4 ms·
There should be no such thing as a default sub for new accounts. Users should pick what they want when they sign up.
by unethical_ban 11y ago
There should be no such thing as a default sub for new accounts. Users should pick what they want when they sign up.
- throwaway40483 11y agoI think you should be careful with this claim. This is what got Twitter into trouble.
- basch 11y agono way. /r/all is terrible the defaults are important because they let people use the site before they decide they want to sign up
- unethical_ban 11y agoI think defaults are necessary when someone is not logged in. When an account is created, suggestions are given based on interest, such as it is with meetup.com - News, politics, sports, local, tech, animals, humor, etc. are recommended in their own categories, and people sub as desired.
- basch 11y agoI HATE it when I sign up for a newsreading service and the first thing it asks me is to pick topics I like. I just want to try out the product / interface. Don't road block me with some set of tiles and vague "business, technology, fashion, music" screen. Reddit has it right that a new account should have some baseline. Their discovery tools however are not intuitive, if you can even call them tools.
- unethical_ban 11y agoThe designation of a sub as a default on reddit dooms it to be trashy and political, and reddit admins would never come out and say "avoid these awful communities, go find your local reddits!". So it goes.
- basch 11y agoit's a catch 22 have defaults with strict moderation, and alienate newcomers have defaults with loose moderation, and the voting algorithm will favor the most superficial, bitsized posts.
- kwgardner 11y agoThis is actually what we're doing on Imzy! We ask people their interests and then show them what communities they may want to join based on that. Then they choose which ones they want to join. Hopefully by doing that, we'll decrease the circlejerking and increase the quality of conversations, since people only get there if they actually care about that topic and want to talk about that thing.
- matt4077 11y agoSorry for posting in this thread, but I think you might want to know about this bug: I have a (completely valid) .coffee domain and you're actually the first to refuse my e-mail address. It's not just valid, it's got coffein! All the best!
- kwgardner 11y agoOh, interesting. I'll pass this along to our developers. Thanks for letting me know, and sorry about that!