4 ms·
> Then, in one of 2015’s greatest moments of schadenfreude, especially for those who care about the widespread availability of quality healthcare and hip hop, S
by mirimir 11y ago
> Then, in one of 2015’s greatest moments of schadenfreude, especially for those who care about the widespread availability of quality healthcare and hip hop, Shkreli was arrested by the FBI for fraud. Alas, the FBI left Once Upon a Time in Shaolin in Shkreli’s New York apartment.
So why doesn't the FBI take the bloody thing, and auction it? They sold DPR's Bitcoin, no?
- onewaystreet 11y ago> So why doesn't the FBI take the bloody thing, and auction it? Shkreli hasn't been found guilty of anything yet (and he put up his $45 million E-Trade account to secure his bond).
- amock 11y agoWhy would the FBI confiscate and sell his property? Just because he was arrested doesn't mean he's guilty, and even if he his that doesn't give the FBI the right to confiscate his property.
- mirimir 11y agoWell, they sold DPR's Bitcoin before he was convicted. Cops do that. It's partly how they fund themselves. I was responding to the precious "maybe we'll never know" aspect of the article. I'm not saying that civil forfeiture is legitimate. Far from it. But it's pretty common. Edit: Also, the article basically suggests burglary as an option. So ...
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoTo which DPR agreed.
- mirimir 11y agoReally? That I did not know. Why? Plea deal?
- kevinnk 11y agoIn his pre-trial, Ross denied ownership[1] of the server that the coins were found on (for obvious reasons - the server also ran the Silk Road). Since no one claimed ownership, the FBI was free to auction them. [1] This actually turned out to be a major blunder on the part of the defense. See http://www.wired.com/2014/10/silk-road-judge-technicality/ http://www.wired.com/2014/10/silk-road-judge-technicality/
- jessaustin 11y agoEh, do we all really believe the judge on that one? Sure, if he had claimed ownership, then the unreasonable search objection wouldn't have fallen on that point. Except, she eventually would have found some other reason why all FBI activities constituted "reasonable" search. Conviction rate in federal court is over 90%, and for many of those cases only the prosecutor assigned even gives a shit. Everybody in the federal system, FBI, prosecutors, judges, etc. wanted this guy's head on their wall, so no legal argument was going to keep him out of FPMITAP. Ross was fucked from the moment the beast knew his name. For future projects like Silk Road, a basic part of the security plan will be to set up Ross look-alikes to take the fall, because USA-Justice is not something you can just design around. Once the beast has a scent, it will be fed, by someone.
- gwern 11y agoThere were two sets of Bitcoins. The bitcoins found on the SR1 server, which the Ulbricht defense team decided to not claim any interest in (which in retrospect seems like a serious legal blunder per the other comment), and the bitcoins found on Ulbricht's laptop in SF and his backup devices etc. The SR1 server bitcoins could be sold off without any trouble, but Ulbricht's bitcoins were in legal jeopardy as they might have been the proceeds of drug trafficking and not legitimate Bitcoin trading activities. As it happens, Ulbricht's bitcoins also got sold off as part of a mutual agreement between Ulbricht and the government to insulate them against the possibility of Bitcoin going to zero during the lengthy legal proceedings. (Neither party would be happy if terrible things happened to Bitcoin and it slowly went to zero, but they couldn't sell or do anything about it because the bitcoins were frozen.)
- c22 11y agoThe nice thing about cash is they can claim it was obtained illegally and it's often very hard to prove it wasn't. There's no reason to believe this album was obtained illegally (and in fact, abundant evidence that it wasn't.)
- mirimir 11y agoYes, but he did buy it.
- c22 11y agoA time-honored method for legally obtaining things...
- dave2000 11y agoIf you buy something stolen you don't own it; you've just broken the law and wasted your money. If it can't be proved you knew it was stolen then you've just wasted your money. This is how it is in the UK at least.
- icebraining 11y agoBut nobody claims the album was stolen, why are you bringing it up?
- mirimir 11y agoOK, in https://medium.com/fluxx-studio-notes/the-first-rule-of-pricing-is-you-do-not-talk-about-pricing-1875caa39b89#.de5evml08 https://medium.com/fluxx-studio-notes/the-first-rule-of-pric... I see this: > He bought the only copy of Wu Tang Clan’s album “Once Upon a Time in Shaolin” for $2m, then said “I’ll probably never even hear it. I just thought it would be funny to keep it from people.” That's why! Edit: He probably also considered it funny (or at least, ironic) that people died because they couldn't afford Daraprim.