3 ms·
> If the owners of capital assets whose worth increases over their lifetime hold them until death, their heirs pay zero capital gains taxes on them. Such “unrea
by barry-cotter 11y ago
> If the owners of capital assets whose worth increases over their lifetime hold them until death, their heirs pay zero capital gains taxes on them. Such “unrealized” gains now account for more than half the value of assets held by estates worth more than $100 million.
Those people also derived no benefit from their wealth. They invested their wealth rather than spending any of it.
> The new work requirements haven’t reduced the number or percentage of Americans in poverty. They’ve just moved poor people from being unemployed and impoverished to being employed and impoverished.
I don't know enough about the Clinton welfare reforms to have an informed opinion but having a job makes it a great deal easier to get another job.
> Six of today’s 10 wealthiest Americans are heirs to prominent fortunes.
So 40% of the 10 wealthiest Americans made their own money? That sounds like the mark of a dynamic economy.
There is an interesting discussion to be had about wealth, poverty, work and the relation between them. This article is not part of it.
- Kliment 11y agoThe typical approach is to get loans with the "unrealized" stuff as collateral, and then deduct the interest payments from tax owed on dividends from said assets.
- bbcbasic 11y agoShhh!
- wz1000 11y ago> Those people also derived no benefit from their wealth. Of course they did. You don't have to spend money to benefit from it. You get access to opportunities people without wealth don't have, most important being loans and such means of raising capital.
- egjerlow 11y agoSo let's discuss here! I think these issues are very interesting, and it's fascinating that there exists views that differ so radically when it comes to how wealth should be redistributed (if it should), and when it comes to whether a given fortune is 'deserved'. It is also fascinating to see how different these views are between, say, Europe and the US. Personally I think Pikettys suggestions make sense if we're trying to truly build a system where the quality and quantity of work performed is as closely mapped to the amount of wealth gained as possible. The nuances are difficult - i.e. how do we deal with the fact that parents want the best education for their children, etc? There must be set some thresholds, and as usual, people will find ways to circumvent those thresholds. Opinions also differ on how big of a role luck plays. I lean towards the view that noone truly 'deserves' wealth because they are all products of their genes and upbringing, so if someone is lazy, is it truly their 'fault'? They lack certain neurological impulses that other people have, but how were they supposed to gain these impulses in the first place? Maybe the only difference between that person and someone non-lazy and 'successful' is that the successful kid once saw a television show about Thomas Edison which the other kid happened to miss. To me it seems obvious that it is these kinds of coincidences that make a person what s/he is. Then we create environments to make certain coincidences more probable, but there are never any guarantees that your child will not become a heroin addict, develop mental issues, or what have you. And I don't think the child is ever truly 'at fault' although we may phrase it as such in order to try to import the correct neurological pathways in our child's brain. And the same is true for the occurrences that lead to massive wealth. In many cases it takes genius (which, as I argued above, is a matter of chance IMO) but as many people will attest, genius is only part of it - you also have to be at the right place at the right time. Given all this it seems unreasonable to me to say that any wealth is 'deserved'. In my view, the only thing that can positively be derived from the concept of wealth is as a motivator for people to innovate. Thus, when wealth becomes something that you inherit, it has less of a sociological purpose.
- coldtea 11y ago>Those people also derived no benefit from their wealth. They invested their wealth rather than spending any of it. I call BS on "any of it". They spent enough -- and not that much is really needed compared to their total wealth -- to live like kings, with several luxury houses all across the country/globe, yachts, private jets, parties and all. >I don't know enough about the Clinton welfare reforms to have an informed opinion but having a job makes it a great deal easier to get another job. It can also make it harder, as you can't go looking for a job when you're overwhelmed working two jobs or 10+ hour shifts (as many of the "lazy" poor do). Besides this all presumes there are jobs for that particular job market -- else, merely looking or at best going from one crappy job to another is not much of an improvement. The more better of (e.g. us programmers) can take months off of work, even start a personal project, and use our savings to get by for a while before starting to look for a new job. The poor play job seeking in a harder mode. Double so when they're fired from the previous one. >So 40% of the 10 wealthiest Americans made their own money? That sounds like the mark of a dynamic economy. Does it really? Seems like it should be comparative -- if 60% done the same in the past, then it would be sounding like the mark of an economy becoming less dynamic...
- slantaclaus 11y ago"to live like kings, homes across the globe, yachts, private jets" <-- this idea of what it is like to be wealthy is one reason the poor stay poor
- coldtea 11y agoWe're not discussing what the poor think it means to be wealthy. We're discussing what people with > $100 million net worth do. And most of them do have all these things.
- ac29 11y agoIf this is your idea of the "1%", prepare to be disappointed. It's more like the 0.001% - a few thousand people in the US. In California, one of the top income states in the US, the top 1% of households grossed $500k+ [1], which is about $250k after taxes (admittedly this is at the low end). This is nice house, nice cars, good schools for kids, and occasional first class trips abroad money, yes, but not yachts and private jets money. [1] http://www.sacbee.com/site-services/databases/article9349178.html http://www.sacbee.com/site-services/databases/article9349178...