7 ms·
Amateur ISIS Investigator Ends Up in Prison
- ghshephard 11y agoThis guy was really asking for trouble when he went ballistic on an FBI agent, from the article: he sent an agent 80 increasingly overheated messages in 10 days. In one, he declared, “Just remember whatever ends up happening to you … You deserved it,” and added an expletive.
- BtM909 11y agoWhich was the major reason to arrest him in the first place.
- tyingq 11y agoValid reason to arrest him. Not a valid reason to sit in prison for 14 months, with no due process, trial, etc. Edit: Also, to me, the context is fairly clear that the "threat" of "whatever ends up happening to you" is talking about the potential embarrassment or career consequences to the agent around ignoring advice that might save some hostage. He was (incorrectly) convinced he was trying to save lives, and frustrated that nobody would take him seriously.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoThat's why you just do whatever law enforcement says and be kind and deferential to them at all times. They're literally above the law.
- StavrosK 11y agoNot sure if sarcasm.
- funkyy 11y agoNot sure if using Reddit style "questioning" or "asking" is right thing to do on HN.
- bitJericho 11y agoHaving experience with the legal system, definitely not sarcasm.
- Ao7bei3s 11y agoDepends on the country.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoNo it's not sarcasm. Law enforcement privileges tend to breed abuse.
- StavrosK 11y agoI meant more the part that we should be deferential, rather than try to influence politicians to make law enforcement not be above the law.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoI don't think you should be deferential to politicians, not legislators anyway. I think you should be deferential to law enforcement. If you're talking about current term executive branch politicians then I guess I would include them too if they are in law enforcement.
- mtgx 11y ago> Valid reason to arrest him. Not a valid reason to sit in prison for 14 months, with no due process, trial, etc. I remember when the NDAA passed for the first time in the budget bill, Obama said it would not actually be used to keep people indefinitely in prison with no trial. In reality, the government has already been doing that to people, even before the NDAA passed, and now the NDAA just represents legal cover. Kind of how they repealed the law that said the US government can't use propaganda on US soil, and now they can also do that in one way or another (either through the MSM or through Internet psyops).
- tptacek 11y agoNo portion of the detainee provisions of the NDAA were at play in this case: * Lopez wasn't part of al Qaeda or involved in the 9/11 attacks. * Lopez wasn't apprehended by the US military. * Lopez wasn't detained "under the laws of war". * Lopez wasn't held in military custody.
- tptacek 11y agoJust to be clear: he was in prison for a portion of his detention, after being arrested for making the threat and being informed by his mother that he was armed. He was then moved to involuntary psychiatric commitment. The article is unclear on the amount of time he spent in each kind of detention, but gives the strong impression --- by marking time in terms of psychiatric evaluations --- that most of it was spent in psychiatric inpatient detention.
- tyingq 11y ago>>most of it was spent in psychiatric inpatient detention Apparently, mostly because extremely important information needed to make a serious psychological evaluation wasn't made available to the medical people doing those evaluations. See this image from the article: https://static01.nyt.com/images/2016/04/24/us/24salesman-psych/24salesman-psych-articleLarge.jpg https://static01.nyt.com/images/2016/04/24/us/24salesman-psy... They finally got the information on his 3rd eval, which is what led to his release. All charges were dropped at that point.
- tptacek 11y agoMaybe. But the documents make a pretty compelling case for mental illness, because they also indicate that he expected to talk to the President about freeing Kayla Mueller, and became unhinged after she died. Lopez's grandiose claims about his connections to ISIS were in fact fictional --- it looks like he was being set up for an advance-fee scam. None of this is meant to excuse the criminal mental health care system in the US, which is, I think, criminal. I think it took over a year in Lopez's case because pretty much nobody gives a shit about people in this system.
- Hondor 11y agoIt always find it surprising that Americans say they have the right to own guns but whenever something else goes wrong, owning or carrying a gun seems to cause massively greater punishment. Shouldn't it be illegal to discriminate against people based on gun ownership? Otherwise it's kind of restricting people's freedom to own guns.
- blowski 11y agoOff topic, but why does the NYT website have a 'show full article' button (on mobile at least)?
- hellojason 11y agoGuessing, but probably to get more accurate engagement stats. It would be better to assume a user has read most or all of the article if they clicked that button. Maybe also a way of determining if the introductory paragraphs were written in an engaging way, because they determine whether I will continue reading or not.
- tlrobinson 11y agoSeems like monitoring the scroll position would have the same (or better) effect.
- mattmanser 11y agoIt has a paywall so when you hit the limit of 10(?) free views that no longer works.
- blowski 11y agoOK that makes the most sense - I've just never seen the paywall.
- mik3y 11y agoIt's a common "recirc" technique (recirculation). All that crap after the button/article? If you skim the first paragraph and are not interested, they want you to go there rather than press "back".
- a3n 11y agoMan who made a vague threat against FBI agent is disappeared for 14 months.
- tptacek 11y agoI know this is just a drive-by comment, but on the off chance you don't actually know the difference between unjust detention and "disappearing", I'll spell it out: * Lopez was apprehended in daylight at his house by uniformed police acting on an arrest warrant. The disappeared are snatched by anonymous or covert paramilitaries. * Lopez was taken to the NY Metropolitan Corrections Center. The disappeared are tortured and killed. * Lopez' family was aware of his location throughout his ordeal. The families of the disappeared never know that, which is why they're called "disappeared". * Lopez was released. The disappeared usually stay disappeared.
- a3n 11y agoYou're right, it was an exaggeration, to highlight the fact that he was held and not tried for fourteen months, and charges were only dropped when an evaluator finally got access to evidence that should have been available from the beginning. How much longer would he have been disappeared in plain sight if the government were able to suppress evidence/information even longer? (And yes, I know the difference.)
- tptacek 11y agoMaybe. But I don't think that's what happened. What I think happened was, the guy was involuntarily committed through the criminal justice process, and so like everyone admitted to psychiatric inpatient care --- under any circumstances --- he was stuck until the facilities got sick of him or he lucked into a doctor that actually gave a fraction of a shit about him. Unfortunately for him, private psychiatric inpatients are there on the dollar of their insurance companies, and so there's an implicit clock ticking on their stay. The same is not the case for the utterly unaccountable state-run involuntary mental health care system.
- 11y ago
- fyirt 11y agoGuy was clearly unstable and in over his head. Not against the law mind you, but his mental health was deteriorating (by his own mothers admission) and he began threatening FBI agents. The 14 months in prison without due process could have been expanded on more in the article, there was next to no info regarding that situation which leaves the reader with a fair few unanswered questions.
- tptacek 11y agoWhat's there to say? Involuntary mental health commitment in the US is a disaster. The doctors operating state-run mental health prisons are overworked and underqualified. And, if you've had run-ins with the doctors operating private mental health hospitals, you know that's saying something! Lopez was apparently armed and, from the picture painted in this article, pretty much unhinged. Something needed to be done. But the only "something" the criminal justice system has in its bag of things is, by pretty much all accounts everywhere, a total debacle. Are things better in other countries? Who's doing this well? What does Norway do?
- zymhan 11y agoThere is next to no funding in the US for public mental health. We no longer have aslyums, because those were awful infringements on people's rights, regardless of whether or not they're sane. But we never replaced those centralized mental institutions with the community psych care that was necessary to make up for the gap. So now many of those same people live on the streets and/or in and out of jail and hospitals because of a lack of long-term support.
- torpfactory 11y agoMy wife works as a nurse in the Emergency Department of a hospital in Washington state, which has a shortage of mental health hospital beds available for patients. They are forced to board these patients in the Emergency Room for days at a time. The rooms often have no windows and are not set up for long term care. If the patient wasn't crazy before coming in, they will be by the time they leave. The stories she has make my engineering job look like some kind of kindergrten. Patients trying to eat their own feces, trying to hurt staff members. Just remember techie folks that there is a whole other world out there where very bad and difficult things do happen.
- user24 11y agoHoly Moly. > Without access to his records, prison psychologists assumed his tales of talking to Islamic State members were fiction, symptoms of a mental illness that made him incompetent to stand trial. Prosecutors sought a hearing to decide whether he should be forcibly medicated.
- tamana 11y agoThis is sadly common. There was a famous case where a woman in a car accident was committed to a psychiatric prison because they didn't believe that Obama followed her on Twitter. Psychs believe that anyone who claims to know famous people is insane, just like cops believe everyone they encounter in the beat who looks sketchy is a criminal. Psychiatry is petty in the same way as police: anyone who seems "better" than the official is taken down a notch using the official's power.
- themartorana 11y agoIs this more of the justice system (and doctors, now) not understanding the Internet at all? We know I could go read jihadist website propaganda tonight if I wanted to, but I understand the true nature of the wealth of information I can access from my own home. It's scary when a elderly judge doesn't understand the Internet. It's worse when that lack of understanding runs through the entire criminal justice system. Then you really are screwed.
- cubano 11y agoI found the most surprising aspect of the article was the guy absolutely refusing to believe that his Skype contact was phony and trying to scam money from him, even when the very law enforcement he so trusted to help "save the hostages" 1/2 way across the world told him so. I wonder what sort of physiological issues must be present, and why, that allows someone to be sucked so deeply into believing the fantasy of the situation, even in the face of overwhelming evidence, and how that very thing exists in so many other decisions that confront people.
- faster 11y agoI just finished a book[1] that explains this pretty clearly. Dissonance between reality and a person's self-image (i.e. "I am difficult to fool") is often 'resolved' in favor of the more important factor, which is the person's self-image. So they deny reality. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Mistakes-Were-Made-But-Not/dp/B003HFFIUM/ http://www.amazon.com/Mistakes-Were-Made-But-Not/dp/B003HFFI...
- cubano 11y agoThat look super interesting...just bought it in fact. Thanks for the info.
- greenyoda 11y agoThat book looks very interesting, but note that you link to an old edition. The new edition is here: http://www.amazon.com/Mistakes-Were-Made-but-Not/dp/0544574788 http://www.amazon.com/Mistakes-Were-Made-but-Not/dp/05445747... This URL also lets you preview the book with a "Look Inside" link.
- Jugurtha 11y agoWhatever the psychological issues he had, I suspect they were coupled with the so frequent movie plot of "I'm right and the stupid FBI doesn't believe me". So many movies portray this image of the clueless law enforcement agencies and the guy who, although has never heard of intelligence analysis and is mentally unstable, somehow ends up being right and everyone else ends up appologizing to him, becomes a hero, and the President honors him. It sounds absurd but it's exactly what's happened here, down to the attitude of the FBI agents. Some people watch a James Bond movie and start acting like him, some even apply for a job in the intelligence domain (of course I suspect their names are diligently saved and they're prohibited from ever working in such an unforgiving field). What irritates me isn't that an outsider took it upon himself to right a wrong by taking as a hobby something people do for a living and many die while doing so... what irritates me is that: Of course this would happen, what would one expect? The problem is how was this allowed to happen. No fail-safe mechanisms to make it impossible to go directly from selling Toyotas to jail. So many red flags that should have triggered each a different action: He wasn't aware of his own condition and his own delusion. He was mentally unstable, unknowingly incompetent in what he pursued which made him a fanatic in a way, armed, threatening tone ("Any attempt to arrest me will be treated as a hostile act"? It's a miracle he's still alive), and had a seemingly lousy lawyer who was confused about what his job was (to get his client out, not to diagnose his mental health). With all that, add the fact he wasted agents' time and interfered with their jobs (every moment they spent on him, there was real work not being done; lives were at stake. Not only that but the worst he could do is add a parameter, a degree of freedom, to something already hard to do). The question still is: why was this allowed to go this far? Why didn't the family seek help (the guy 'quit his job' because of his online activities). Whatever the psychological issues he had, I suspect they were coupled with the so frequent movie plot of "I'm right and the stupid FBI doesn't believe me". So many movies portray this image of the clueless law enforcement agencies and the guy who, although has never heard of intelligence analysis and is mentally unstable, somehow ends up being right and everyone else ends up appologizing to him, becomes a hero, and the President honors him. It sounds absurd but it's exactly what's happened here, down to the attitude of the FBI agents. Some people watch a James Bond movie and start acting like him, some even apply for a job in the intelligence domain (of course I suspect their names are diligently saved and they're prohibited from ever working in such an unforgiving field). What irritates me isn't that an outsider took it upon himself to right a wrong by taking as a hobby something people do for a living and many die while doing so... what irritates me is that: Of course this would happen, what would one expect? The problem is how was this allowed to happen. No fail-safe mechanisms to make it impossible to go directly from selling Toyotas to jail. So many red flags that should have triggered each a different action: He wasn't aware of his own condition and his own delusion. He was mentally unstable, unknowingly incompetent in what he pursued which made him a fanatic in a way, armed, threatening tone ("Any attempt to arrest me will be treated as a hostile act"? It's a miracle he's still alive), and had a seemingly lousy lawyer who was confused about what his job was (to get his client out, not to diagnose his mental health). With all that, add the fact he wasted agents' time and interfered with their jobs (every moment they spent on him, there was real work not being done; lives were at stake. Not only that but the worst he could do is add a parameter, a degree of freedom, to something already hard to do). The question still is: why was this allowed to go this far? Why didn't the family seek help (the guy 'quit his job' because of his online activities). Prevent instead of mitigate.
- Hondor 11y agoPeople are saying he was "unhinged" or mentally ill, but it sounds like he was simply sucked into an online scam. That happens to normal people all the time (even professionals through "whaling"). If you believe your scammer, and he tells you about freeing hostages, and those stories corroborate with what you hear on the news, then what normal person wouldn't get agitated and emotional? That doesn't sound like mental illness, it sounds like normal reaction to finding out that the one person who could save some hostages is refusing to cooperate. Don't forget his friend was actually killed in Afghanistan so he's got some genuine emotional connection to these troubles already, making the other stories easier to believe perhaps. What would you do if you believed you had a way to free a hostage and the FBI just told you to get some sleep? When the hostage was killed, what would you say to that FBI worker? Normal mentally healthy people would get angry and obsessive when they believe they're being impeded from saving lives. I've seen more extreme reactions for far lesser problems.
- gnoway 11y agoI would consider getting some sleep. I agree with your point about the emotional involvement, but honestly, this is an unemployed former car salesman and restaurant manager. For him to think he's legitimately negotiating release of hostages over twitter and skype... sure, maybe, but it falls into the 'requires extraordinary evidence' bucket for me.
- DanBC 11y agoIf you live in England and think this kind of psychiatric detention needs stronger controls you might be interested in looking at becoming a "Mental Health Act Manager", or "Hospital Manager". This is often a voluntary position that looks at some detentions under the Mental Health Act and sometimes orders the de-sectioning of people detained under section. http://www.mentalhealthcare.org.uk/mental_health_act http://www.mentalhealthcare.org.uk/mental_health_act https://www.rethink.org/resources/m/mental-health-act https://www.rethink.org/resources/m/mental-health-act https://www.rethink.org/living-with-mental-illness/mental-health-laws/discharge-from-detention https://www.rethink.org/living-with-mental-illness/mental-he... In England it's rare to become a mental health inpatient. Only about 8% of the people getting care from mental health trusts ever go in-patient. Some of that is lack of beds (especially for children), but mostly it's because hospitals are sometimes harmful (This is true for physical health too) and people should get better care from "Crisis Resolution and Home Treatment Teams" (for short term emergency care) and community teams (for longer term recovery and rehabilitation). But if you think it's something that might happen you should probably think about advanced directives, and sorting out who your "nearest relative is", and getting a crisis plan set up.
- pinaceae 11y agowell, the contrast is all the other mentally unhinged, armed men in the US that do not get taken off the street and then go on a shooting rampage - recent example being ohio. pick your poison. seen this liberal approach in europe with a neighbors daughter, paranoid schizo. threatened her mother with a knife, admitted to hospital, meds, meds work, she clears up, gets asked if she wants to leave, yes, is home, stops taking meds, goes psycho again, knife comes out. rinse repeat, for years. because yes, let's give mentally unstable people the choice over life or death decisions.
- fudged71 11y agoContacting fake ISIS members and FBI agents is one thing. Really sad that he was contacting american hostages families.