Ubuntu finally gave up and started shipping new versions of Firefox as soon as Mozilla releases them. I think they need to do the same with most of the packages in "universe", too, including the vast majority of GUI apps. No backporting, just pull the new version, build it, and run some tests. It would save a lot of duplicate work that every upstream is already doing, at negligible cost to the stability of the LTS release as a whole.