4 ms·
That's a very insightful thought. I do find it interesting how people are coming to the idea that local governments are where new ideas are formed, but degrade
by unethical_ban 11y ago
That's a very insightful thought.
I do find it interesting how people are coming to the idea that local governments are where new ideas are formed, but degrade the concepts of States' rights or smaller federal intervention as racism whenever it doesn't suit a liberal agenda.
- infosample 11y agoBecause "States' rights" has historically been used as a dog-whistle for racism, segregation, and voter suppression. Moreover, the article is referring to city/local government which is different from the state. I don't see how conflating local innovation with state oppression is a liberal agenda. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/States%27_rights#States.27_rights_as_.22code_word.22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/States%27_rights#States.27_rig...
- stcredzero 11y agoused as a dog-whistle Such an overloaded term. It is also used to mean "something only some can hear, but I can't." States have also been a source of innovation. California, Oregon, and Washington were noted as "bellwether" states, whose pioneering policies were sometimes adopted by other states. California's pollution/vehicular laws have been a force for positive change and innovation in the auto industry.
- Bjorkbat 11y agoYou could argue that it was the cities that gave these states such pioneering policies. Urban California is a pretty liberal place, but rural California really isn't. Granted, I have my doubts it would be as conservative as the Deep South, but if Central California were a state of its own they'd probably repeal a number of these "pioneering" laws that cut into farm profits. I would argue that states with a liberal voting record also likely have a majority urban population of registered voters, even if we're talking about a large state with plenty of land being used for natural resources.
- NotSammyHagar 11y agoCan you expand on your thoughts? I see "state's rights" as a call to get supporters when the state might do something that someone wants, and there's no real substance or distinguishing feature that lets us understand what is or is not a state right. It just appears to be a way to justify doing what you want. If you don't want something to happen, then you claim something is not a state right.
- marcoperaza 11y agoThey're talking about American politics. "State" is referring to the 50 cosovereign subdivisions of the United States. "State's rights" refers to politics that defends the rights of states, rather than the national (aka federal) government, to set policy in certain areas.
- NotSammyHagar 11y agoI am an american person. I was referring to the fact that conservatives use state's rights to argue for things they want that the federal govt wants to do differently, but argue against states rights for the things that they want. So I don't see any real clarity in what people argue is or is not state's rights.