2 ms·
Birds are definitely limited by aerodynamics, biology just says well screw this it ain't worth it because life forms are limited by the amount of energy availab
by dogma1138 11y ago
Birds are definitely limited by aerodynamics, biology just says well screw this it ain't worth it because life forms are limited by the amount of energy available to them.
If we take the heaviest flying bird today it has a wing span of about 3M and a total wing surface of slightly under 1 m/sq the Quetzalcoatlus you've mentioned has a wing span of about 15m and a total wing surface of about 35 m/sq, back of the envelope math means that about a mass increase of about 12 times over the Kori (heaviest bird capable of flight) results in about 30-35 times the increase in lift surface (and we are still unclear if the damn thing was even capable of powered flight or not).
And again you are missing the point Solar Impulse can lift about 1000 lbs of w/e if you want to scale it up either increase the thrust by 50 or increase your lift surface by 50 to get to that 50,000 lbs cargo you want.
If we ignore load baring and drag than 3 Solar Impulse aircraft combined could lift 3000 lbs that's it.
We can argue about this till the sun doesn't shine it won't change the fact that solar flight will never be a viable option for cargo transport.
But it can replace other things, things that for example are well in range of the 1000 or lbs of payload that any reasonable designed solar aircraft could carry - surveillance, communications, weather and atmospheric monitoring equipment etc.
They could potentially replace satellites, and increase the endurance of both military and civilian drones considerably but no one is looking at them to carry cargo because it's simply silly.
Also if you want to move 50,000 lbs today by air it usually won't take less than 6 days, the only thing you can really ship overnight are small things that end up going on commercial flights not cargo flights.
And while it's also true that a container ship can take 21-30 days from say China to the US about 14-15 of those days are spent in local transit and loading, the sailing it self a cargo ship can do within 10 days of good weather with the average being probably closer to 12 or so days due to weather and fuel economy.
- Retric 11y agoThe problem with shipping by boat is the variability. Your just in time supply chain needs to assume a ~6 weeks or longer in case of a strike etc. Variability goes down a little when you have more boats going to more ports. As a final point on energy larger birds can do generally have a slower metabolism. They simply need less energy per lb to maintain flight and can travel longer distances on smaller per pound energy budgets. Not that I think anything could convince you, but look into glide ratios and optimum glide speeds. If A and B have 15:1 ratios and B glides at 2x the speed that's more efficient.
- dogma1138 11y agoNo matter how many tricks you play eventually it comes to 2 things. Amount of thrust (limited by solar power) * lift surface limited by materials and physics, it all boils down to math. http://www.ajdesigner.com/phpwinglift/wing_lift_equation_force.php http://www.ajdesigner.com/phpwinglift/wing_lift_equation_for... So I really don't see any way of a solar power aircraft which uses aerodynamic lift getting of the ground even in the most perfect unattainable conditions.
- Retric 11y agoA they already built a solar aircraft and B they say it can scale to 50x the size and carry 50 people. IMO, that would be more useful for lifting cargo vs people. Second wing area and lift is related to velocity (not power) right before you stall outside of that it's a looser connection. Velocity is indirectly related to power in steady level flight based on drag. Drag in level flight is a function of weight, shape, altitude, and velocity. Economicly I don't think this is a good idea. Physically it seems possible with cheaper and more efficemt solar cells it might make this more reasonable up to a point. Especially if they can boost altitude and thus speed.
- dogma1138 11y agoYes they've built an airplane with the wing span of a 747 and a lower lift than a Cessna. Please show me where they stated that they can scale it 50x the size, that would mean it will have a wing span of 10000 feet, that's 10 Eiffel towers....
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Retric 11y agoThe article says electric aircraft holding 50 people in 50 years. Granted, not pure solar aircraft but electric. 50x the power takes 50x the surface area and 7.1x the length / width. Or less than that with a lifting body approach. Or significantly less than that if it's daytime only.